Showing posts with label Starbucks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Starbucks. Show all posts

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Analogy #197: Change the Rules


THE STORY:
I used to live in a city that was having some problems with the quality of the municipal water supply. There was too much of a certain chemical in the water.

By law, when a city was in violation of water standards they had to send a letter to every household in the community. This letter had to do three things:

1) Inform people of the problem with the water;
2) Explain the risks in using the water;
3) Provide details on how the city was planning to fix the problem.

In essence, this is a summary of what the city said in the letter.

1) The levels of a particular chemical in the water exceed the maximum allowed by the government.
2) We don’t think it’s a big deal.
3) Our primary solution is to petition the government to raise the allowable levels for this chemical, so that our current levels would be considered safe.

For some reason, I did not get a lot of comfort from that letter.

THE ANALOGY:
Every industry tends to have a certain accepted way of doing business. They become the standard operating procedure—the rules for how things get done. Most of the time, these rules aren’t written down—it is just how the industry evolved.

There are reasons why these standardizations are useful:

1) Getting the entire supply chain in an industry to work smoothly requires the cooperation of many different firms. The more procedures are standardized, the easier it is for these firms to work together.

2) There is usually a limited pool of quality employees in a given industry. It’s difficult to tap into that pool of employees if your procedures are radically different from the norm, because they are trained and experienced to excel within these norms.

However, it should also be pointed out that these accepted ways of business are somewhat arbitrary. They do not have to work that way. Other processes could have just as easily have evolved over time.

In the story, it seems rather audacious that one little community would challenge the water standards set by the Federal Government. After all, it is assumed that scientists picked the maximum levels for that chemical in the water based on solid evidence. Similarly, it may seem audacious for a business to ignore the operating standards of its industry.

However, I am reminded of a conversation I had with a doctor at Mayo Clinic who was on a team of experts to determine what was the acceptable range of health should be for one of those common measures used in medicine, like blood pressure or cholesterol. He said that it’s not as if you are healthy and that all of the sudden after reaching a certain point you suddenly become unhealthy. He said it is a gradual thing and that as measures like blood pressure and cholesterol gradually go up, you gradually become less healthy.

According to this doctor, the point at which you declare one of these ranges to go from “healthy” to “unhealthy” is somewhat arbitrary. And in fact, he disagreed with the committee he was on and thought the range for “healthy” should have been narrower.

So maybe it was not that audacious after all for that city to challenge the federal water standards. And maybe it is a good thing if your business’ strategy challenges the standards of your industry.

THE PRINCIPLE:
The principle here is that industry standards are arbitrary to some degree and that sometimes it is in your best interest to change them. There are several reasons why you might want to change industry standards.

1) The standards tend to protect the established leaders. If you are not an established leader, they may become a barrier to your success.

2) The standards may not play to your natural strengths. A different set of rules might give you more of a competitive advantage.

3) Standards tend to reinforce the status quo. True innovation may require abandonment of some of these standards. In fact, almost every major innovation creates a new set of standards for how things are done. If you are unwilling to bend the rules, you may never truly innovate.

Here are some examples of firms which changed the rules in order to get an advantage. We’ll start with the typical rules in furniture. Furniture brand firms in the US tended to be large companies who desired to made their furniture in their own factories. They spent lots of money to create a consumer demand for their brands. Labor costs were high, but they were able to pass the costs on to the smaller, and less powerful retailers.

Then along came Ashley furniture. Ashley had no desire to own manufacturing facilities. When cheap labor markets like China opened up, they aggressively went into these countries to source their products from anyone who could meet their specifications. Ashley didn’t care about establishing a strong, separate brand name for their products. They just sold them under the name of their retail brand.

By abandoning the status quo and rewriting the rules, Ashley had several advantages. First, they were able to secure products far cheaper than the status quo, who were burdened with factories and unions and other costs, which were higher and less flexible. Second, by sourcing directly, Ashley entirely avoided the branded manufacturing middlemen, saving even more costs.

