Showing posts with label Supply Chain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supply Chain. Show all posts

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Strategic Planning Analogy #506: Perspective



THE STORY

Let’s assume that a government transportation committee examined whether to add more lanes to an urban highway. 

The conclusion of their study went something like this:

Yes, we concede that during a brief period of the day (rush hour), the highway becomes highly congested and traffic stops moving. However, outside of rush hour, the highway is operating well below capacity and flows very smoothly. Since the highway is well below capacity for approximately 85% of the day, we see no reason to add any lanes. After all, 85% efficiency for a highway is quite acceptable.

The response from a consumer group advocating extra lanes went something like this:

The reason why the highway flows well outside of rush hour is because that is not the time when the highway is most used and most needed. According to our research, 85% of the cars using the highway use it during the congested rush hour period when cars greatly outnumber the current highway capacity. Since the highway is well above capacity when 85% of the drivers are on it, we see a clear justification for adding more lanes to the highway. After all, 85% inefficiency for a highway is quite unacceptable.

So is the current highway 85% efficient or 85% inefficient?


THE ANALOGY

Strategy creation involves making decisions. Facts are a key input for making those decisions. In fact, I had a boss once who on a daily basis would say that he would not make any decisions unless they were “fact-based.”

But how reliable is the “fact-based” approach? In the story above, two groups used facts to reach a conclusion. The transportation committee used facts to “prove” that the highway was 85% efficient. The consumer group used facts to “prove” that the highway was 85% inefficient. These facts lead each group to come to a different conclusion about adding lanes to the highway.

Was one group’s facts right and the other group’s wrong?  No, both groups had equally true facts:

a)     85% of the TIME OF DAY the highway had excess capacity.
b)     85% of the TIME OF DRIVERS using the highway was during times of inadequate capacity.

So what is the right “fact-based” decision? Obviously, we need more than just these facts to reach an acceptable decision. And when it comes to strategy we need more than just facts as well.


THE PRINCIPLE

The principle here has to do with perspective. Facts alone do not automatically lead to the proper conclusion. It is only when we place those facts within the context of the proper perspective that we see what is the right thing to do. Therefore as much care and effort should be given to developing the proper perspective as is given to acquiring the right facts.

Perspective depends on two items: Where one is looking from and what one is looking at. In strategic analysis there are usually multiple places to look from and multiple items to look at. If you miss out on examining some of these options, you may come to the wrong conclusion.

Perspective #1: Where One Is Looking From
From the eyes of the transportation officials looking at the highway from afar, what they saw was smooth operations nearly all day long. From the eyes of the drivers on the highway, nearly all of them saw congestion nearly every moment they were on the highway. Their different perspectives cause them to see the situation very differently.

A similar situation can occur in developing your strategy. From the eyes of the executives inside your organization, you may see a particular strategic option as ideal for your bottom line. But how does that option look from the perspective of other eyes?

Perhaps your decision places added burdens on your suppliers, causing them to no longer want to supply you or only supply you if they get added compensation for those added burdens. That added compensation might wipe out a lot of the original advantages you saw from the internal executive eyes. A similar situation could also occur with your distributors.

Or perhaps your decision triggers an adverse reaction from your customers when they see it. This problem could not be seen with the internal executive eyes, but was quickly apparent to the customers’ eyes.  The unperceived adverse consumer reaction could make that original strategic option no longer as viable as first seen.

Or perhaps when your competition sees the strategy, they perceive it as a bigger threat than you thought and they react far more aggressively than anticipated. This aggressive reaction wipes out your perceived benefit.

Or maybe when those ideas from headquarters get down to the factory floor, they cannot be operationalized as smoothly as one thought. Something gets lost in the implementation on the factory floor which hurts the strategy’s effectiveness.

Therefore, before making a decision, step away from the pile of facts and look at the situation through other sets of eyes. How will the decision be seen by all the other relevant parties (suppliers, distributors, customers, competition, front line employees, the government, etc.)? How will their perspective affect their behavior, and how will that behavior impact your strategy?

You may find a need to modify your strategy in order to get all of the players see the situation in a manner which moves them all in a favorable direction for your business.

In addition, consider how you communicate your decisions, so that you can help influence how others see it. How the decision is communicatted may be just as important as the decision itself when it comes to implementation.

Perspective #2: What One Is Looking At
In the story, everyone was looking at the same issue: what is the proper number of lanes to have on the highway.  It assumes that the only way to address congestion is by looking at lane-count for the highway. Is this a fair assumption?

Perhaps there are other solutions one could look at, like:

a)     Increasing use of public transportation;
b)     Convincing more people to use alternate routes;
c)     Getting businesses to stagger the hours employees work;
d)     Reallocation of traffic direction for the current lanes depending upon time of day (e.g., more inbound lanes in the morning and more outbound lanes in the evening).
e)     Financial incentives for carpooling.
f)      Building a separate road nearby.

How do you know you are making the right decision if you have not fully explored all potential options? All those facts you’ve gathered may only be applicable to examining one particular option. If you look at the problem in a different way, you may find that you need a different set of facts altogether.

Remember, business success usually depends on offering a superior solution to your customers’ problems. There may be many distinctively different ways to solve that problem. Unless you examine many alternatives, you may not offer the right solution.

Perfecting the obsolete is not a path to success. After all, even a mediocre smart phone is far superior to the best Morse code telegraph solution, no matter how much time you spend trying to perfect it.

