THE STORY
Top secret agent James Bomb was about to go out on a very important mission to try to stop the evil schemes of dastardly Dr. Whoa. Before embarking on his mission, James Bomb went to the agency’s top secret lab to find out what kind of customized sports car he was getting.
“This automobile is state-of-the-art in fighting evil,” gushed with pride the scientist who customized the sports car. “It has everything you need…a machine gun, a rocket launcher, a grenade launcher, and even a torpedo launcher, in case you end up near the water.”
“I looks ingenious,” said James Bomb. “Now show me how they work.”
“Well, therein lies the problem,” sighed the scientist. “Because the sports car is so sleek, there was no room for the bullets, the grenades, the rockets or the torpedoes. I was able to squeeze in all the launchers, but none of the things they launch.”
“What, then, am I supposed to do?” asked Mr. Bomb.
The scientist replied, “In the glove compartment, there is a small pistol which shoots little BB pellets. I’m sorry, it was all I could find at the last moment.”
“Hrrummph,” murmured the disappointed Mr. Bomb. “Well at least I can hope to find some pretty women on the mission.”
THE ANALOGY
Just as in the spy world, there are important missions in the business world. It may not be the dastardly schemes of Dr. Whoa you are fighting, but there are forces out there that can seriously damage the future of your business unless you stop them.
They can give you a fancy mission and they can give you a fancy title (like top secret agent). They can even give you what looks like a powerful platform from which to do battle (like that sports car). However, if you have no bullets or rockets or grenades, you will lose that battle. All you have to look forward to is nabbing a little beauty on the way down.
I think a similar situation is occurring for many of those placed in the Chief Marketing Officer position, known as the CMO. They have been given a fancy mission: to protect the brand long-term and to help it grow over time. They have even been given the fancy title of CMO (they get to be part of the “C”-suite). And as part of the C-suite, they have what appears to be a powerful platform from which to operate.
Unfortunately CMO’s, as a whole, appear to be failing in their task. I think a lot of it is because they do not possess all the tools to get the job done (their version of grenades and bullets). They can make some beautiful ads on the way down, but that’s about it.
THE PRINCIPLE
In last week’s issue of Advertising Age magazine (dated July 9, 2007), one of the cover stories was about a study of the effectiveness of CMOs. The study, by marketing professors Pravin Nath at the LeBow College of Business and Vijay Mahajan of the University of Texas at Austin, looked at 167 companies over a five year period.
What they concluded was the following: CMOs on top management teams don’t have any effect on a company’s financial performance. Let me repeat that: CMOs on top management teams don’t have any effect on a company’s financial performance.
This study will be published in the January 2008 edition of the Journal of Marketing. To quote Advertising Age, “Pay attention CMOs: If you’ve been fighting for more influence with top management, hide this publication—now.”
I guess then it should be no surprise that in a different article which appeared last year in Advertising Age, it said that the average tenure for someone in the CMO position continues to drop and is now less than two years. It appears that boards and CEOs are not waiting for this study. They are already frustrated and have taken to canning the CMO.
What’s going on here? What is the problem? I think the problem has a lot to do with the principle of Expectations and Capabilities. In other words, if people’s expectations exceed your capabilities to meet them, you are bound to fail. It’s like super secret agent James Bomb. He is expected to defeat the evil Dr. Whoa, but his capabilities are limited to a little BB gun.
The typical expectations for a CMO are to:
1) Increase Sales Near-Term
2) Increase the Business Even More Dramatically Long-Term
3) Protect and Strengthen the Brand over Time
In many businesses, the CMO is pretty much the only one in the C-suite with a mandate to focus primarily on the long-term interest of the company. That is quite a tall order. And to top it off, if near-term sales take a dip, all the work on the long-term becomes somewhat for naught, as the pressure builds to forget long term and get the near term fixed. And if the average tenure is less than two years, how is anyone in the CMO position going to have enough time to see the fruit of their labors?
And for all of this responsibility and all of this stress, what are the tools this person has to work with? Typically, it is little more than advertising. In the fight for the future, advertising is like a BB pistol. It has some impact, but it is not enough. The fight for the future needs more.
In a prior blog, I talked about how if someone comes from a narrow professional background, they will see all problems as requiring their narrow background for the solution (see “Henry the Hammer”). In other words, if your background is advertising, you will see nearly every problem as requiring advertising to fix it. Most CMOs tend to come out of a narrow advertising background. Hence, they tend to rely on advertising as their primary tool to get their job done.
However, much of what it takes to protect and grow a firm long-term has little to do with advertising. It is far more complex, involving finance, strategy, asset alignment, personnel choices, and so on. All of the intricacies of positioning, pursuit and productivity which I briefly outlined in a prior blog (see “Same Title, Different Jobs”) come into play. Advertising is only a small part of the puzzle.
My conclusion is that the position of CMO is failing because the design of the position is such that it is almost impossible not to fail. The capabilities do not match up to the expectations.
My solution? Bring back the chief strategist. Strategic planning as a full time job in companies is becoming obsolete. Yet there is nobody more qualified to handle the expectations of preserving and building the future than the strategist. Strategic planners tend to have broader backgrounds than CMOs and are more capable of getting their arms around the big picture. Because they are pulled less in two directions (look out for the future AND get out next week’s ad), they can do a better job of focusing on and articulating the full scope of what must be done to grow the company.
Yes, outside strategic consultants have their value. However, would you ever consider outsourcing any of your other C-suite functions to an outside consultant who only shows up on an infrequent basis? By having someone on premise all of the time worrying just about your future, you get far more than just the advice of someone out for billable hours.
Advertising and marketing are very important, but they are not the whole job. Giving a VP of Marketing the title of CMO doesn’t really change anything but their title (and, I suppose, their compensation). Adding a Chief Strategy Officer to the team, however, can give a much needed fresh broad perspective to winning the future.
SUMMARY
Protecting and growing the future of your firm is an important task. It is important enough to require having someone on senior staff, full-time, just worrying about the future. The CMO is usually not capable of doing this, regardless of expectations, because they are distracted by the “tyranny of the now” on their advertising responsibility as well as not usually having a broad enough background to cover all the aspects related to the task. Instead, the best solution to the problem is to have a senior executive schooled in the art of strategic planning.
FINAL THOUGHTS
It is interesting to note that, while the study mentioned in Advertising Age saw no positive impact from CMOs on financial performance, it also concluded that “CMOs do not have a negative impact on financial performance.” Well, there you have it. Something to call home about and to put on your tombstone: “I did not have a negative impact on financial performance.”
If you have CMO in your title, I would suggest that you always be out there networking, because the nature of your position tends to cause short career stints.
Sunday, July 15, 2007
Wednesday, July 11, 2007
Management by Growing
THE STORY
Once upon a time, the there was a small little boy who hated being so small. “Nobody pays any attention to me or gives me any respect because I am so small,” he lamented to himself.