These savings allowed Ashley to provide a far superior value to the customer. The customer responded, and Ashley thrived. Most of the large, established furniture retailers in the US who played by the old rules have gone bankrupt. In the mean time, Ashley has catapulted to becoming the largest furniture retailer in the US.

And, of course, everyone knows the story of Starbucks. Before Starbucks, the rules about coffee went something like this. Coffee was something you consumed at home or at work. Coffee was purchased by consumers in bulk in ingredient form. The customer manufactured their own coffee. The ingredients tended to be heavily couponed and sold in supermarkets, with the choice usually made on the basis of price.

The key manufacturers, like Folgers and Maxwell House knew the rules and played by them. The consumers knew the rules and played by them. That is, until Howard Schultz came along and changed the rules. At Starbucks, you consume the coffee at the coffee shop. You buy it one cup at a time, prepared by someone else. Quality became far more important than price.

Now, consumers are drinking a lot more coffee, but Folgers and Maxwell House are struggling, because they stuck to the old rules.

I am very excited about the prospects for Alan Mulally, the new CEO at Ford Motor Company. He is an outsider who has no personal connection to the old rules about the automobile industry. As a result, he is far more inclined to rewrite those rules. I hope he is able to do so.

SUMMARY:
Industries tend to run using generally accepted rules and procedures. However, just because everyone tends to do things in a similar manner does not mean that it is necessarily the only or even the best way of doing things. It may be a result of historical quirks or factors which are no longer as relevant in a changing society. Therefore, when developing strategy, the best tactic is not always to look for ways to outdo everyone within the current paradigm. Instead, you may be better off looking for a new paradigm which plays by another set of rules.

Even if you like the status quo, one must not get too cozy with them. It is important to keep your eyes on the horizon, looking for firms who want to destroy the rules which are helping to create your success. As we have seen, if you stick to the old rules when society is migrating to the new rules, you will lose out. As a consequence, even if you prefer the old rules, you may need to quickly shift gears in order to remain relevant.

FINAL THOUGHTS:
When I received that letter from my city water company and found out how little they were prepared to do to fix the water quality, I changed the rules about the way my family consumed water. I bought a home water filtration system.

Not all rule changes are driven by innovative businesses. Some are driven by rule-changing consumers. Keep an eye on the leading edge consumers. They may already have a new set of rules in mind. All you have to do is tap into them.

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Spalding Water

THE STORY
Back about the time when sports beverages were just starting to take off, I had the opportunity to attend a huge food and beverage convention. In the gigantic exhibition hall, there was a company with a booth dedicated to pushing a new product called “Spalding Water.”

It sounded interesting, so I went up to talk to the salesman at the booth. He started praising the virtues of his “light, refreshing” sports drink, making sure I got the name association with Spalding, a company noted for its dedication to sports.

I asked him a simple question: “So this stuff has all of the electrolytes and the other chemicals to replenish your system like Gatorade?”

His answer was, “No, there are none of those replenishment chemicals in this beverage. We wanted to make sure this beverage was safe for children, so we did not put all of those chemicals in the water. Instead, we just wanted to keep it light and refreshing.”

Looking at the brightly colored water in the bottles, I responded, “So, then, is this stuff just an expensive version of Kool-Aid?”

“No, not really,” said the salesman. “Kool-Aid has a much stronger flavor. This Spalding water is lighter and more refreshing. In addition, it has much less sugar.”

I took a small sample of the beverage. After pondering his words for a brief moment, I think I started to get the picture, so I posed another question. “So what you’re telling me is that this is something which tastes liked watered down Kool-Aid where they forgot to put in all the sugar…and because it says Spalding on the bottle, I’m supposed to pay a premium price for the privilege. Is that about right?”

