Showing posts with label strategic planning department. Show all posts
Showing posts with label strategic planning department. Show all posts

Friday, September 14, 2012

Strategic Planning Analogy #469: Mirror, Mirror


 
THE STORY
I knew a woman who didn’t like the way she looked.  She wanted a quick and easy way to solve the problem…and she found one.

She took all the mirrors out of her house.

 
THE ANALOGY
Yes, getting rid of the mirrors meant that she could no longer see the way she looked.  And yes, by not seeing the way she looked, she no longer was reminded of the way she looked, so it did not bother her anymore.  But it didn’t change the way she looked.  The problem was merely avoided, not eliminated.

Company leaders often take a similar approach.  They are uncomfortable with their long-term prospects (or how to deal with them).  As a result, they only focus on what they are comfortable with—the near-term issues (the crisis of the day).  They never take the time to examine the firm with a look at the long-term.  The long-term views are eliminated like mirrors, so that you can no longer see how dire the future might be.

Although that may be the comfortable way to eliminate dealing with the issue, it doesn’t solve the problem.  It merely avoids the problem.  Eventually, long-term issues will catch up with you.  And if you haven’t dealt with them in advance, they can destroy your business.

 
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that the future is will come, whether you are paying attention to it or not.  The more you pay attention to it in advance, the better it will be.

Back in the 1980s, Gary Hamel and CK Prahalad wrote an article for the Harvard Business Review saying that senior executives should be spending about a third of their time looking into that future mirror.  Instead, what they found was that senior executives were only spending about 3% of their time looking into that mirror.  I don’t think those numbers have changed significantly since then. 

The tyranny of the immediate always seems to win over gazing into the long-term.  And there is a serious price to pay for this.

Why ignoring the future is a mistake:

1) The Future Determines Your Valuation
The value of a company or business is not based on what happened in the past or what is happening now.  It is based on what will happen in the future.  Companies are cash flow machines and today’s value of the firm or business is roughly the sum of its future cash flows brought back at some discount rate.

Look at the social media firms like Facebook.  Their extremely high stock valuations cannot be justified by what is happening today.  They can only be justified by future expectations.

If you want a high valuation for your firm or business, then you need to have a compelling story about the future and future cash flows.  And you won’t have that story if you ignore the future and only concentrate on the here and now (by throwing away the long-term mirrors).

The question is not what have you done for me lately, but what are you going to do for me tomorrow.  And a great tomorrow won’t happen by accident.

2) Others Are Still Looking at Your Future
In the story, the woman no longer fretted about how she looked because she could no longer see what she looked like.  However, throwing out the mirrors did not stop others from looking at her.  And if they were turned off by her appearance, she would still have problems.  It could hurt her social life, hurt her career and lead to a less desirable life.

The same is true in business.  Consumers look at you; bankers look at you; private equity looks at you; parent companies look at you; clients look at you; vendors look at you; competition looks at you.  If they don’t like your future prospects, they can make your life miserable.  They will take away funding.  They will take away business.  They will assume you are a higher risk and charge you more for their services.  As a result, you will have even more near-term crises and more dire future prospects.

3) Others Are Preparing their Future
If everyone was equally blind to the future, we would all be similarly handicapped.  However, there are always those companies who seriously work to optimize their long-term prospects.  Their proactive approach will help define how the future unfolds.  And since they are working for their own advantage, the future will not unfold to your advantage.  You will become weaker as they become stronger.

Remember that if you don’t define a place for yourself in the future, someone else will define it for you…and you probably won’t like the results.

4) The Future is not Always Incremental
The future does not roll out as a smooth continuous line of incremental improvement.  Major disruptions can occur.  Just ask anyone in the analog business who got wiped out by the digital revolution (like Kodak, traditional newspapers, etc.).  So just trying to get better at the status quo will at some point break down.

So if your head is only looking down at what is in front of you today and all you are trying to do is make it incrementally better, faster, or cheaper, then at some point you will have the best, fastest, cheapest obsolete item on the market.