One day, a fairy godmother came to visit the little boy and offered to grant him any one wish. Well, that was an easy choice for this boy. “I want to grow and grow and become BIG!” he replied.
The next day, the boy woke up and was big and tall, like an adult. The boy was ecstatic! People, finally paid attention to him and gave him respect. It felt great.
Unfortunately, his growth did not stop there. Every day he grew a little bigger. At first, it wasn’t such a big deal. But eventually he was so big that he was taller than large buildings. Everywhere he stepped, he ended up crushing something with his gigantic feet. The respect he used to get from others turned to fear, as people were afraid to be near him for fear of being crushed. It made him feel like the monster Godzilla.
“I guess it’s possible to grow a little too much,” the boy finally admitted.
THE ANALOGY
One of the most popular phases in a business life cycle is the growth phase. It can be a lot of fun. Your position is relatively well set and desired by a lot of consumers. Your only problem is growing the company fast enough to take advantage of all the great potential you have. It feels like you can do no wrong.
Shareholders seem to love growth companies as well. They give the stocks high multiples. Suddenly, the company is worth a whole lot of money, and everyone is smiling.
It’s like the boy in the story. When he was small, he was ignored and not given any respect. However, once he started growing, everything started to change for the better. He started receiving the love and respect of others.
It feels so good that you want it to continue forever. However, as we saw in the story, sometimes too much emphasis on growth for too long can backfire on you. Continuing the push for growth long after you’ve reached your optimal size can cause all of your friends to turn on you.
In the business world, maturity will eventually come, causing additional rapid growth to no longer be appropriate. Too much growth for too long can result in investments which are no longer needed in the marketplace, causing returns below your cost of capital. You may be merely spreading your relatively constant sales over a larger, more costly infrastructure, which reduces overall profitability.
Growth is good, but other factors also need to be considered in your strategic planning, so that your company does not turn into a hideous monster like Godzilla.
THE PRINCIPLE
In the last three blogs, we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry. In the blog “Same Title, Different Jobs”, we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the solution you are providing, the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path to achieve (or improve) your desired position. This usually involves acts which allow you to gobble up market share so that you can build a strong claim to your position.
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
During the rapid growth phase of an industry, most of the attention is on growing the business (I guess that’s why it’s called the growth phase). The key area of strategic focus in this period is on pursuit. The idea is to grab as much of the market potential as fast as you can, so that nobody else can gain a stronger foothold at that position.
The success of your position is what is making the growth possible, so there is not much need to reassess the position. Regarding productivity, you greatest contribution at this point is the productivity which is a natural outcome of rapid growth—economies of scale. Hence, if you focus on the growth, productivity will be a natural byproduct at this stage of the lifecycle.
That being said, one still needs some balance. Positioning and productivity cannot be ignored. Success usually causes imitators to crop up. These imitators may create a need to tweak your positioning strategy in order to stay one step ahead of them.
In addition, the growth phase usually leads eventually to a consolidation of the industry, as a greater percentage of a company’s growth comes from acquiring competitors. If you are not an efficient, productive operator, it is likely that you will be the one being acquired rather than being the one doing the acquiring. Efficiency helps give you the edge when the intra-industry warfare begins, to see who will survive and make it to the mature stage. When the sporting goods retail industry recently went though its consolidation phase, it was the blander, but more efficient Dick’s Sporting Goods which acquired the flashier, but less productive Galyan’s.
Thus, although pursuit is the most important concern at this stage, the other factors should not be ignored.
The pleasure which comes in the growth phase causes pressure to want to continue the growth phase, long after that phase in the industry is over. It seems like everyone wants to be a growth stock forever.
If you want to be a growth stock forever, one probably needs to abandon industries as they mature and move on to new evolving industries. This is pretty much what GE has done over the decades. The growth comes from shifting one’s position, rather than continuing growth in an industry that no longer requires it. At that point, it is an emphasis on positioning, rather than pursuit which continues the growth (We’ll talk more about that in a blog at a later date).
Last month, Wal-Mart finally started coming around to seeing this conclusion. They announced that they were cutting back on new store growth, because it was no longer as productive as in the past. The sales for the new stores were coming largely from other Wal-Marts, so the net increases were shrinking.
Here is what the Wall Street Journal had to say about it on June 2nd:
“Wal-Mart Stores Inc. plans to sharply curtail future U.S. store openings, amid disappointing results for the world's largest retailer and growing investor pressure to curb its aggressive domestic expansion. Friday, it promised to cut more than a third of this year's planned store additions, delay some openings and restrict future U.S. store expansion.
“The move will cut the retailer's capital expenditures by $1.5 billion in 2007 to $15.5 billion for the year and help fund a large share buyback that investors also have been urging the company to pursue. Wal-Mart has been under pressure on Wall Street to slow its U.S. expansion and use the savings to prop up its stock price.
“Wal-Mart, based in Bentonville, Ark., isn't the only retailer to retreat on its store-building boom. AutoZone Inc., Home Depot Inc. and McDonald's Corp. have pulled back on expansion in recent years to improve store operations and boost shareholder returns. 'This is what everyone's been clamoring for,' said Goldman Sachs retailing analyst Adrianne Shapira.
“News of the capital-spending cutback and share repurchase cheered investors, who sent Wal-Mart shares up 3.9%, or $1.87, to $49.47 in 4 p.m. composite trading on the New York Stock Exchange Friday.”
So as you can see, sometimes it is wise get out of a single-minded approach to planning focused only on growth and move to a balance which includes productivity (such as stock buybacks or reinvestments in making current assets more productive, as McDonald’s has done).
SUMMARY
Growth is good, but too much of the same kind of growth for too long is often not one’s wisest move. One needs to have a balanced approach which also looks at potential repositionings or focuses on productivity in order to keep the profit wheels moving.
FINAL THOUGHTS
For some people, the thought of no longer being a growth stock is like a fate worse than death. Trust me, there is life after rapid growth. By no longer pumping all that money into pursuit, those years can be some of your most profitable. Yes, the stock might initially fall when growth-minded shareholders leave, but keep this in mind. Those same people will also leave if they see your rapid growth as no longer productive. And in that case you have nothing.
At least if you stop the unnecessary investments and start doing things like buying back stock or raising dividends or improving efficiencies, you can attract other shareholders who will still reward you. All of the retailers mentioned in that Wall Street Journal article saw their stock rebound when then quit the unnecessary growth. And finally, keep in mind that Warren Buffett did pretty well refraining from the lure of rapid growth, and instead focusing his investments in a lot of more stable businesses.
Once upon a time, the there was a small little boy who hated being so small. “Nobody pays any attention to me or gives me any respect because I am so small,” he lamented to himself.
One day, a fairy godmother came to visit the little boy and offered to grant him any one wish. Well, that was an easy choice for this boy. “I want to grow and grow and become BIG!” he replied.