At that point, the salesman gave up on me. I could see in his eyes that he was unable to respond because, in essence, I had described what they had done. I know it sounded better when he described it as “light and refreshing,” but as part of a nation which grew up on Kool-Aid, I think most others would have describe it somewhat like I did, after tasting it.

And you know what? I never saw Spalding Water sold in any store. I don’t think it got much beyond the stage of being introduced at this convention.

THE ANALOGY
At some point, businesses succeed by selling something to someone at a profit. It can be either a good or a service or some combination of the two, but eventually money needs to change hands.

If you have a new product which you are introducing to the marketplace, potential customers are going to want to know what it is you are selling before they make a purchase. Like the example in the story above, I was confronted with a new product, called Spalding Water. I was trying to understand what exactly Spalding Water was. Because I eventually associated the product with something which made it appear bad—inferior Kool-Aid—I became uninterested in the product.

If you want to succeed, you need to be proactive in making sure that you help the customer define the product in a favorable light. This is accomplished through making sure it compares favorably to an alternative (“more refreshing than plain water”) rather than unfavorably to an alternative (“less flavorful than Kool-Aid”).

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is relativity, or the idea of reference points. Great positioning strategies tend to target a new space which is not already claimed by someone else. For example, Starbucks chose a great position for coffee which was pretty much untapped in the United States. Unfortunately, because it was a new position, customers did not have any experience with the position. In order to make sense out of the new position (which they did not fully understand or appreciate), people would try to compare it to something which they did understand.

The item they compare it to becomes the reference point. The customer compares the new product to their reference point to see if they think it will be better or worse. If they decide it is relatively better than the reference point, you stand a better chance of making a sale.

In Starbuck’s case, a common reference point could have been how the person was currently purchasing coffee—in five pound cans of Maxwell House at the supermarket. With that as their reference point, the relative conclusion could have been as follows: Why should I make a special trip to stand in line to get a single cup of coffee at Starbucks which costs almost as much as an entire can of Maxwell House, when I can conveniently just pick up a can at the supermarket and brew it any time I want?

With that as a reference point, Starbucks appears to be relatively worse. However, Starbucks was clever in changing the reference point. Instead of being seen as a more expensive and less convenient way to get a cup of coffee, Starbucks chose a different way to portray their offering. They positioned it as a very inexpensive way to get a high quality diversion and indulgence into your humdrum life (and oh, by the way, there is some coffee in there somewhere as an added bonus). With alternative forms of partial day diversions as the reference point, Starbucks suddenly appears more desirable.

New positions are naturally at a disadvantage in the beginning, because they are asking consumers to not only change their behavior, but to change the way they think about their world. New products succeed by making current reference points appear inferior or irrelevant. We all tend to be creatures of habit who find comfort in our current reference points. Therefore, strategic success requires not only time spent in creating wonderful new positions, but time spend in helping make sure the new position compares favorably to the current, dominant reference point. And if it doesn’t compare favorably, then we need to help customers find a different reference point.

In the case of Spalding Water, it was branded with a name associated with sports and athleticism. They also referred to it as a sports drink. Therefore, my reference point at first was the dominant sports drink of Gatorade. Since Gatorade dominated the category of “sports drinks”, my reference point for what a sports drink should be was to be what Gatorade is. Gatorade is designed to help athletes replenish the necessary chemicals lost when sweating through athletic activity. Therefore, my first reaction was that for this to be a successful sports drink, it would need to do a better job of replenishing those chemicals than Gatorade.

Spalding Water, however, made no attempt to even try to replenish these chemicals. Therefore, using my reference point for what a sports drink should be, I claimed Spalding Water to be a failure.

So then the salesman said that it was not targeted at athletes as much as it was at children. My reference point for a children’s beverage was Kool-Aid. As a comparison to my reference point of Kool-Aid, Spalding Water came off as being less flavorful and less sweet (and we all know that the sweetness is why kids love it so much). So again, the product failed against my reference point.