Only by looking to the future will you have the foresight needed to adapt to the non-incrmental change (which is inevitable)—hopefully with enough advance notice in order take advantage of the leap rather than be a victim of it.

So What is the Solution?
If top management has a little trouble finding sufficient time (or desire) to stare into the mirror, then someone else needs to be doing it for them.  That would be a key role of a strategic planning group.  By being freed a bit more from the tyranny of the immediate, they can spend more time looking into the mirror and pondering what the future looks like.  

Then, as a trusted advisor (and a bit of a nag), the strategy group can ensure that the voice of the future is at the table when decisions are being made.

 
SUMMARY
The future will come, whether we are ready for it or not.  And the future will be better if we are prepared in advance.  After all, that’s where today’s value comes from—our potential future prospects.  And if top management cannot carve out enough time to do so, then strategic planning can add significant value by doing much of it on behalf of senior management.  That alone should make every executive team want to have a vibrant strategic planning unit.

 
FINAL THOUGHTS
There’s an old saying which goes something like this:  “Blessed is the company which never does any long-term planning, for their inevitable demise will come as a complete surprise to them (and they won’t have wasted all that time in worry about it).”  A better blessing would be to properly prepare for the future so that you can be rewarded with long prosperity.  Look into those long-term mirrors.

Friday, October 1, 2010

Strategic Planning Analogy #355: Measuring Up


THE STORY
I used to work for a company that was big into metrics. They wanted to measure everything. As a result, the budgeting department sent a form to each department. On this form, they wanted each department to suggest a key metric to be measured by and a targeted goal with that metric for the following year.

Being in a Strategic Planning Department, I had a hard time thinking of what an appropriate metric for us should be. In talking it over, the department decided that our greatest contributions to the company were ideas. Therefore, we put on the form that our department should be measured by the number of ideas we come up with.

Then we had to come up with a goal for this metric. We picked an arbitrary number. I think it was 1,000. Therefore, we put on the form that our goal was to come up with “at least 1,000 ideas” in the following year.

We turned in the form. We never once heard back from the budget department on our suggestion. That was fine by me.

THE ANALOGY
I don’t think Strategic Planning Departments are well suited to annual metrics. One of their primary functions is to improve the long-term prosperity of the business. This is hard to put into an annual metric, because:

1) You usually do not know how much the long-term prosperity of the business is improved until many years later (falling outside the annual metric).

2) Since there is no control group, it is hard to measure how much of the improvement in a business’ long-term performance was as a result of the strategic planning department (vs. how much would have happened anyway).

3) If a plan fails, it is often difficult to determine how much of the failure was due to the quality of the plan versus the quality of the implementation. Since strategic Planning Departments are more responsible for the quality of the plan (while line operators are more responsible for implementation), it becomes difficult to determine how much credit (or blame) to assign to the strategic planning department versus the implementers.

4) When things go bad, there is always the excuse that “It would have been even worse without the strategic planning department.” Again, this is very difficult to measure.

Since long-term prosperity is a difficult annual metric, companies often look to simpler measures for a Strategic Planning Department, like staying within their budget or successfully completing a planning cycle process. Although these are easier to measure on an annual basis, they still have problems. In particular, there is no correlation between doing well on these measures and in improving the long term prosperity of a business. Creating a planning document on time and within budget does not mean that it is a good plan.

That is why my department did not take the budget exercise in the story seriously.

That being said, one might also conclude that it is not worthwhile to assign metrics to the strategic plan itself. However, I think that would be a mistake. Strategic Plans are not the same as Strategic Planning Departments. Although I think that planning departments are hard to measure, I believe that strategic plans can and should be measured.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that a good strategic plan outlines certain conditions which are necessary in order for the plan to succeed. One can and should measure whether or not these events occur, because if they do not occur, your future is in trouble.