The next day, the boy woke up and was big and tall, like an adult. The boy was ecstatic! People, finally paid attention to him and gave him respect. It felt great.
Unfortunately, his growth did not stop there. Every day he grew a little bigger. At first, it wasn’t such a big deal. But eventually he was so big that he was taller than large buildings. Everywhere he stepped, he ended up crushing something with his gigantic feet. The respect he used to get from others turned to fear, as people were afraid to be near him for fear of being crushed. It made him feel like the monster Godzilla.
“I guess it’s possible to grow a little too much,” the boy finally admitted.
THE ANALOGY
One of the most popular phases in a business life cycle is the growth phase. It can be a lot of fun. Your position is relatively well set and desired by a lot of consumers. Your only problem is growing the company fast enough to take advantage of all the great potential you have. It feels like you can do no wrong.
Shareholders seem to love growth companies as well. They give the stocks high multiples. Suddenly, the company is worth a whole lot of money, and everyone is smiling.
It’s like the boy in the story. When he was small, he was ignored and not given any respect. However, once he started growing, everything started to change for the better. He started receiving the love and respect of others.
It feels so good that you want it to continue forever. However, as we saw in the story, sometimes too much emphasis on growth for too long can backfire on you. Continuing the push for growth long after you’ve reached your optimal size can cause all of your friends to turn on you.
In the business world, maturity will eventually come, causing additional rapid growth to no longer be appropriate. Too much growth for too long can result in investments which are no longer needed in the marketplace, causing returns below your cost of capital. You may be merely spreading your relatively constant sales over a larger, more costly infrastructure, which reduces overall profitability.
Growth is good, but other factors also need to be considered in your strategic planning, so that your company does not turn into a hideous monster like Godzilla.
THE PRINCIPLE
In the last three blogs, we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry. In the blog “Same Title, Different Jobs”, we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the solution you are providing, the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path to achieve (or improve) your desired position. This usually involves acts which allow you to gobble up market share so that you can build a strong claim to your position.
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
During the rapid growth phase of an industry, most of the attention is on growing the business (I guess that’s why it’s called the growth phase). The key area of strategic focus in this period is on pursuit. The idea is to grab as much of the market potential as fast as you can, so that nobody else can gain a stronger foothold at that position.
The success of your position is what is making the growth possible, so there is not much need to reassess the position. Regarding productivity, you greatest contribution at this point is the productivity which is a natural outcome of rapid growth—economies of scale. Hence, if you focus on the growth, productivity will be a natural byproduct at this stage of the lifecycle.
That being said, one still needs some balance. Positioning and productivity cannot be ignored. Success usually causes imitators to crop up. These imitators may create a need to tweak your positioning strategy in order to stay one step ahead of them.
In addition, the growth phase usually leads eventually to a consolidation of the industry, as a greater percentage of a company’s growth comes from acquiring competitors. If you are not an efficient, productive operator, it is likely that you will be the one being acquired rather than being the one doing the acquiring. Efficiency helps give you the edge when the intra-industry warfare begins, to see who will survive and make it to the mature stage. When the sporting goods retail industry recently went though its consolidation phase, it was the blander, but more efficient Dick’s Sporting Goods which acquired the flashier, but less productive Galyan’s.
Thus, although pursuit is the most important concern at this stage, the other factors should not be ignored.
The pleasure which comes in the growth phase causes pressure to want to continue the growth phase, long after that phase in the industry is over. It seems like everyone wants to be a growth stock forever.
If you want to be a growth stock forever, one probably needs to abandon industries as they mature and move on to new evolving industries. This is pretty much what GE has done over the decades. The growth comes from shifting one’s position, rather than continuing growth in an industry that no longer requires it. At that point, it is an emphasis on positioning, rather than pursuit which continues the growth (We’ll talk more about that in a blog at a later date).
Last month, Wal-Mart finally started coming around to seeing this conclusion. They announced that they were cutting back on new store growth, because it was no longer as productive as in the past. The sales for the new stores were coming largely from other Wal-Marts, so the net increases were shrinking.
Here is what the Wall Street Journal had to say about it on June 2nd:
“Wal-Mart Stores Inc. plans to sharply curtail future U.S. store openings, amid disappointing results for the world's largest retailer and growing investor pressure to curb its aggressive domestic expansion. Friday, it promised to cut more than a third of this year's planned store additions, delay some openings and restrict future U.S. store expansion.
“The move will cut the retailer's capital expenditures by $1.5 billion in 2007 to $15.5 billion for the year and help fund a large share buyback that investors also have been urging the company to pursue. Wal-Mart has been under pressure on Wall Street to slow its U.S. expansion and use the savings to prop up its stock price.
“Wal-Mart, based in Bentonville, Ark., isn't the only retailer to retreat on its store-building boom. AutoZone Inc., Home Depot Inc. and McDonald's Corp. have pulled back on expansion in recent years to improve store operations and boost shareholder returns. 'This is what everyone's been clamoring for,' said Goldman Sachs retailing analyst Adrianne Shapira.
“News of the capital-spending cutback and share repurchase cheered investors, who sent Wal-Mart shares up 3.9%, or $1.87, to $49.47 in 4 p.m. composite trading on the New York Stock Exchange Friday.”
So as you can see, sometimes it is wise get out of a single-minded approach to planning focused only on growth and move to a balance which includes productivity (such as stock buybacks or reinvestments in making current assets more productive, as McDonald’s has done).
SUMMARY
Growth is good, but too much of the same kind of growth for too long is often not one’s wisest move. One needs to have a balanced approach which also looks at potential repositionings or focuses on productivity in order to keep the profit wheels moving.
FINAL THOUGHTS
For some people, the thought of no longer being a growth stock is like a fate worse than death. Trust me, there is life after rapid growth. By no longer pumping all that money into pursuit, those years can be some of your most profitable. Yes, the stock might initially fall when growth-minded shareholders leave, but keep this in mind. Those same people will also leave if they see your rapid growth as no longer productive. And in that case you have nothing.
At least if you stop the unnecessary investments and start doing things like buying back stock or raising dividends or improving efficiencies, you can attract other shareholders who will still reward you. All of the retailers mentioned in that Wall Street Journal article saw their stock rebound when then quit the unnecessary growth. And finally, keep in mind that Warren Buffett did pretty well refraining from the lure of rapid growth, and instead focusing his investments in a lot of more stable businesses.
Tuesday, July 10, 2007
Management By Dreaming
THE STORY
At the peak of the dotcom bubble, I was working at Best Buy. All sorts of people were knocking on Best Buy’s door trying to convince us to put money into their dotcom dream. I heard a number of them. I remember one in particular.
This young man came to the office. I think he was still a freshman in college. He claimed to have a great dotcom idea. His idea was to run a site where consumers could gather and jointly buy major appliances (items like stoves, refrigerators, washing machines and the like). The more people who gathered together and wanted to buy identical appliances, the lower the price they would pay on each unit.