So don’t frame your strategic discussion too narrowly. Before deciding on the best way to do something, first make sure it is something worth doing. First frame the discussion around finding the best solution rather than just finding ways to improve the status quo.


SUMMARY

Facts are useful, but facts alone are incomplete. Facts are only useful if seen from the proper perspectives. Therefore, before deciding a course of action, improve your perspective by:

a)     Looking at the problem through all the eyes of the various people who have an influence on the successfulness of the strategy (suppliers, distributors, customers, competition, front line employees, the government, etc.).
b)     Looking at multiple ways to solve the problem. Creative, superior solutions may look nothing like the status quo.


FINAL THOUGHTS

Great strategic solutions may take you into uncharted territory—doing things in a way they have never been done before. There won’t be a big pile of facts to help you in uncharted territory. And if you wait to act until you can get a big pile of facts, someone else will have already captured that strategic space. Perspective helps fill in the holes when facts are hard to come by.

Friday, May 24, 2013

Strategic Planning Analogy #501: The Power of Control




THE STORY

In the early 1970s, there was a fellow named Robert Taylor, who owned a small soap company, called Minnetonka. Taylor came up with the idea to sell liquid soap in small dispensable pump containers. Although a great idea, there was no way to patent it. After all, liquid soap and pump dispensers already existed.

This caused a dilemma. If the Minnetonka liquid-soap-in-a-pump idea was successful, then larger, more established soap companies could legally steal his idea and use their scale and clout to put him out of business. So even if the idea was great, Minnetonka would probably not be able to benefit from it, right?

Maybe not.

Taylor got bold. He decided to corner the market on pump dispensers. By raising $12 million dollars—more than his company's net worth—Taylor ordered 100 million of the pump dispensers from the only two companies that manufactured them in the U.S. An order of this size gobbled up the entire manufacturing capacity for these two manufacturers for at least a year, and maybe two. That gave Minnetonka plenty of time to establish itself in the marketplace without any real competition.

It worked. Taylor’s product, called SoftSoap, was a huge hit and owned the category because competitors couldn’t get their hands on an adequate supply of pumps.

In Taylor’s second smart move, he sold the business to Colgate-Palmolive for $61 million around two years after introduction. This would be about the time Taylor’s control of the dispenser manufacturers’ capacity was running out and anyone could enter the market—which they did, causing SoftSoap to dramatically lose market share (which hurt Colgate-Palmolive, not Taylor).


THE ANALOGY

Companies hate it when they have no competitive advantage. Without an advantage, there is no advantage to exploit. Without an advantage, anyone who wants to can copy your business model and directly compete against you. Barriers to entry and exit fall. A price war begins and usually only the largest and best financed survive. Profits are minimal.

So to avoid this, firms try to build competitive advantages. The problem is that firms tend to focus on finding their competitive advantage within the product or service they are selling. After all, that is what people are buying—it is what the money is paying for, right? So firms try to create uniqueness into their product which cannot be easily imitated, using tools like patents and unique capabilities.

My favorite story in this regard was when General Mills introduced Frosted Cheerios cereal. In designing the product, General Mills did not just take their regular, oat-based Cheerios and put frosting on it. Instead, General Mills made the frosted Cheerio out of a secret blend of multiple grains. Was this done to make it tastier? No. Was this done because it would make it more desirable to customers? No.

The new formulation, according to General Mills, was done to make it harder for private label competitors to accurately imitate the product. It was done to create a small internal advantage, which I doubt will have much impact on the imitators.

Sometimes, the best advantages come from not from internal formulations, but from actions taken external to the product.

SoftSoap did not have any internal advantages. It had no exclusivity to the idea of putting liquid soap in pump dispensers. In fact, it was at a major disadvantage, because Minnetonka was a small player competing in a marketplace controlled by giant consumer products companies.

So instead of looking internally, Minnetonka looked externally. It decided to create its advantage in the upstream supply chain.  By locking up the supply of pump bottles, Minnetonka created an external advantage. It prevented copying by competition not by making its product unique, but by making it impossible for competitors to get their hands on a key ingredient from a third party.

So, when looking for your competitive advantage, don’t just look internally at your product or service. Be like Robert Taylor and look for external ways to create that advantage.


THE PRINCIPLE

The principle here has to do with control. If you control access to a scarce asset, you have a competitive advantage. This type of external control can create even stronger competitive advantages than internal product uniqueness. As we saw with SoftSoap, control of the external supply of pumps overcame no real internal advantage. And we also saw that Taylor was smart enough to sell the business before the effect of that external control was lost, since once that control was lost, so was SoftSoap’s value.

Upstream Control
One place to look for that external control is upstream in the supply chain. That is what SoftSoap did. It went upstream to control the supply of pumps.

Another example would be Apple. They have been accused multiple times of using a similar tactic. Sometimes, they’ve been accused of locking up the supply of key electronic components needed by their competitors (their equivalent of soap pumps). Other times, they have been accused of locking up the shipping capacity from key technology manufacturing centers in Asia to the US, thereby making it difficult for their competitors to ship their products to the US in time for Christmas. Either way, the external control by Apple gives them a competitive advantage.

Downstream Control
Another approach would be to control the downstream capacity in a supply chain. For example, I remember talking to someone at Andersen Windows shortly after they signed the deal to be the exclusive replacement window vendor for Home Depot. Although Home Depot is not the only outlet for replacement windows, it is one of the largest and most powerful distributors in the space. By being the only replacement window available at Home Depot, Andersen Windows had no direct competition inside Home Depot. That is an important downstream competitive advantage.