As I’ve mentioned in the past, a good plan should encompass three areas:

1) Positioning
2) Pursuit
3) Productivity

Conditions should be assigned to these areas and they should be measured.

1) Positioning
A position provides the reason why your business exists (from the customer’s perspective). It gives potential customers a reason to prefer your business versus the alternatives. For example, Wal-Mart owns the low price position, which is a reason to prefer it over higher-priced retail alternatives. Mercedes-Benz owns the prestige position, giving a reason to prefer it over other, less prestigious automobile options.

The position is the place where you need to win if the strategy is ever going to succeed. If you do not give customers a legitimate reason to prefer you, they will prefer someone else.

Positions are won in the minds of your desired consumer segment. They either believe it (and give you credit for owning it) or they do not. Your position is only real if they perceive it to be so.

Therefore, if you want to measure the effectiveness of your positioning efforts, you need to measure what is going on in the minds of your desired customer segment. How many believe that you own your desired position? This includes not only the customers who have already purchased from you, but consumers in your desired segment who have not purchased from you. Even if they have not purchased from you, they probably have an opinion about what you stand for, and that opinion may be what is keeping them away.

2) Pursuit
Pursuit includes the plan to obtain all of the necessary pre-conditions in order to deliver on the promise of the position. This includes things like:

A. Competency—the expertise to know how to deliver on the promise of where you want to win;

B. Capacity—the infrastructure needed to deliver on the promise; and

C. Contacts—proper access to all the other players in the business ecosystem needed to deliver on the promise.

Depending upon your position, there will be different priorities in what you need to pursue.

For example, if Wal-Mart is going to excel at delivering a low price retail position, it needs expertise in low price retailing, an efficient infrastructure of stores and distribution centers with enough capacity to take advantage of economies of scale, and the proper relationships with key vendors and suppliers.

These are measurable conditions. Either you have them or you don’t. Strategic plans should provide a roadmap of where you are deficient and what needs to be done to fill the gap. And then you measure the extent to which the gap is been filled.

And since we live in a dynamic environment, what is necessary to win on your position changes over time. New expertise may be needed, improved infrastructure may be required, new contacts may be needed. A good plan anticipates this dynamic so that you can stay ahead of the curve on pursuing what you need to win in the future. You can measure your progress on these as well.

3. Productivity
Productivity is needed in order to ensure that your costs to pursue the position do not exceed the benefits of owning the position. Productivity includes activities such as:

A. Action Trade-offs—Cutting expenditures in less important areas so that you can afford to spend more in areas more critical to the position.

B. Efficiency Efforts—Eliminating Waste without Eliminating Effectiveness

C. Investing in projects which will increase long-term productivity (sometimes you have to spend money in order to save money).

D. Cash Management—Reducing receivables, increasing payables, reducing interest payments, etc.

Particular goals and actions can be addressed in the plan regarding these types of productivity issues. These can be measured.

What Not To Measure
Specific conditions related to positioning, pursuit and productivity can and should be measured. However, there are other metrics which should be avoided (or at least downplayed). The metrics to avoid or downplay are those which can be achieved while ignoring the strategy. For example, look at a metric like sales. There are lots of ways to boost sales in the short run. Many of these methods can damage or destroy a long term positioning.

Toyota, for example, recently got sidetracked into a pursuit of growing sales as fast as they could. To achieve this growth, they took their eyes off the key position of reliability. As a result, reliability slipped, and now Toyota is having to spend a fortune to recapture its position.

Just focusing on sales will not necessarily achieve the plan. But if you properly focus on positioning, pursuit and productivity, the right kind of sales will naturally come.

So, when choosing metrics, ask yourself this question: Is it possible to excel in this metric without advancing the plan? If so, eliminate or downplay that metric.