That was pretty much his entire pitch. It only took about five or ten minutes.
It was obvious to me that he had not done his homework on the major appliance industry. First, the margins in the major appliance industry are razor thin. In fact, the retail prices for standard major appliances during the dotcom boom of the 1990s were almost identical to the prices charged back in the 1950s (and you know that costs have gone up quite a bit since the 1950s).
One of our merchants used to say that there is so little profit in major appliances, that a retailer can make more gross margin dollars selling a single George Foreman grill than in selling one oven. If we dropped prices the way this young man suggested, we’d be bankrupt in a hurry.
Second, I started asking him questions about implementation. I asked him how the consumers would get their gas stove, particularly if they lived outside of a Best Buy trade area. Would we ship it to them by UPS? If we did, that charge would wipe out any cost savings from the bidding. And who would install that gas stove? He replied that he hadn’t thought through all of those details.
In fact, I don’t think he had thought through any details. He had no detailed deck showing his research. He had no preliminary financials. He didn’t even have a Powerpoint presentation. He didn’t bring any software skills or any prototypes of the site. All he had was a dream…and not a very good one at that.
THE ANALOGY
In the last two blogs we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry.
If you are at the very early stages in a business cycle, the industry is not well defined and lots of business ventures come and go. Success at this stage has a lot to do with dreaming up clever ideas on how to win in the new space in ways that have never been done before.
This was the case in the early days of the dotcom boom. As the story above illustrates, a number of people were dreaming up ways to use the internet to reinvent an industry. In this case, the young man was trying to reinvent how appliances were sold.
Yes, it is appropriate in these early stages of an industry to focus significant attention on dreaming. This is a key part of the strategic planning process at that point in the lifecycle. However, as we saw in the story, if your dream is not grounded in at least some rudimentary research, it can be more like a nightmare.
THE PRINCIPLE
Two blogs back (see “Same Title, Different Jobs”), we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the solution you are providing, the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
In young, evolving industries, the positions are relatively wide open. Nobody really has a lock on the market in any given position. In fact, you are probably inventing a new position that never before existed—a brand new way to solve an age-old problem. At this early stage, one of the greatest ways to add value to the business is to spend time in your strategic process focusing on what your original position should be.
This is really not the time to be stressing out over getting the last ounce of productivity out of the business model. After all, it is likely that the business model at this early stage will morph into numerous variations until you get the new formula right. Trying to optimize productivity before the business model is set can be counter productive to your immediate battle to find the right position and win it in the minds of your customers before someone else does.
So the first priority at this early stage is dreaming and experimenting to first get the positioning “relatively right”, then to look at ways to pursue the position so that you can win in that space. Productivity is well down the list of priorities at this point. As you can see, this is the opposite prioritization of tasks to what was said in the last blog when talking about mature firms (see “Management by Yelling”).
So, yes, dreaming is an important prioritization in this early phase. But it is not the only task. Dreams need to be rooted at least a somewhat, through some combination of:
1. Consumer research
2. Secondary research
3. Concept testing with potential customers
4. Small trial runs of some aspects of the business model actually run for real out in the real world marketplace
5. Beta testing
6. Financial modeling
7. Pressure testing your assumptions against what you know about the marketplace. In particular, it is important to gage how big the space may eventually evolve into and how well suited your idea is to capture that demand.
The more your insights come from actual behavior rather than opinions, the better. Behavior is a better predictor than opinion, especially in new areas where the consumer has little experience in which to base an opinion.
Sure, because you are venturing into new space there will be many unknowns. If you wait until all the facts are in, it will probably be too late to enter the space. Yet that is no excuse to enter blindly like that young man in the story.
Speed is important at this stage, so you don’t want to get bogged down in the paralysis of analysis. However, running as fast as you can when you have no idea of the general direction where you should be heading is not a formula for success, either (for more on this topic, see the blog “Cutting Your Way to Prosperity—Part 2”).
The idea here is balance and timing. Use some diligence to get close on the position, then quickly shift to pursuit, where you begin to roll out the business model out into the real world to see how well it really flies and to make modifications. The closer you get to getting the model “right”, the faster you can ramp up your pursuit. Then, once the rules are relatively established and you position is relatively strong, you can shift more of your focus to increasing productivity.
Of course, this does not mean that productivity is completely ignored in the early stages. If you are inefficient and completely unproductive in the early stages, you will not have the financial stamina to fight the battles to get to the next stage. That’s one reason why so many dotcom startups during the boom fizzled out early. They ran out of cash before they could generate their own due to wastefulness. Again, there needs to be balance, even in the early phases.
SUMMARY
Even though young and evolving industries should spend the majority of their strategic effort on getting a grip on how to invent their position, they also need to spend some time on understanding how to get insights from pursuit and how to create enough cash to get to the next stage via productivity.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Rarely do the original dreams look exactly like what the business evolves into. But don’t let that stop you from taking the risk. You cannot evolve to the right position if you never start at all.
At the peak of the dotcom bubble, I was working at Best Buy. All sorts of people were knocking on Best Buy’s door trying to convince us to put money into their dotcom dream. I heard a number of them. I remember one in particular.
This young man came to the office. I think he was still a freshman in college. He claimed to have a great dotcom idea. His idea was to run a site where consumers could gather and jointly buy major appliances (items like stoves, refrigerators, washing machines and the like). The more people who gathered together and wanted to buy identical appliances, the lower the price they would pay on each unit.
That was pretty much his entire pitch. It only took about five or ten minutes.
It was obvious to me that he had not done his homework on the major appliance industry. First, the margins in the major appliance industry are razor thin. In fact, the retail prices for standard major appliances during the dotcom boom of the 1990s were almost identical to the prices charged back in the 1950s (and you know that costs have gone up quite a bit since the 1950s).
One of our merchants used to say that there is so little profit in major appliances, that a retailer can make more gross margin dollars selling a single George Foreman grill than in selling one oven. If we dropped prices the way this young man suggested, we’d be bankrupt in a hurry.
Second, I started asking him questions about implementation. I asked him how the consumers would get their gas stove, particularly if they lived outside of a Best Buy trade area. Would we ship it to them by UPS? If we did, that charge would wipe out any cost savings from the bidding. And who would install that gas stove? He replied that he hadn’t thought through all of those details.
In fact, I don’t think he had thought through any details. He had no detailed deck showing his research. He had no preliminary financials. He didn’t even have a Powerpoint presentation. He didn’t bring any software skills or any prototypes of the site. All he had was a dream…and not a very good one at that.
THE ANALOGY
In the last two blogs we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry.
If you are at the very early stages in a business cycle, the industry is not well defined and lots of business ventures come and go. Success at this stage has a lot to do with dreaming up clever ideas on how to win in the new space in ways that have never been done before.