GE did something similar with its appliances. GE made solid connections with most of the major home builders in the US. As a result, they locked in a number of deals to be the vendor of choice for appliances which come with a new home. Other appliance manufacturers were frozen out. The ones buying these new houses could pick which GE appliance they got, but not appliances from other brands. This was a big competitive advantage.

And Apple plays in this space as well. By owning the largest distributor of digital music (the iTunes site), it controlled how the entire digital music industry evolved (to Apple’s benefit). Having only Apple products in the cool Apple stores is a similar example.

And then there is Microsoft. Microsoft would probably not exist today if it hadn’t structured the deal the way it did for selling its first product (MS-DOS) product to IBM. Normally, in these types of deals, IBM would have owned distribution rights the operating system they commissioned. But Bill Gates took a lower fee in exchange for controlling distribution rights to MS-DOS. This allowed Microsoft to sell the operating system to every other PC manufacturer, creating the de-facto standard and a lock on PC software for decades to come.

Promotional Control
Another scarce external resource can be advertising/promotional capacity. If you lock up all the key promotional capacity, you can weaken competition’s ability to get the word out about their offering. You see something similar with consumer electronics manufacturers, who try to get massive publicity just before a competitor’s new product launch, in order to minimize the competitor’s ability to create buzz in the promotional marketplace.

Now, one might think that in today’s internet culture, it is harder to create promotional control. But think about this. If you lock up all the relevant key words on Google, you can lock up the ad space on the search engine and freeze others out a key source for getting clicks to their site.


SUMMARY

Looking internally at what you offer is not the only place to seek competitive advantage. Controlling access to external factors can also create competitive advantage. In many cases, this external control can be a more powerful advantage than anything you can do internally. Therefore, consider external control when designing your competitive strategy.


FINAL THOUGHTS

In the end, who do you think got the biggest benefit from their competitive advantage efforts—SoftSoap with its external control of supply, or General Mills with its internal control of a slightly (perhaps even inperceptively) modified recipe for the Cheerios hidden under the flavor blast of frosting?

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Strategic Planning Analogy #352: Tug o’ War


THE STORY
Tug o’ War is a simple game. All you need are two teams and a large rope. The two teams each grab onto the opposite ends of a rope and pull as hard as they can. The team which out-pulls the other, causing the other team to cross into their territory, wins.

Having played the game a few times, I know it can be a very difficult and strenuous game if both teams are of equal strength. When the teams have equal strength, the game seemingly goes on forever and you get extremely exhausted. It’s more fun if your team is a lot stronger than the opposition. Then, you don’t have to work as hard and you win more quickly and more often.

THE ANALOGY
In Tug o’ War, winning comes from amassing more power at the point of struggle than your competition. The one with the relatively larger strength wins. The same is true in the business world. The one with the larger relative strength usually wins.

Think of the rope in Tug o’ War as being like your supply chain. The person on the other side of the rope is someone else in your supply chain, either upstream (supplier) or downstream (distributor, customer). Within a supply chain, there is a certain amount of revenue and a certain amount of costs. These revenues and costs need to be allocated amongst all the players within the supply chain. If you are a good negotiator, you can get a disproportionately higher percentage of the supply chain revenues while absorbing a disproportionately lower percentage of the costs. Your gains come from the losses of others within your supply chain.

Of course, while you are trying to get a disproportionate advantage against others in the supply chain, others in the supply chain are trying to do the same to you. Hence, the big struggle, like a game of Tug o’ War. And, like in the game, the one with the most power typically wins the struggle.

As mentioned earlier, Tug o’ War is more fun if you are stronger than the team on the other side of the rope. The same is true in business supply chains. I’ve worked with retailers who were very strong relative to their suppliers and I’ve worked with retailers who were weak relative to their suppliers. Let me tell you, those experiences are very different.

When with the weak retailer, we were forever going to the suppliers begging for access to sell their product. We were willing to promise almost anything to get them to cooperate and sell to us. Needless to say, even if we did successfully get access, we didn’t make much money on the deal because the negotiation favored the supplier, who was much stronger.

Conversely, when the retailer was relatively much stronger, the roles were reversed. The vendors came knocking at the doors of the retailer, begging us to sell their wares. To gain access to our stores, they would offer almost anything—even including some equity ownership in their company. In this case, retailer got the most favorable end of the negotiation.

The more power you bring to the supply chain, the better your negotiation of who gets the revenues and who pays the costs. Getting such power rarely comes by accident. It takes strategic effort.

Therefore, when strategizing about the battles ahead, don’t just build your strategy around the struggles against your competition. Remember, you also have this tug o’ war with your supply chain as well. In fact, your ultimate profitability may have more to do with how your supply chain tug o’ war turns out than how your competitive battle turns out. This is because a winning tug o’ war strategy in the supply chain not only makes your individual transactions more profitable, but it can also give you an edge in your fight against the competition (particularly if their tug o’ war within the supply chain was less successful).

How much of your strategic effort is focused on your supply chain tug o’ war?

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here has to do with accumulating the right amount of power within the supply chain. The key here is determining what the right amount of power is and what it takes to get it. This is not just about getting the most power you can. Remember, it is not absolute power which is important, but relative power. It does little good to focus on building your power if you still end up significantly less powerful than your supply chain partner on the other end of the rope. Also, as we will see later, there can be risks if you gain too much power. The goal is not to obtain all of the power, but only enough to gain advantage.