SUMMARY
Although it may be difficult to apply metrics to a strategic planning department, that shouldn’t stop you from applying metrics to the strategic plan. But not all metrics are good metrics. The metrics you choose should be specifically related to actions which advance the plan. In particular, they should measure:

A. Whether consumers believe in your position;
B. Whether you have properly pursued in getting what is needed to deliver on the promise of the position;
C. Whether you have taken specific steps to increase productivity without compromising your ability to deliver on the promise of the position.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Of course, if the best metrics are those designed to measure positioning, pursuit and productivity, then you’d better first create a plan which addresses the issues of positioning, pursuit and productivity. It amazes me how many plans ignore this first step.

Monday, September 27, 2010

Strategic Planning Analogy #353: Warning!


THE STORY
Awhile back, I was awakened in the night by beeping smoke detectors. It wasn’t the high pitched squeal warning me of fire. It was just the beep to warn me that the batteries were low. But it woke me up anyway.

This was a newly built house which still had the original batteries in the smoke detectors. I didn’t even know how many smoke detectors were in the house. As I stumbled around half-asleep, I discovered six smoke detectors and took out their batteries (for one I needed a ladder). But I could still hear a beeping. As it turns out, there were seven smoke detectors, and it took me forever to find that seventh one.

Then I got dressed and went to a store open all night in order to purchase replacement batteries. When I got home, I had to remember where those seven smoke detectors were, so that I could put in the new batteries (which wasn’t easy). By the time I was done, I had trouble getting back to sleep.

Why can’t these things happen in the middle of the day?

THE ANALOGY
The purpose of a smoke detector is to monitor the environment. If it detects the early signs of a fire, it gives a warning so that you can escape to safety before it is too late.

The strategic planner serves a similar function. One of the roles of a strategic planner is to monitor the environment, looking for early signs that the environment is changing. Ideally, the planner will then make key executives aware of the problem early enough so that the company can adapt to the change before it is too late.

Smoke detectors are such valuable warning tools that there are laws mandating that they be placed in houses in key locations (which is why my house has seven of them). Let me tell you, if it weren’t for those laws, I would have been tempted that night to yank out some of those pesky detectors that were keeping me awake.

Fortunately for me, those laws are there to keep me safe. Unfortunately for businesses, there are not similar laws mandating that businesses have enough strategic planners to adequately monitor the business environment to keep them safe.

If you cannot make a compelling case for having “strategic smoke detectors” at your business, you could miss the early warning signs and your business could be destroyed by the fires of change.

THE PRINCIPLE
We live in a world where the idea of having full-time, on-site strategic planners is becoming ever rarer. To many, the idea sounds quaint and obsolete. Yet, just as smoke detectors are still relevant and critical to ensuring the long term security of the building occupants, full-time strategic planners are still relevant and critical to the long-term security of the business.

If we treated smoke detectors the same way many companies treat strategic planning, we would be seen as reckless fools (as we shall see in the three examples below). Let’s stop the foolishness! Mandate the full-time staffing of strategic monitors.

1. Wait Until There Is a Fire to Buy A Smoke Detector
What if someone said “Fire detectors are only useful when there is a fire, so I won’t buy one until I know there is a fire.”? You’d probably think that person was a bit crazy.

By the time your nose or eyes could detect a fire (without the aid of a smoke detector), the fire may already be quite large. It might be too late to escape. This is not the time to think about running out and buying a smoke detector. At this point, about all you can do is frantically try to keep from dying.

As silly as this sounds for smoke detectors, I have seen a similar approach to strategic planning. The comment goes something like this:

“I don’t need a full-time strategic planner. I’ll just wait until I get into a jam and then bring in a strategic planning consultant.”

The problem with this line of reasoning is that by the time a company is already in a jam, it may be too late to bring in strategic planning. You may not see the signs of problems in your income statement or balance sheet until competing forces and consumer change have already engulfed your business in the flames of your own obsolescence. The world has already passed you by with superior go-to-market strategies which are more relevant to the new environment.