This was the case in the early days of the dotcom boom. As the story above illustrates, a number of people were dreaming up ways to use the internet to reinvent an industry. In this case, the young man was trying to reinvent how appliances were sold.
Yes, it is appropriate in these early stages of an industry to focus significant attention on dreaming. This is a key part of the strategic planning process at that point in the lifecycle. However, as we saw in the story, if your dream is not grounded in at least some rudimentary research, it can be more like a nightmare.
THE PRINCIPLE
Two blogs back (see “Same Title, Different Jobs”), we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the solution you are providing, the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
In young, evolving industries, the positions are relatively wide open. Nobody really has a lock on the market in any given position. In fact, you are probably inventing a new position that never before existed—a brand new way to solve an age-old problem. At this early stage, one of the greatest ways to add value to the business is to spend time in your strategic process focusing on what your original position should be.
This is really not the time to be stressing out over getting the last ounce of productivity out of the business model. After all, it is likely that the business model at this early stage will morph into numerous variations until you get the new formula right. Trying to optimize productivity before the business model is set can be counter productive to your immediate battle to find the right position and win it in the minds of your customers before someone else does.
So the first priority at this early stage is dreaming and experimenting to first get the positioning “relatively right”, then to look at ways to pursue the position so that you can win in that space. Productivity is well down the list of priorities at this point. As you can see, this is the opposite prioritization of tasks to what was said in the last blog when talking about mature firms (see “Management by Yelling”).
So, yes, dreaming is an important prioritization in this early phase. But it is not the only task. Dreams need to be rooted at least a somewhat, through some combination of:
1. Consumer research
2. Secondary research
3. Concept testing with potential customers
4. Small trial runs of some aspects of the business model actually run for real out in the real world marketplace
5. Beta testing
6. Financial modeling
7. Pressure testing your assumptions against what you know about the marketplace. In particular, it is important to gage how big the space may eventually evolve into and how well suited your idea is to capture that demand.
The more your insights come from actual behavior rather than opinions, the better. Behavior is a better predictor than opinion, especially in new areas where the consumer has little experience in which to base an opinion.
Sure, because you are venturing into new space there will be many unknowns. If you wait until all the facts are in, it will probably be too late to enter the space. Yet that is no excuse to enter blindly like that young man in the story.
Speed is important at this stage, so you don’t want to get bogged down in the paralysis of analysis. However, running as fast as you can when you have no idea of the general direction where you should be heading is not a formula for success, either (for more on this topic, see the blog “Cutting Your Way to Prosperity—Part 2”).
The idea here is balance and timing. Use some diligence to get close on the position, then quickly shift to pursuit, where you begin to roll out the business model out into the real world to see how well it really flies and to make modifications. The closer you get to getting the model “right”, the faster you can ramp up your pursuit. Then, once the rules are relatively established and you position is relatively strong, you can shift more of your focus to increasing productivity.
Of course, this does not mean that productivity is completely ignored in the early stages. If you are inefficient and completely unproductive in the early stages, you will not have the financial stamina to fight the battles to get to the next stage. That’s one reason why so many dotcom startups during the boom fizzled out early. They ran out of cash before they could generate their own due to wastefulness. Again, there needs to be balance, even in the early phases.
SUMMARY
Even though young and evolving industries should spend the majority of their strategic effort on getting a grip on how to invent their position, they also need to spend some time on understanding how to get insights from pursuit and how to create enough cash to get to the next stage via productivity.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Rarely do the original dreams look exactly like what the business evolves into. But don’t let that stop you from taking the risk. You cannot evolve to the right position if you never start at all.
Monday, July 9, 2007
Management by Yelling
THE STORY
One time, early in my business career, I had the privilege of flying on the corporate jet. Boy, for a young person like me that was a treat! I highly recommend corporate jets if you travel a lot.
Also on the flight was a senior executive. Normally, this executive would not have given me the time of day, because I was so far beneath him in the corporate hierarchy. However, it was a long flight, and there were no other senior executives on the plane.
Therefore, since I was the next highest ranking person on the plane, after a long period of silence, he finally, reluctantly decided that he would have to talk to me. Not knowing quite what to say, he started off by saying, “You know, I’ve discovered over the years that fear is a great motivator.”
With an opening comment like that, you can imagine that the conversation for the rest of the flight was a little bit awkward.
THE ANALOGY
In the last blog we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry.
These approaches can lead to different styles of management. In the story above, this senior executive had a very cold management style. Fear and yelling seemed to be his way of getting things done. Although I am never sure that this type of management style in its extreme is appropriate, I can see how such a style can develop depending on the types of industries one has worked in.
In industries that have the characteristics of being mature, stable, consolidated, and with high barriers to entry/exit, a cold management style characterized by yelling can appear to be appropriate…at least for awhile. However, as we will see below, even in those instances, it has its limits.
THE PRINCIPLE
In the last blog (see “Same Title, Different Jobs”), we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
In mature, stable industries, the positions are already pretty much staked out. Consumer impressions of what you stand for are already firmly planted in their minds. High barriers to entry keep my customers from having many choices. High barriers to exit give me more ability to play hardball without fear of negative repercussions. Little can change in the near term. Therefore, less time is needed to devote to positioning.
A similar situation exists for mature companies when it comes to pursuit. You have already pursued growth and market share to the point where you were able to survive the industry consolidation and still be in business as one of the industry leaders. You also have had sufficient time to pursue the basic tricks of the trade in your business and become relatively good at them. Therefore, less time is needed to devote to pursuit.
Hence, these mature stable businesses tend to focus their strategy on productivity. In other words, the key question becomes:
How can I use the power of my current situation (a result of prior success in positioning and pursuit) to squeeze more incremental profits out of the same basic business? How can I beat up my sources for lower prices? How can I get more productivity out of the employees? How can I get my customers to pay a little bit more?
With a focus like that, it is easy to see how the management style in these industries can become cold and be based on fear and yelling.
The executive mentioned in the story above learned his management skills while working for a leading supermarket chain in the New York City area. At the time he worked there, supermarketing in New York City was mature and stable. It had consolidated to only a handful of major players and he worked for one of the leaders. It was nearly impossible any more to find many new sites to build supermarkets in the New York metro area, so if you already had stores in the key locations, you were pretty much set. People have to eat, and supermarkets at the time were the primary places to get food to eat, so as long as you were a decent operator, you were pretty much assured of success.
Therefore, the big focus was on trying to squeeze a little bit more out of the business through productivity. This may help explain how this executive came to this management style.
Unfortunately, when taken to an extreme, this type of strategic mindset can get you into big trouble. First, through cockiness, one can start holding back on reinvestment, believing that the barriers to exit are so high that you can get away with letting the business run down a little (so that you can pocket more profits). Second, one can start believing that the current stability will last forever, so there is no need to reassess one’s situation to see if there is a need for repositioning or a new wave of pursuit.