So what can we learn from the game of Tug o’ War to help us with this supply chain strategy?

1) Don’t Let the Other Side Get Too Strong
In Tug o’ War, you can still win if you are weak. All you need to do is ensure that the opposition is even weaker. There are steps you can take in your strategy to proactively try to keep other players in your supply chain weaker than you. Take, for example, the relationship between franchisors and franchisees. If you are a franchisor, you have a choice in whom you franchise to. Are you making those early front-end choices strategically for the long-term Tug o’ War between franchisor-franchisee?

At first, it may seem easier to franchise your concept to a small number of large franchisees. After all, this eliminates the hassles of dealing with a lot of small operations. Through only a few deals, you can quickly get huge geographic penetration for your concept. In addition, these large franchisees tend to be successful and well financed, reducing the risk of failure.

Unfortunately, when you take such a move, you have made the franchisee relatively stronger in the franchisor-franchisee tug o’ war. A large franchisee has more leverage in the negotiations and can gain more advantage. Your one-time decision has created decades of tougher Tug o’ War battles than there needed to be.

Take, for example, NPC International. They own about 1,200 Pizza Hut franchises. Just their volume alone would make NPC a top ten fast food retailer in the United States. Worse yet for Pizza Hut, NPC now controls about 20% of Pizza Hut’s volume in the United States. That gives NPC a lot of power in negotiating with Pizza Hut. For example, instead of accepting the typical supply distribution arrangement Pizza Hut offers its franchisees, NPC in August negotiated a separate deal to get their supplies from McLane Foodservice. I’m sure that this deal between NPC and McLane Foodservice puts disproportionately less of the total supply chain profits in the hands of Pizza Hut.

And it is Pizza Hut’s fault, because they allowed this franchisee to get too powerful. NPC International got large by buying up other franchisees. Strategically, it might have been in more beneficial if Pizza Hut had outbid NPC and then placed those units in the hands of others where the power of the franchisees would have been more dispersed. Then Pizza Hut would have had more power when distribution decisions by the franchisees were being made.

2) Build Your Own Strength With the Help of Others
Even if your team is small and weak you can still win Tug o’ War if you can partner with others who will pull along with you on the same side. In other words, if your negotiating clout is weak, then don’t negotiate alone. Form alliances with others.

The internet has shown that if individual consumers work together en mass, they gain a lot more clout and get better deals (think firms like Groupon). Cooperative buying organizations have been around a long time, where groups of people or companies negotiate together in order to get a better deal. Technology is making such buying even easier. Take advantage of these opportunities increase your relative strength at the point when Tug o’ War negotiating occurs.

3) Keep the Game Fun for Both Sides
If you build up too much power, nobody will want to play Tug O’ War with you because they won’t have any fun. The same is true in business. If you gain too much power, and exploit that power too strongly, nobody will want to play with you. And if nobody in the supply chain wants to play with you anymore, you cannot run your business anymore.

Think of the U.S. automobile industry. The manufacturers had used their power so aggressively to squeeze concessions out of their suppliers that the suppliers could no longer make a profit serving the automobile industry. Many suppliers started diversifying away from the automobile industry and started to no longer bid on projects in the automobile industry. Those suppliers which remained started going bankrupt, causing all sorts of problems for the automobile companies purchasing from them. The result was that the automobile companies now had fewer supply options and the remaining options were shakier. This is all because they had taken the power principle too far.

Remember, the goal is to win with your supply chain, not to obliterate it. Although they may be on the opposite side of the rope, they are still your partners. You cannot survive without them. Getting a disproportionately better deal does not mean taking it all and leaving them with nothing.

Besides, the cost to get that much power may be more than what you can get in concessions (diseconomies of scale). And if you exploit your power too much, you can have government agencies coming after you.

4) Be Careful When Pulling on Both Sides of the Rope.
Some people argue that the best way to avoid problems in the supply chain is to diversify into the rest of the supply chain. In other words, become your own supplier and/or distributor. Now there can be some benefits to this approach, because you cut out some middleman expenses. However, this approach can often be a disaster.

The problem is this—if you own both sides of the negotiating table, then you cannot get a disproportionate advantage. Although you get to absorb all of the revenue, you also have to absorb all of the costs and all of the risks.

It is like trying to play Tug o’ War while holding both ends of the rope at the same time. There is no way to win an advantage.

In addition, if you own a supplier or distributor, that often means that your competition will no longer want to use that same supplier/distributor for fear that it will put more profits in the hands of their competition. As a result, your ownership could weaken the power of that supplier/distributor in its own Tug o’ War battles.

SUMMARY
A large part of a company’s success may be due to how well they play Tug o’ War with their supply chain partners. Therefore, supply chain power management should be a key part of any strategic planning exercise.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Negotiations with supply partners do not always have to be adversarial. Sometimes you can find some win-win alternatives where you can make your whole supply chain more competitive against competing supply chain alternatives. But don’t be naïve when negotiating and assume your partners always have your best interests at heart. I remember one wholesaler saying that his suppliers all told him that he was their favorite customer. At first he was happy because he thought that was a compliment. Then he realized that he was their favorite customer because they got their best differential advantage when negotiating with him. He stopped being happy and started negotiating harder.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Strategic Planning Analogy #322: Problems of Scale


THE STORY
The rising prosperity in China is impacting Chinese eating habits. For example, between 1982 and 2002, daily per capita consumption of grain in China dropped 21%, from 509.7 grams to 401.7 grams. At the same time, meat consumption grew 132% and vegetable cooking oil consumption grew 153 % (Source: Chinese National Bureau of Statistics).