The problem was that Spalding Water had not convinced me that it had come up with a new position, and when I compared it to current positions it failed relative to my reference points. What the salesman should have told me was that this was a beverage targeted to concerned mothers. These are mothers concerned that their precious children are not hydrating themselves enough during the day. These mothers know that if they try to push a lot of water at their children, they will eventually balk at it, so they will remain dehydrated.

At the same time, these concerned mothers do not want to shove a lot of soda or Kool-Aid at their children because of the negative health impact of taking these products in excess. Therefore, Spalding Water is the perfect beverage for concerned mothers because it has just enough flavor and coolness to get their children to drink enough to get hydrated, but not so many additives to cause negative side effects like sodas or Kool-Aid or even adult-strength sports beverages.

Now this would have been a position for which I would have needed a different reference point. I would then have had to ask myself if I thought children would be more likely to hydrate themselves properly if a concerned mother was forcing them to drink a lot of water or drink a lot of Spalding Water. In that case, the reference point would have been tap water, and the Spalding Water would be cooler and more likely to be consumed in enough quantity to give this paranoid mother the assurance that their child was properly hydrated.

SUMMARY
New positions require proactive management of reference points, so that when the customers are confronted with the new position, they compare it to something in their mind for which the new position appears relatively superior. If reference point management is not a part of your strategic plan, consumers may choose reference points which make your product appear inferior. Don’t leave it up to chance. Be explicit in how you want your new product to compare to the current familiar reference points.

FINAL THOUGHTS
When attempting to get someone to switch from a current habit and instead purchase what you are selling, in a way you are forcing a consumer to admit that their past behavior was a mistake. Nobody likes to admit a lifetime of mistaken behavior. That is why ultimately positioning yourself as “new” can be superior to positioning yourself as just a better version of a solution already owned by someone else. This way, instead of forcing the consumer to admit they had habitually purchased the wrong solution, they only have to admit that they are solving a different problem. This will make them more receptive to switching without guilt.

Saturday, April 28, 2007

Too Many Clocks

The Story
My first job out of college was as Assistant to the President of a furniture retailer. This retailer sold a fair amount of grandfather clocks—enough so that there was a separate selling room in the store just for displaying a large number of these clocks.

On one of my first weeks on the job, I noticed that the grandfather clocks were all set at different, and seemingly random, times. I thought I would do everyone a favor and set all of the grandfather clocks to the same time that was on my watch. There were many clocks, so this took a bit of time.

After I finished, the president of the company saw what I had done and told me to go back and reset all of the clocks to different random times. I was a little upset because of all the time it took to set the clocks to the time on my watch, so the president explained why he wanted them switched back. This is basically what he said…

Grandfather clocks are relatively expensive timepieces. As a result, customers want to make sure the clocks keep accurate time. Since the potential customer is not going to stare at the clock all day long to check how well the clock keeps time, the typical customer uses a short-cut. The short-cut is to compare the time on the clock to a reference point to see if the both have the same exact time.

For example, the customer may compare the time on the grandfather clock to the time on his or her watch. The likelihood that I set that clock to exactly the same time as that customer’s watch is highly unlikely. Since the watch and the clock are not exactly identical in time, one must conclude that at least one of them—if not both—are inaccurate. If the clock is not accurate in displaying the correct time, then there is a feeling that the clock may not be accurate in keeping time.

Another reference point would be to compare all of the grandfather clocks in the room to each other. The likelihood that I was able to set all of the clocks to exactly the same time is also highly unlikely. Since all of the clocks would be slightly different from each other in the time they are displaying, the customer could not have confidence that any of the clocks are accurate. The customer would wonder how all these clocks could be accurate if they are all showing slightly different times. In fact, the more clocks in the room, the more likely they would convince the customer that they were inaccurate.

By contrast, if all of the clocks are set at different and random times that are nowhere near the current time, then there is no reference point. The customer then has no reason to assume that the clocks are inaccurate, because there is no known variance. If fact, given the high price the clocks were being sold for, the customer might assume that the clock is built well enough to keep accurate time.