Stable situations never last forever. In the case of supermarkets, the format started to become obsolete as people preferred shopping at larger stores with greater variety, such as supercenters, warehouse clubs and combination food/drug stores. The dense urban markets, which used to seem impenetrable for new competition, were getting increased food selling by drug stores as well as selling by internet companies which did not need to build a lot of stores. Food tastes were changing, with more people looking for gourmet, fresh prepared and organic foods. Gradually, the “conventional supermarket” position in New York was not so strong any more.
Shifts in populations were making some old sites less desirable and opening up new real estate opportunities for more aggressive pursuers. If the supermarkets were not pursuing by reinvesting in the core business, they could start looking weak compared to the new competitors on the block.
Recently, that strong supermarket company this executive used to work for became rundown and quite weak and was eventually sold.
That is why even mature and stable businesses cannot ignore positioning or pursuit and just relying on yelling for more productivity. Times change, requiring repositioning and renewed pursuit.
Take, for example, the photography industry. The camera film business used to be mature and stable. Fuji and Kodak were the survivors who had pursued relentlessly to make their film available for sale almost everywhere. Life, for a time was relatively simple. But then came digital and the need for film started to become obsolete. Kodak was slow in realizing a need for repositioning and a renewed pursuit of the new technology. Now Kodak is only a shadow of its former self.
A similar situation occurred in the camera business. As digital cameras came into being, new companies broke through the old barriers to entry, like Sony and HP. The old rules no longer applied. Recently, I was visiting the Columbus Zoo and noticed that more people where taking snapshots with their cell phones than with digital cameras. So even the idea of a camera may someday become obsolete.
Just getting more productive at making film or making film-based cameras no longer gets the job done. That is why there is a need for balance. Even in mature and stable industries one needs to spend a little time on studying positioning and pursuit to ensure that one is ready when the stability is upended by change. Trust me…all stable businesses eventually get reinvented and the process starts all over again with a new upheaval. You cannot just suck all of the money out of a business without reinvestment and assume it will survive into the next upheaval. Investments in experimentations to ensure that you are on top of industry trends can help keep you from getting upended when the new trends take over.
Wal-Mart was smart enough to understand that traditional discount stores were becoming obsolete and it repositioned itself as a supercenter operator and pursued this new vision relentlessly so that nobody else could beat them to the end goal of leadership once the supercenter industry matures. They did this even though it meant abandoning their huge investment in conventional discount stores and starting the investment process all over again. Sometimes a radical replacement of what you used to be with something else is what is necessary in order to survive the industry upheaval. And a focus only on productivity through yelling won’t get you there.
SUMMARY
Even though mature and stable industries should spend the majority of their effort on productivity, they also need to spend some time on positioning and pursuit, so that they are prepared when the industry inevitably gets upended by a reinvention that makes the industry unstable again.
FINAL THOUGHTS
It is not easy to envision of how an industry is evolving and what must be changed to survive a new instability by yelling at people.
One time, early in my business career, I had the privilege of flying on the corporate jet. Boy, for a young person like me that was a treat! I highly recommend corporate jets if you travel a lot.
Also on the flight was a senior executive. Normally, this executive would not have given me the time of day, because I was so far beneath him in the corporate hierarchy. However, it was a long flight, and there were no other senior executives on the plane.
Therefore, since I was the next highest ranking person on the plane, after a long period of silence, he finally, reluctantly decided that he would have to talk to me. Not knowing quite what to say, he started off by saying, “You know, I’ve discovered over the years that fear is a great motivator.”
With an opening comment like that, you can imagine that the conversation for the rest of the flight was a little bit awkward.
THE ANALOGY
In the last blog we talked about how different companies require a different approach to strategic planning depending on where they are in their lifecycle and how many barriers there are to entry/exit in their industry.
These approaches can lead to different styles of management. In the story above, this senior executive had a very cold management style. Fear and yelling seemed to be his way of getting things done. Although I am never sure that this type of management style in its extreme is appropriate, I can see how such a style can develop depending on the types of industries one has worked in.
In industries that have the characteristics of being mature, stable, consolidated, and with high barriers to entry/exit, a cold management style characterized by yelling can appear to be appropriate…at least for awhile. However, as we will see below, even in those instances, it has its limits.
THE PRINCIPLE
In the last blog (see “Same Title, Different Jobs”), we said that there are three major steps in strategic planning:
1) Positioning: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the place where you can win.
2. Pursuit: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
3. Productivity: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
In mature, stable industries, the positions are already pretty much staked out. Consumer impressions of what you stand for are already firmly planted in their minds. High barriers to entry keep my customers from having many choices. High barriers to exit give me more ability to play hardball without fear of negative repercussions. Little can change in the near term. Therefore, less time is needed to devote to positioning.
A similar situation exists for mature companies when it comes to pursuit. You have already pursued growth and market share to the point where you were able to survive the industry consolidation and still be in business as one of the industry leaders. You also have had sufficient time to pursue the basic tricks of the trade in your business and become relatively good at them. Therefore, less time is needed to devote to pursuit.
Hence, these mature stable businesses tend to focus their strategy on productivity. In other words, the key question becomes:
How can I use the power of my current situation (a result of prior success in positioning and pursuit) to squeeze more incremental profits out of the same basic business? How can I beat up my sources for lower prices? How can I get more productivity out of the employees? How can I get my customers to pay a little bit more?
With a focus like that, it is easy to see how the management style in these industries can become cold and be based on fear and yelling.
The executive mentioned in the story above learned his management skills while working for a leading supermarket chain in the New York City area. At the time he worked there, supermarketing in New York City was mature and stable. It had consolidated to only a handful of major players and he worked for one of the leaders. It was nearly impossible any more to find many new sites to build supermarkets in the New York metro area, so if you already had stores in the key locations, you were pretty much set. People have to eat, and supermarkets at the time were the primary places to get food to eat, so as long as you were a decent operator, you were pretty much assured of success.
Therefore, the big focus was on trying to squeeze a little bit more out of the business through productivity. This may help explain how this executive came to this management style.
Unfortunately, when taken to an extreme, this type of strategic mindset can get you into big trouble. First, through cockiness, one can start holding back on reinvestment, believing that the barriers to exit are so high that you can get away with letting the business run down a little (so that you can pocket more profits). Second, one can start believing that the current stability will last forever, so there is no need to reassess one’s situation to see if there is a need for repositioning or a new wave of pursuit.
Stable situations never last forever. In the case of supermarkets, the format started to become obsolete as people preferred shopping at larger stores with greater variety, such as supercenters, warehouse clubs and combination food/drug stores. The dense urban markets, which used to seem impenetrable for new competition, were getting increased food selling by drug stores as well as selling by internet companies which did not need to build a lot of stores. Food tastes were changing, with more people looking for gourmet, fresh prepared and organic foods. Gradually, the “conventional supermarket” position in New York was not so strong any more.