The best time to adapt to a changing environment is early on, when you still are operating from a position of strength and relevancy—when you still have the time and the cash flow necessary to adjust. This type of situation requires having strategic planners on site all the time, monitoring and adjusting in the early stages—when things may still look good to the naked eye. If you don’t bring in the strategic planning until the time and cash flow are nearly gone, there is little the strategist can do to help you prosper. At this point, about all you can do is hope to escape without dying.

Have you ever noticed that whenever a company issues a press release saying that they have recently hired a strategic planner to help them “examine strategic alternatives” that the end result is usually either selling the company or declaring bankruptcy? That’s because if you wait until the fires of change have already made your company irrelevant before looking for alternatives, then bankruptcy or selling out (to someone who adapted sooner and better to the change) are about the only alternatives left.

2. Complain When the Smoke Detector Doesn’t Make a Sound
What if—on that night when I was changing batteries in my smoke detectors—I had said, “These smoke detectors are worthless. They have never once warned me about a fire. They cost me money as well as the time and expense of replacing the batteries. I think I’ll get rid of them.”

If I said that, you’d think I was pretty short-sited. Just because my house had never caught on fire does not mean that the smoke detectors were worthless. They were still faithfully monitoring the environment. They were still ready to act the moment they detected change. Had there been a fire, I would have been protected. Taking the smoke detectors out makes me vulnerable to any future fires.

Eliminating smoke detectors is silly and short-sighted, but a similar approach is often taken with strategic planning. Things may be going well at the business and there may be little need at the immediate moment for drastic strategic change. Therefore, a business might conclude that strategic planning isn’t doing much or isn’t needed much. As a result, they eliminate the department.

Just because the alarm has not yet sounded does not mean that you should eliminate the alarm. Change is inevitable. Some day you will need that alarm. Having strategic planning on site all the time is the only way to ensure that you will have the alarm when you need the alarm.

Do we get angry when we live another day and do not yet need our life insurance? No…we are happy in knowing we are still alive and in knowing we are prepared just in case. The same is true of strategic planning. It is insurance against change. Eliminate the planners and you no longer have that protection. Sometimes strategic advice to “stay the course” is the best advice a strategist can give. Be happy that the strategy is still working for another day. Don’t fire the strategist because he has no new strategic change agenda.

3. Complain When the Alarm Sounds
What if my house caught on fire and my smoke detectors started blaring away in the middle of the night. Wouldn’t you think I was a bit crazy if I started getting upset over all the noise from the alarms and hated them for waking me up? Instead, I should be grateful that they woke me up so that I could get to safety.

Yet, I have seen similar reactions to strategic planners. Part of the role of strategic planning is to help companies change to adapt to the changing environment. Their call for change is often essential if I want my business to be in a safe position for the future. However, instead of the leaders being grateful for the wake-up warning, they complain. The leaders grumble about being woken up from the daily grind and commanded to change. They don’t want to change. They label the planners as excessive worriers who have too much of a negative attitude. As a result, they stop listening to the warnings.

If we want to be successful as strategic planners, we need to manage our image so that our warnings are properly heeded. An alarm clock is worthless if the user just turns off the alarm and goes back to sleep. We need to sound our alarm in such a way as to keep management from just turning us off and going back to sleep.

SUMMARY
There are many businesses today which do not fully appreciate the value of having a permanent strategic planning department on site. This attitude is like not wanting to have permanent smoke detectors on site. Just as eliminating smoke detectors leaves you vulnerable to fires, eliminating strategic planners leaves a company vulnerable to obsolescence. If you do not make a strong case for having such a permanent planning department, you can be putting your company at significant risk.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Not only will this current trend put businesses at risk, it also puts your career at risk if you are a strategic planner. That should give you added incentive to make the case for keeping permanent strategic planning departments.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Professional Vs. Passin' Through


INTRODUCTION
Some companies like their strategic planning areas to be full of strategic planning professionals, who see this discipline as a long-term career choice. Other companies like to fill their strategic planning areas with young, fast-track, up-and-coming operators who are being groomed for bigger things and are only in planning on a temporary basis. Which is better?