If you consider that fact that it takes about 7 or 8 grams of grain to produce one gram of meat, the grain requirements for China are growing rapidly, even though direct grain eating is going down. According to an article in the June 24, 2008 issue of the China Daily, if the Chinese started to eat meat at the same level as in the US, the world would need to produce an additional 277 million tons of grain to grow the meat. That would require finding an additional 68 million acres of quality farm land that is not currently being farmed (about one-sixth of the farmland in the USA).

Add to that the fact that if every Chinese adult drank just one additional can of beer in a year, China would need approximately 150 million more pounds of grain. This starts adding up in a hurry.

THE ANALOGY
It doesn’t sound like much when you say that it takes about 7 kg of grain to make 1 kg or meat, or that it takes about 0.08 kg of grain to make a can of beer. However, when you multiply that against a population in the billions, small changes in meat and beer assumption can really change grain consumption.

This is what happens when you apply scale to these equations. Suddenly, little movements in behavior create large swings in demands all up and down the supply chain. The bigger the scale, the larger the swings.

Strategy is usually concerned with finding ways to change behavior—to your benefit. The equations associated with current behavior may appear innocent enough, and you might apply them to your strategy. However, if there is enough scale to your behavior change, the current equations may no longer be applicable.

For example, changes in the diet of China are affecting global food availability and global food prices. The old cost of goods assumptions are no longer applicable, since the new consumption has altered prices of all sorts of cost components throughout the entire food production pipeline. Add to this the uncertainty of biofuel consumption and the formulas may need to change again.

Your strategic actions impact the environment in which the strategy will operate, rippling out changes in many directions. You need to take that into account when assessing your strategy viability, especially if it starts to scale large.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that strategies do not operate in a vacuum. If your strategy is to create large-scale changes in demand, then all the current assumptions about how the marketplace works need to be thrown away, because your changes will impact how the marketplace works.

Here are six factors to consider when contemplating large-scale strategies.

1. Is there Capacity to Satisfy Demand?
Years ago, I talked to someone at McDonalds. They were testing a new meal item—McShrimp Cocktails. The item tested very well. Based on the current economics, it looked like it could be priced to make a profit. Then they looked at what happens when you scale this up to the entire McDonald’s chain.

As it turns out, it would have taken more than 100% of the world’s capacity of shrimp to meet annual the demand projections. So McDonald’s couldn’t meet demand, even if they wanted to. Even scaling back demand, the change to the shrimp market would have been so huge that the old cost estimates would have been invalid. Scarcities would raise the price of shrimp, making it too expensive for the McDonald’s menu. A great test of McShrimp Cocktail was made invalid once consideration was given to scaling it up.

In the early days of Starbucks, Starbucks promoted itself as being a place to get superior coffee, because it was small and could afford to be choosy about the quality of beans it purchased. Now that Starbucks is huge, it has to buy so many beans that it cannot afford to be as choosy as it once was. There are not enough “superior” beans to meet the Starbucks demand. As a result, a promotional approach was no longer valid.

There are retailers who specialize is selling manufacturer overruns and other distressed or excess goods at a deep discount. Over time, some of those retail chains have gotten so large that there is not enough excess in the marketplace to fill their stores. They have to supplement their supply by purchasing goods the normal way, just like they retailers whom they are trying to under-price. Suddenly, the strategy doesn’t work like it used to.

2. Can the Supply Chain Handle the Shift?
I was talking to someone years ago at the Mars candy company. I complained that they had changed the recipe of their Mars Bar candy bar from hazelnuts to almonds. I told him I liked the old taste better.

His response was that the original Mars bar created a large scale change in hazelnut consumption. The hazelnut supply chain was not built to handle that kind of demand. As a result, Mars found that there was not a stable, predictable way to procure the hazelnuts they needed and that the pricing was not stable. By contrast, the almond ecosystem could easily absorb the demand of the Mars bar in a predictable way, so Mars shifted from hazelnuts to almonds.

A similar situation happened with General Mills and their introduction of a buckwheat based cereal. The demand for the cereal was strong. Unfortunately, the supply chain for buckwheat was not able to satisfy the sharp rise in demand created by this cereal. The supply chain was so bad that General Mills decided to stop making the popular cereal. So much for that great buckwheat cereal strategy—foiled because the supply chain ramifications weren’t adequately considered.

This is why, when McDonalds is expanding into new territories, they start years in advance to first change the local supply chain for products like beef and potatoes. They want to make sure the supply chain can handle their large scale before putting that scale into the marketplace. A similar process occurred for the Chipotle restaurant chain. They had to delay their rapid growth strategy until they could convince farmers to rapidly expand the capacity for avocados. Otherwise, there would not have been a stable supply chain for the restaurants.

3. How will your Scale Impact Pricing?
Supply and demand impact prices. If scale radically increases demand, and supply does not keep up, prices for your raw materials will skyrocket. This will make any strategy based on the old supply and demand relationships obsolete (and perhaps make your strategy no longer valid).

To get around this, your strategy may need to consider locking in long-term supply contracts at fixed prices…or maybe consider backwards integration into owning your sources of supply in order to guarantee adequate supply at a reasonable price.

Suppliers need to worry about this as well. In the US food business, the manufacturers saw their primary customer as the supermarket. When the wholesale clubs like Costco and Sam’s Club first started, their demand was tiny when compared to the supermarkets. It was seen as incremental business. Therefore, the temptation was to set prices to the clubs based more on incremental costs rather than full costs (which were disproportionately born by the supermarkets). Of course, once the clubs achieved huge scale, that pricing plan was no longer valid.