Shifts in populations were making some old sites less desirable and opening up new real estate opportunities for more aggressive pursuers. If the supermarkets were not pursuing by reinvesting in the core business, they could start looking weak compared to the new competitors on the block.
Recently, that strong supermarket company this executive used to work for became rundown and quite weak and was eventually sold.
That is why even mature and stable businesses cannot ignore positioning or pursuit and just relying on yelling for more productivity. Times change, requiring repositioning and renewed pursuit.
Take, for example, the photography industry. The camera film business used to be mature and stable. Fuji and Kodak were the survivors who had pursued relentlessly to make their film available for sale almost everywhere. Life, for a time was relatively simple. But then came digital and the need for film started to become obsolete. Kodak was slow in realizing a need for repositioning and a renewed pursuit of the new technology. Now Kodak is only a shadow of its former self.
A similar situation occurred in the camera business. As digital cameras came into being, new companies broke through the old barriers to entry, like Sony and HP. The old rules no longer applied. Recently, I was visiting the Columbus Zoo and noticed that more people where taking snapshots with their cell phones than with digital cameras. So even the idea of a camera may someday become obsolete.
Just getting more productive at making film or making film-based cameras no longer gets the job done. That is why there is a need for balance. Even in mature and stable industries one needs to spend a little time on studying positioning and pursuit to ensure that one is ready when the stability is upended by change. Trust me…all stable businesses eventually get reinvented and the process starts all over again with a new upheaval. You cannot just suck all of the money out of a business without reinvestment and assume it will survive into the next upheaval. Investments in experimentations to ensure that you are on top of industry trends can help keep you from getting upended when the new trends take over.
Wal-Mart was smart enough to understand that traditional discount stores were becoming obsolete and it repositioned itself as a supercenter operator and pursued this new vision relentlessly so that nobody else could beat them to the end goal of leadership once the supercenter industry matures. They did this even though it meant abandoning their huge investment in conventional discount stores and starting the investment process all over again. Sometimes a radical replacement of what you used to be with something else is what is necessary in order to survive the industry upheaval. And a focus only on productivity through yelling won’t get you there.
SUMMARY
Even though mature and stable industries should spend the majority of their effort on productivity, they also need to spend some time on positioning and pursuit, so that they are prepared when the industry inevitably gets upended by a reinvention that makes the industry unstable again.
FINAL THOUGHTS
It is not easy to envision of how an industry is evolving and what must be changed to survive a new instability by yelling at people.
Saturday, July 7, 2007
Same Title, Different Jobs
THE STORY
Back when strategic planning was considered to be more of a full-time profession, there were several strategic planning societies to belong to and numerous strategic conferences to attend. When I would attend some of these conferences, I would typically see the same phenomenon played out.
Even though all the people attending all had relatively similar job titles (something involving leadership in strategic planning), the participants at these conferences tended to congregate into two separate groups. One group would be people from either relatively mature industries or industries with high barriers to entry and exit. This would include a lot of heavy industrial manufacturing companies and people involved with the oil industry or mining.
The other group tended to consist of people who were in relatively new industries or industries with low barriers to entry or exit. This tended to include people who worked in high tech, the dotcom space, or retailing.
What was interesting was that when each of these two groups began to talk to the other about their roles in strategic planning, it was as if the groups had two distinctively different jobs. There was almost nothing in common between the two groups. They defined their roles differently, they did different tasks, and they even had different expectations for what strategic planning is supposed to be.
Even though the people in both groups had similar job titles, they had totally different jobs. As a result, each group would soon start to have little to do with the other group, and would just converse with the group which most matched their own perception of strategic planning. In the end, it would almost be as if two separate meetings were going on at the same conference. Maybe that’s one reason why people stopped scheduling all of those conferences.
THE ANALOGY
Beware of people offering up a one-size-fits-all approach to strategic planning. As the story above pointed out, all firms are not in the same situation. Based on barriers to entry/exit or location on an industry life cycle, one’s strategic needs can be quite different. To treat them all the same would be unproductive. That would be like having a doctor treat an emergency room trauma case in the same manner as a routine office checkup.
One must tailor the approach to strategic planning based on particular situation a company finds itself in. Therefore, the first step in strategic planning is to determine which type of planning is appropriate for the current situation.
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of appropriateness and balance. First, the strategic planning process used should be appropriate to the situation a company is in. Not every situation requires the same strategic process. Second, although different situations may require a different emphasis, businesses can get in trouble if they ONLY look at the area emphasis. Although the primary focus should be on the point of emphasis, a balance is needed to ensure that a company is not surprised by any “blind spots” which come along. The other aspects need to be considered as well.
In this blog, we will outline these two principles. Then, in subsequent blogs, we will apply these principles in more depth to the two main types of strategic situations as alluded to in the story above.
In a complete strategic planning process there are three major steps:
1. POSITIONING
Goal: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the place where you can win.
Sub-Tasks:
a. Discovering: Learning about the near and long term environment and coming to some conclusions about key trends. This would include external discovery—learning about the world in which you will compete, as well as internal discovery—learning about one’s own strengths and weaknesses relative to that external environment.
b. Visioning: Creating visions of possible future states and the types of positions one could own in them. This would answer questions like: What problems am I solving for what type of customers? Why is my solution to the problem superior to the alternatives for that customer?
c. Evaluating: Combining what is learned in discovery with what is proposed in visioning to determine which alternative is most desirable and achievable for your company/brand.
2. PURSUIT
Goal: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
Sub-Tasks:
a. Pursuit of Capabilities
b. Pursuit of Supply Chain Connections
c. Pursuit of Market Share
3. PRODUCTIVITY
Goal: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
Sub-Tasks:
a. Doing well at general business efficiency principles
b. Finding unique nuances in your business which can improve productivity
c. Use power and influence to extract a disproportionate share of profits from your industry ecosystem.
Focus on Appropriate Areas
If you are in an industry which has some of the following characteristics, then your strategic focus tends to be mostly on #3 Productivity and least on #1 Positioning:
i. Mature Industry (consolidation has already taken place and rules of success already written).
ii. Stable Industry (the future is going to be a lot like the present).
iii. High Barriers to Entry and Exit (The players in the game remain the same. The risk of getting kicked out low).
The reasoning for the emphasis on productivity is obvious. If you believe the industry is relatively set in its ways and your current position within the industry is set, then there is less need to worry about positioning or pursuit. Your position is already fairly firmly set and most of the pursuit activities have already occurred. Hence, the key focus is on how to squeeze a little bit more profitability out of your current situation through productivity.
Conversely, you will have an opposite focus if your industry is in the following situation:
i. Embrionic or Early Growth Stage of lifecycle.
ii. Instability in the rules of the industry, the players in the industry, or the technology in the industry.
iii. Low Barriers to Entry or Exit
In these types of situations, there can be ambiguity about who holds what position in the marketplace and there may be opportunities to stake out new and better claims to a position. At this point, profitability is of lesser importance as investments are made to stake claim to a position which can reap great rewards later once you survive the consolidation.