The irony is that the further away the clocks are from the current time, the more accurate they will appear to the customer. I quickly caught on to what the president was saying and immediately changed the clocks back to random and different times.

The Analogy
Strategic planning and clocks both have something in common. Both are used to better understand the time. Clocks are used to help us understand the current time. Strategic planning is used to help us better understand time in the future. Rather than looking at a clock to tell the time, strategic planners look at research. Strategic planning is all about trying to build a more successful future. Research helps planners understand what kind of future they are trying to build that success in. The better one understands the future environment, the more likely one can design the proper plan for that future.

There is an odd relationship between clocks and the perception of their accuracy. If you have only one clock, when you want to know the time, you just look at it and assume it is accurate, without even thinking about it. However, if you want to know what time it is and you have two clocks to check, your feeling of confidence in their accuracy goes down because they will not be exactly the same. Since you do not know which of the two clocks is accurate, a bit of doubt fills your mind. You are less confident that you know the real time, since you now have more options to choose from—the first clock, the second clock or something in-between. If you add a third clock the confidence goes down even more, because there is even more variability in the times being displayed.

The irony is that the more clocks you check, the more uncertainty you have regarding your confidence in knowing what the exact time is. If you have an entire room of clocks, like the store in the story above, there is a feeling that you will never know the exact time. There are too many different options to choose from. By looking at all of the clocks in the room you may feel reasonably confident that the time is, say, approximately two o’clock in the afternoon. However, you will never know when it is exactly two o’clock.

Adding more clocks will not help the situation. Two rooms of clocks will not give you any more of a sense of the accurate time than one room of clocks. You will know no more than you did before—that the approximate time is around two o’clock.

A similar situation occurs when gathering research for strategic planning. After a certain point, the amount of research you have gathered may start pointing to a rough approximation of where the future may evolve. However, it will never give you an exact knowledge of what the future will look like. There is too much variability in the research—they never say exactly the same thing about the future.

Further research in that area will not increase your accuracy. You will know no more than you did before—the same approximation of what the future may look like. Two rooms full of research will not get you any closer to accuracy than one room of research.

The Principle
There is a phenomenon that often occurs in strategic planning referred to as the “paralysis of analysis.” The phenomenon occurs with people who are afraid to take action until they have a certainty of information. Since there is never certainty about the future, these people procrastinate about taking any action. Instead of implementing a plan, they decide to find additional research. The reasoning is that, if one gets additional information, one can make a make a better decision later. Therefore, the person waits for more research.

However, as we saw above, after a certain point, additional research does not increase the accuracy of your prediction. The additional research just keeps roughly circulating around the same approximate direction. If your plan is to continue searching for research until you reach certainty, you will be researching forever, because certainty will never be found. Hence the term “paralysis of analysis.” The person is paralyzed and unable to take any action towards building a better future because he or she is lost in an endless cycle of gathering and analyzing research. While this person is paralyzed, a competitor may not be, which gives the competitor the opportunity to win a better position in the future than the paralyzed one.

Planning is not an exact science. There is always a little bit of uncertainty. Action will need to be taken with less than perfect information.

Going back to the clock story, most people are able to function and take appropriate action in the current moment even if they know that the clocks in their life are not 100% accurate. As long as one knows that it is approximately two o’clock, then that is good enough to take action. This same attitude needs to be applied to thinking about the future. One needs to be able to take appropriate actions towards the future even if one knows that the research possessed about the future is not 100% accurate.

There are three reasons why any additional research beyond a base level will never achieve greater clarity about knowing the future:

1. Consumers are Unreliable in Predicting What they will do in the Future
2. The Future is Not Destiny
3. By the Time Something is Completely Knowable, it is Too Late to Make a Meaningful Strategic Impact.

These are all discussed below.