4. How Does Scale Impact Image?
Many goods are sold on the basis of image or prestige, such as luxury goods and fashion brands. Much of the appeal is based upon their scarcity—only available to the rich and famous. Once the item is widely available to the masses, the elite customers may abandon the brand.

It can be tempting to take a prestige brand and adapt it to a large scale for the masses. At first, it will create a huge spike in demand and in profits. However, if the large scale destroys the prestige image, the brand will eventually lose its luster. It will be quickly abandoned by the elite customers. And when the masses see the elite abandoning it, they will soon follow. Therefore, the short-term boost can lead to a long term disaster.

There may be greater long-term success by not scaling up for the masses.

5. How Does Scale Impact Competitor Reaction?
If you are a small niche, the big competitors may ignore you. However, if you scale up large enough to threaten the big players, they will retaliate. They will either try to destroy demand for your product or design competing products. Either way typically leads to a price war, which will destroy your profit margin.

Always assume that the scale which comes from success will result in increased competitive retaliation (for more on that, click here). Put the economic impact of those retaliations into your strategic model to see if you can sustain the price cuts and other pressures. It may be more profitable to remain a small niche.

Also, consider in your strategy ways to increase the barriers to entry, making it harder for the eventual retaliation. One of the reasons why the iPod was so successful was the integration of hardware, software and iTunes. By attacking all three fronts with a seamless and superior business system, it was harder for anyone else to break into the market and retaliate.

6. The Additional Scale Does Not Have to Come From You
Even if you do not upset the status quo with large increases in scale, that does not mean that the status quo will remain. Others may upset the scale. Your business will be impacted by the change even if you did not create the change.

For example, China’s rapidly growing economy is impacting the global oil market. That can impact your energy costs, even if your business has nothing to do with China.

There was a road near my house in Ohio that was closed for quite a while due to the lack of a bridge. The reason? The high demand for steel in China had created a global steel shortage. The community I lived in did not want to pay a premium price to get the steel quickly. Therefore, the bridge was not built until they could get cheaper steel (by being willing to wait). If construction in China could affect my little bridge in Ohio, think of what remote activities could affect you.

Scan the environment to see where surges in scale created by others might occur that could affect your strategy. Then come up with plans to deal with these surges caused by others.

SUMMARY
Large changes in the scale of demand make the mathematics of the status quo environment obsolete. If you do not change your modeling and assumptions to account for the ways the volume will impact the ecosystem, your strategy will be flawed.

FINAL THOUGHTS
The good news is that China may be opening up a great new surge in demand. The bad news is that China may be opening up a great new surge in demand. The ratio of good news to bad news can be impacted by how your strategy adapts to this news.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Analogy #216: Stop the Labeling!


THE STORY
When I was a young boy, my parents would occasionally send me off for a week of summer camp.

In order to keep track of things, the camps would ask parents to label everything with their child’s name. Clothes were to have labels sewn onto them. Property was to have sticky labels. That way the camp could make sure that all the boys went home with the same stuff they brought.

Of course, all of the boys would ridicule the other boys when they saw one of those labels. They would call them a “mama’s boy.” Having those labels with your name on it became a badge of shame.

Therefore, one of the first things the boys would do when they got to camp would be to rip off all those labels with their names on them. All that careful work by the parents to label things was for naught.

THE ANALOGY
There’s a certain comfort level in labeling things. The camps and the parents felt assured that such labeling would make it easier to track all of those possessions. Unfortunately, the children did not like the stigma of being labeled.

Businesses also tend to like labeling people…and each person seems to only be allowed one label. For example, some people are labeled good customers and others bad customers, and the label sticks regardless of the situation. And if you are labeled a customer, then you cannot be labeled a vendor, and vice versa.

What if businesses acted more like those boys at summer camp and ripped off those labels?

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that once something gets labeled, the label tends to dictate how the item is treated. For example, if you label someone as “aggressive,” you will approach them differently than if they had been labeled “passive.” The less labeling one does, the more flexible and adaptable one can be towards that object.

Businesses interact with a lot of different people/companies. Those people/companies tend to get labeled and put into a category: customer, supplier, partner, competitor, employee, and so on. Once placed in a category, the tendency is to limit interactions to just what is implied by that label. However, new strategic opportunities open up if we rip out those labels we have mentally sewn onto them.

For a recent example of this, we can look at an article in the October 2008 Harvard Business Review. The article, entitled “The Contribution Revolution: Letting Volunteers Build Your Business,” was written by Scott Cook, founder-chairman of Intuit.

The basic idea of the article is that if a company provides the right kinds of Web 2.0-type tools, all sorts of people will voluntarily make contributions that will have a significant profitability impact on your business. Cook then lists all sorts of examples.

At his own company, Intuit, they do not have a Spanish language manual, but Spanish speaking volunteers have offered all sorts of Spanish language mini-manuals and podcasts. Unilever has the “In the Motherhood” user forum and Proctor & Gamble has the BeingGirl online community for teens. Cook likes the way both provide all sorts of relevant user-generated content.

Some companies use “free volunteers” to help design and critique products. Others ask their customers to help create their advertising. Key bloggers can be used as “free advertising” as well.

My point is that if you label someone as a customer, then you will think of them in terms of how to get them to buy from you—after all, that’s what customers are supposed to do. However, if you rip off the label, you can see how they are connected to your brand in many ways and can help in many ways—often for free.