Yet Still Keep Balance
In mature industries, although productivity may be the key focus, you cannot ignore the rest. Stable industries can be made unstable by new technologies or new ways of solving problems. If you are not watching the environment for these industry changers, you may find your position become obsolete.
Similarly, in the young and evolving industries, productivity is not the primary concern. However, if your cost structure is way out of line with the rest of the industry, you will probably not survive to the next level of the life cycle. Even in the heyday of the dotcom bubble, when profits seemed irrelevant, there eventually came a day of reckoning when the inefficient were erased from the marketplace.
Thus one also needs balance.
SUMMARY
The ideal design of your strategic planning process depends in part on where your industry is in its lifecycle and your current position within that industry. Once you determine this, you can put the proper emphasis on positioning, pursuit and productivity, where one or more of these get greater emphasis, but none are ignored.
FINAL THOUGHTS
This is a lot of content to cover in one blog. That is why we will be continuing the discussion in subsequent blogs.
Back when strategic planning was considered to be more of a full-time profession, there were several strategic planning societies to belong to and numerous strategic conferences to attend. When I would attend some of these conferences, I would typically see the same phenomenon played out.
Even though all the people attending all had relatively similar job titles (something involving leadership in strategic planning), the participants at these conferences tended to congregate into two separate groups. One group would be people from either relatively mature industries or industries with high barriers to entry and exit. This would include a lot of heavy industrial manufacturing companies and people involved with the oil industry or mining.
The other group tended to consist of people who were in relatively new industries or industries with low barriers to entry or exit. This tended to include people who worked in high tech, the dotcom space, or retailing.
What was interesting was that when each of these two groups began to talk to the other about their roles in strategic planning, it was as if the groups had two distinctively different jobs. There was almost nothing in common between the two groups. They defined their roles differently, they did different tasks, and they even had different expectations for what strategic planning is supposed to be.
Even though the people in both groups had similar job titles, they had totally different jobs. As a result, each group would soon start to have little to do with the other group, and would just converse with the group which most matched their own perception of strategic planning. In the end, it would almost be as if two separate meetings were going on at the same conference. Maybe that’s one reason why people stopped scheduling all of those conferences.
THE ANALOGY
Beware of people offering up a one-size-fits-all approach to strategic planning. As the story above pointed out, all firms are not in the same situation. Based on barriers to entry/exit or location on an industry life cycle, one’s strategic needs can be quite different. To treat them all the same would be unproductive. That would be like having a doctor treat an emergency room trauma case in the same manner as a routine office checkup.
One must tailor the approach to strategic planning based on particular situation a company finds itself in. Therefore, the first step in strategic planning is to determine which type of planning is appropriate for the current situation.
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of appropriateness and balance. First, the strategic planning process used should be appropriate to the situation a company is in. Not every situation requires the same strategic process. Second, although different situations may require a different emphasis, businesses can get in trouble if they ONLY look at the area emphasis. Although the primary focus should be on the point of emphasis, a balance is needed to ensure that a company is not surprised by any “blind spots” which come along. The other aspects need to be considered as well.
In this blog, we will outline these two principles. Then, in subsequent blogs, we will apply these principles in more depth to the two main types of strategic situations as alluded to in the story above.
In a complete strategic planning process there are three major steps:
1. POSITIONING
Goal: Determining what you will stand for (own) in the marketplace—the place where you can win.
Sub-Tasks:
a. Discovering: Learning about the near and long term environment and coming to some conclusions about key trends. This would include external discovery—learning about the world in which you will compete, as well as internal discovery—learning about one’s own strengths and weaknesses relative to that external environment.
b. Visioning: Creating visions of possible future states and the types of positions one could own in them. This would answer questions like: What problems am I solving for what type of customers? Why is my solution to the problem superior to the alternatives for that customer?
c. Evaluating: Combining what is learned in discovery with what is proposed in visioning to determine which alternative is most desirable and achievable for your company/brand.
2. PURSUIT
Goal: Determining the path that will ensure you are able to obtain (or re-enforce your hold on) your desired position. This involves making it easier to get what you need and harder for your competitors to do the same
Sub-Tasks:
a. Pursuit of Capabilities
b. Pursuit of Supply Chain Connections
c. Pursuit of Market Share
3. PRODUCTIVITY
Goal: Discovering ways to leverage your position so that you can optimize the return on your investment.
Sub-Tasks:
a. Doing well at general business efficiency principles
b. Finding unique nuances in your business which can improve productivity
c. Use power and influence to extract a disproportionate share of profits from your industry ecosystem.
Focus on Appropriate Areas
If you are in an industry which has some of the following characteristics, then your strategic focus tends to be mostly on #3 Productivity and least on #1 Positioning:
i. Mature Industry (consolidation has already taken place and rules of success already written).
ii. Stable Industry (the future is going to be a lot like the present).
iii. High Barriers to Entry and Exit (The players in the game remain the same. The risk of getting kicked out low).
The reasoning for the emphasis on productivity is obvious. If you believe the industry is relatively set in its ways and your current position within the industry is set, then there is less need to worry about positioning or pursuit. Your position is already fairly firmly set and most of the pursuit activities have already occurred. Hence, the key focus is on how to squeeze a little bit more profitability out of your current situation through productivity.
Conversely, you will have an opposite focus if your industry is in the following situation:
i. Embrionic or Early Growth Stage of lifecycle.
ii. Instability in the rules of the industry, the players in the industry, or the technology in the industry.
iii. Low Barriers to Entry or Exit
In these types of situations, there can be ambiguity about who holds what position in the marketplace and there may be opportunities to stake out new and better claims to a position. At this point, profitability is of lesser importance as investments are made to stake claim to a position which can reap great rewards later once you survive the consolidation.
Yet Still Keep Balance
In mature industries, although productivity may be the key focus, you cannot ignore the rest. Stable industries can be made unstable by new technologies or new ways of solving problems. If you are not watching the environment for these industry changers, you may find your position become obsolete.
Similarly, in the young and evolving industries, productivity is not the primary concern. However, if your cost structure is way out of line with the rest of the industry, you will probably not survive to the next level of the life cycle. Even in the heyday of the dotcom bubble, when profits seemed irrelevant, there eventually came a day of reckoning when the inefficient were erased from the marketplace.
Thus one also needs balance.
SUMMARY
The ideal design of your strategic planning process depends in part on where your industry is in its lifecycle and your current position within that industry. Once you determine this, you can put the proper emphasis on positioning, pursuit and productivity, where one or more of these get greater emphasis, but none are ignored.
FINAL THOUGHTS
This is a lot of content to cover in one blog. That is why we will be continuing the discussion in subsequent blogs.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)