In my opinion, either extreme can cause problems. I prefer a balanced mix of both professionals and those who are passing through.

THE PROS AND CONS OF ALL PROFESSIONALS
The benefit of filling your strategic planning department with professional planners is that they have the proper long-term strategic mindset. They know all the proper tools to use. They are trained to think strategically. And since their professional focus is on long-range planning, they are less likely to become distracted by the day to day fires that need to be put out, and therefore can stay on the long-term task better.

Unfortunately, if all you have are strategic planning professionals, there is a risk that they can become too theoretical/academic and lose site of the realities of the business. This can lower their stature in the organization and make it harder to get the respect of the people who have to implement it. Second, good strategies exploit the nuances of the business, and people who have not spent some time in operations may not fully understand or appreciate those nuances.

THE PROS AND CONS OF ALL TEMPORARY OPERATING EXECUTIVES
The benefit of using key operating executives on a temporary basis is that they tend to have a more intimate understanding of how the business works. They also tend to be better connected to the people who have to put the strategy into action, which can give them an edge in strategic implementation.

However, if the entire planning function is put into the hands of people who are “passing through” there are negative consequences. First, if you know the assignment is short-term, there is not much incentive to focus on long-term results (which won’t have an impact until after you have passed through). Instead of comprehensive, integrated long-range plans, you are more likely to get a series of short-term “special projects.”

Second, even if intentions are good, if you are not trained in strategy, how good can you ultimately be at it? Without some professionals around, there is nobody to train these operators in strategic skills. The qualifications to be a good operations manager are often quite different than what makes for a good strategist. It doesn’t always work to switch roles—it may be a poor fit and not come naturally.

THE BENEFIT OF A BLEND
Therefore, in my opinion, there should be a blend of both professional planners and temporary operations people within a company’s strategic planning area. The benefits:

1) The operators help to keep the professionals grounded in reality.
They can let the group know when they are getting too academic or if the ideas are too impractical or too unrealistic to put into practice in the “real world.”

2) The professionals help to teach the operators about strategic thinking. This could be one of the greatest advantages of the blend. As operators flow through the department, you get each of them to think and act more strategically. They will take this knowledge with them when they go back into operations. As you do this over time, you will create a company where strategic thinking has been spread throughout the organization, like a good virus.

3) Implementation improves via better trust and better networking. People in the field will trust the professionals more (and view them less as out-of-touch academics) if they know that some of their own were involved in the process. This greater acceptance will help when handing off the strategy to the implementers. Even more importantly, by having some of the operators pass through, the professionals get exposed to more people. This improves their network, making it easier for the professionals to reach out to the field when they need to.

I think the blend works best if there are more professionals than those who are passing through. This reduces the amount of time lost in getting people acclimated to their new temporary role as a strategic planner. There is better continuity and a stronger learning curve if there are more professionals around to do the work on a long-term basis. Also, since the work load is strategic planning, I think results are better if most of the people in the area are experts in strategic planning.

For example, you may put a few operators into an R&D function to help ground the research in practical applications, but you would still want most of the researchers to be scientists and/or engineers. These professionals know how to do R&D. I think the same principle applies to strategic planning.

SUMMARY
When putting together a strategic planning department, there should be a blend of strategic planning professionals as well as operations executives rotating through on a temporary basis. Within the blend, I think most should be strategic planning professionals.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Some firms like to rotate through professional planners. They do this by hiring professional strategic planning consulting firms to come in from time to time. Although this can work, it also has some risks. First, since they are outsiders, they may not understand the nuances of your business (which are often the source of a lot of strategic advantage). Second, these consultants are more likely to pull out a generic strategy from their bag of tricks than to create a strategy specifically designed for you. Third, they are usually gone before implementation is over, leaving you to clean up any of their messes. Finally, because they tend to work the entire industry, they will use what they learned at your firm with their other clients. Where’s the competitive advantage if all the firms are working off the same generic strategy?