1. Consumers are Unreliable in Predicting What they will do in the Future. History has shown that consumers are terrible at predicting what they will do in the future, especially as it relates to activities surrounding situations they have not yet encountered. As a result, research that asks your consumers about what they will do in the future has significant limitations. Sony is proud to point out that no consumer has ever asked for any of the myriad of successful inventions they have introduced. If Sony had waited for research to tell them what to invent, none of those items would have been invented. Rather than doing rooms full of specific consumer research, one needs to rely more on generalized research about the basic needs and desires of your consumers and then make inferences about how your plan would play to those basic needs and desires. Consumer research about the future will never give you the specific answer about what to do. At best, it will tell you what general areas or qualities to focus on.

2. The Future is not Destiny. Because I have spent decades studying the retail industry, I am often asked my opinion regarding future trends in retailing. When asked about a particular retail trend, I often respond by saying, “I will not answer your question until you answer a question for me. How aggressively do you think Wal-Mart will be in adopting this trend or in trying to block this trend?” The point I am trying to make is that the future is not written in stone. The future is not an unalterable destiny to be discovered. Instead, the future is changeable. Wal-Mart is so big and powerful, that the decisions it makes can significantly alter the way a retail trend evolves. If Wal-Mart decides to go after a particular business with a particular format, then the trends surrounding that format will be larger and occur faster than what would have occurred if Wal-Mart had not participated.

The same principle applies to you. Since the actions of you and others can alter how the future unfolds, no amount of research alone will ever be able to accurately predict the future. Rather than spending all of your time analyzing two rooms of research, it is better to have spent some of that time considering how you can use your influence to alter the future. Rather than only looking for ways to discover the future, look for ways to create the future.

If the future were 100% certain, then there would be no way to alter it. If one could not alter the future, then one could not alter his or her level of success in that future. If that is the case, then there is no point in planning. It is precisely because the future is not destiny that makes planning so important. Your strategic plans can alter the course of the future. The better your plans, the better your future.

3. By the Time Something is Completely Knowable, it is Too Late to Make a Meaningful Strategic Impact. Often times, the most successful plans are ones in which your company is the first to make a meaningful impact in a new space. If you wait until the space is completely defined and understood before entering, it is often too late. Starbucks rapidly expanded into the new space it created well before it was completely understood. There were no books describing in detail the types of coffee shops that Starbucks invented. In fact, the conventional wisdom based on the research of the time was that consumers wanted their coffee to be inexpensive and convenient. Starbucks was expensive and time consuming.

If you are waiting for all of the research to be written down in complete detail in a book before taking any action, you will be too late. The only way to get research in that much detail is to wait until the market is already fully developed. By the time it is fully developed, your ability to enter and win in that space is severely limited. It is better to get into a new space early and learn via experimentation rather than wait for all of the facts before taking any action.

With all of that said, this is not an excuse to avoid doing any research. Research is still an important part of any strategic planning process. However, the goal should not be to gather rooms full of data in search of exact information. The goal is to gather enough information to get a general impression of how the future may evolve and then start crafting your actions.

Summary
Strategic planning deals with the future. Just as clocks help us understand the current time, research helps planners understand future time. Gathering rooms full of clocks will not give you certainty of the current time. Neither will rooms full of research give you certainty of the future. There are diminishing returns to time spent getting and analyzing research. Just as you can have too many clocks, you can have too much analysis. Gather enough to get a feeling for the general trends and then supplement the research with activities and experiments. Otherwise, you may fall into the trap of “paralysis of analysis.”

Final Thoughts
General George S. Patton is famous for saying that “A good plan violently executed now is better than a perfect plan executed next week.” The goal of strategic planning is not to create a perfect plan. The goal is to create a better future. This requires more than just planning. It requires doing. Good research and good planning can help you reduce the risk of doing the wrong thing. But if you never get around to doing anything because of the search for the perfect plan, the plans do you no good.