The same thing goes for suppliers. If you think of them only in terms of that label, then the tendency is to just try to use “hardball” negotiations to get the lowest price for what they supply. But if you think of them as a strategic partner in your supply chain, you may see that you can help each other create a more efficient supply chain, which could be far more profitable than what you can get only through hardball price negotiations. Toyota’s relationships with its suppliers is an example of this.

In the grocery industry, it is not uncommon for supermarket companies to outsource a lot of their shelf space management to a variety of their vendors/suppliers. The logic is that the supplier is a specialist expert who understands that particular product class better than anyone else. In other words, the supplier becomes a “free” merchandising consultant to the supermarket.

Even those labeled as “competition” may be seen as free helpers if you rip off that label. For example, maybe you can work together to lobby the government on various causes of mutual interest. Or maybe you can jointly support an effort to create a more favorable image for your industry which could expand the total industry demand.

Employees could be seen as free “brand advocates” or free “guinea pigs” for various experiments. Really loyal and engaged employees may want to freely volunteer ideas to help the company in areas that have no direct bearing to their job label.

Although these ideas work well in the digital web 2.0 world, it can go well beyond that. Face to face meetings, joint committees, call centers, and the ol’ suggestion box can be a part of the mix as well.

To get all of this free help requires several things. First, as mentioned, get out of the mode of narrowly labeling people and companies. Look as everyone as a potential partner, willing to help you for free (or at least at below market prices).

Second, create lots of ways to make it easy for people to help you. That requires both creating lots of ways for them to communicate with you as well as people on your end to willingly and graciously receive the free help.

Third, don’t be bashful. Ask a lot of questions to a lot of people. You’re more likely to get the help you want if you let them know what you’re looking for.

Finally, get out of the habit of describing some customers as always “good” or always “bad.” Even people labeled as “bad” customers can be “good” customers if you look at them differently. Perhaps they can become good customers if you design a new business model. For example, much work has been done recently to find economic ways to sell to low income third world areas, people who had traditionally been seen as too poor to be a good customer.

Or perhaps a so-called “bad” customer is merely a “future-good” customer. It may just be too early in their life-stage for them to hit their prime opportunity years. However, if you appeal a bit to them today, they may be more loyal to you once they hit their prime opportunity years. Get a young girl hooked on your luxury handbag today, and you may create a strong brand supporter for your entire luxury portfolio once they get older and wealthier.

SUMMARY
Labeling can have the unintended negative consequence of narrowing our expectations of people. We only expect of them what is implied by the label. For example, a customer is only expected to consume, a supplier is only expected to supply. However, if we take the labels off, we can see broader potential. Everyone can become a potential strategic partner, offering all sorts of assistance. And best of all, it is often nearly free.

FINAL THOUGHTS
One time when I was at camp, they did a spot inspection of the cabins and happened to luck into coming at a rare moment when my cabin was clean. This was the exception rather than the rule. But needless to say, that rare inspection paid off and I was given a badge for “cleanliness.” Later, I was running through the woods with the badge, tripped and took a terrible tumble into the dirt. The cleanliness badge got all mangled and blackened with dirt smudges.

When camp was over, I proudly gave my dirty, mangled “cleanliness” badge to my parents. They weren’t fooled by the cleanliness label. They knew better. You should know better than to be fooled by labels, too.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Analogy #209: Draw A Bigger Circle


THE STORY
Once upon a time, there was a politician who wanted to clean up water pollution in the local rivers. He decided that he would have greater success if he started small. Therefore he took a map of a large river in his district and drew a circle over a portion of that river.

“There,” he said. “I will start by making all the river water within this circle pollution-free. Once that is done, I’ll move to another circle until the whole river is clean.”

The politician passed all sorts of laws making it impossible for anyone to do any sort of polluting within the boundaries of that circle. Proud of himself, he later went to check on the quality of the water within that circle. To his dismay, the politician discovered that the water was more polluted than before.

“How can this be?” the politician cried out. “I banned all polluting activity within that circle.”

Upon further investigation, he discovered that:

1) There were factories on the shore of the river just outside his circle that were pouring tons of pollutants in the river.

2) There were tributaries to this river that were bringing polluted water into the river. These tributaries were also outside the area in the drawn circle.

3) There were polluting activities upstream from the circle that flowed into the area inside the circle.

At this point, the politician realized that he could not solve the problems of the water inside his circle without also tackling issues occurring outside the circle.

“I guess I drew my circle too small,” sighed the politician.

THE ANALOGY
The strategic planning process is a tool to help improve the performance of our business. This is similar to the politician’s goal of trying to improve the quality performance of that river.

The politician’s mistake was that he tried to fix the problem by only looking at the area inside the circle. He failed to realize that his little portion of the river is connected to a lot of other areas. These other areas had a significant impact on the quality of that river’s water. By ignoring the outside influences, he was unable to control the internal results.

The same is true in business planning. Our goal may be to improve our firm (or brand or division or product’s) performance. However, not all of the factors which influence that success fall within the direct control of the firm (or brand or product). Outside influences are important.

Therefore, as we develop our strategic planning, it is important that we do not draw our circle of planning too small. The process needs to be inclusive enough to cover not only our own internal team, but the major influencers as well.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that interconnected solutions work best if all the interconnected pieces are a part of the planning process. So the question we must ask ourselves is this: How big is the circle of people involved in our planning process? Is our circle large enough?

In this blog, we will look at four groups you may want to consider adding to the list.

1) Employees
There are two reasons why it is important to get employee feedback into the planning process. First, employees are your eyes and ears out in the areas where your products/services are produced and sold. They see things that may never make it to the secluded offices at corporate headquarters. They know things you do not know. This knowledge and insight can be very valuable in creating a strategy most appropriate for the “real” world (which may look different from the “perceived” world in the minds of the leaders at the top). Take advantage of that resource.

Second, the employees are the ones who have to do a lot of the work to make the plan a reality. If they are not solidly behind the strategy, they may not be as effective at implementing it. By contrast, if they had a stake in creating a strategy, they are more emotionally attached and motivated to making it come to life.

2) Partners
Today’s business activities are far more interconnected. Larger pieces of the business are outsourced to various outside partners. In addition, financial partners have a desire to become more active and involved in how the business is run. More and more of your success is dependent upon these partners over which you do not have full control.

If you do not invite your partners to the planning table, they may not be able to fulfill their role in making your strategy a reality. For years, Microsoft and Intel worked closely to ensure optimal performance for their own individual business. Microsoft knew that if Intel did not supply sophisticated enough chips, there would not be the ability for computers to run the next generation Microsoft software. Similarly, Intel knew that if Microsoft did not invent more complex software, there would not be demand for their more sophisticated chips.

Since each company’s success was dependent upon the actions of the other firm, there were benefits to working this out together.

The new Boeing Dreamliner airplane is being built with cooperation of an extraordinarily large number of outside partners. Significant delays are occurring due to the difficulties of coordinating the activities of all of these outside partners. The better you can jointly plan these activities, the smoother the cooperation.

3) Suppliers
The same principle applies to suppliers. In this just-in-time world, it is difficult for a supplier to meet the demands of your plans if they are not aware of what the plan is. Even more important, if you let the suppliers in on the planning process up-front, they may have suggestions on how to do it better, based on their unique perspective and superior knowledge in their own field. This point may be even truer with partners.

The Japanese auto industry shows some of the advantages of working more closely with suppliers.

4) Customers
In today’s environment, customers are demanding a greater say in the operations of the businesses they patronize. Digital technology is making it easier to create interaction between customers and companies. For example, Dell has used web 2.0 consumer conversations to help them understand what the customer really wants. Dell’s latest product introductions are a direct result, offering some of the most wanted features.

There are many ways to include the customers in your planning process. The good news is that the more the consumers are involved in the brand, the greater the emotional attachment to the brand. This should improve customer loyalty. In addition, it’s no small benefit if the interactions create a strategy more in tune with the marketplace where the money is made.

This is not to imply that all of these people (employees, partners, suppliers and customers) need to be a part of the entire planning process. Yet, it amazes me how often these players are not a part of any of the planning process.

Who do you invite into your planning circle? What is the list of people invited to sit at the planning table? Is it big enough?

SUMMARY
Individual company/brand/product success depends not only on the internal actions of your business, but also upon the actions of numerous parties on the outside. Your chances of success in having a successful strategy improve if these outsiders are invited to the planning table. First, they bring knowledge and insight from their unique perspective. This knowledge can improve the quality of the plan design. Second, by being a part of the plan, they should be better able to execute their portion of the plan.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Some problems are so large that it may be necessary to even work together with your competitors. For example, it may be beneficial to get the government to change its stance on issues related to your industry. Therefore, industry associations and lobbying groups may also be people to include in your planning circle.

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Analogy #205: Dating Among Friends


THE STORY
If you want to mess up a perfectly good relationship among friends, start having some of them date each other. I’ve seen it happen many times. There will be a group of mutual friends that like to hang out together. Then, two in the group start having a serious dating relationship with each other. Suddenly, the dynamics in the group change.

Now, all of these same people can be a little less comfortable hanging around together. The two that started dating may prefer more private time away from the group…or maybe the others feel awkward being with the daters (the proverbial “third wheel”). And if someone else in the group is jealous because they wished they were having that dating relationship the other person, then it gets even messier.

Now if some in the group get married, it can change the dynamics between the married ones in the group and the unmarried ones. The gang may end up splitting into two groups—the married and the unmarried.

A similar situation could occur among guys who hang out together if one of the guys starts dating the younger sister of one of the others in the group. All of that free-flowing conversation about girls may no longer be as free flowing. Suddenly, that isn’t just a girl—it’s my baby sister—and “nobody is going to talk that way about my sister.” The friendships can become strained.

THE ANALOGY
People are not the only ones who have relationships. Businesses (and their leaders) do as well. Businesses have relationships with their suppliers. They have relationships with their customers. They even have relationships with their peers in the same industry.

As long as everyone feels pretty much like equals, these relationships can be somewhat friendly and work smoothly. However, if some of these businesses start pairing up to form more serious relationships, it can ruin the old gang of friends.

For example, you may not be as friendly with a supplier if they start a serious relationship with one of your peers and end up merging with them. Now, buying from your supplier feels like you are lining the pockets of your competitor and that feels less comfortable.

And if a competitor gets a little too cozy with one of your customers, you may become as angry as if one of your friends was taking advantage of your little sister.

Therefore, if your strategy calls for creating some more serious relationships with others in the supply chain (like acquisitions, mergers, strategic alliances, etc.), be careful. Sure, it may seem all romantic and wonderful to hook up. However, it could upset a lot of your other relationships in a negative manner. The negative unintended consequences with the rest of the gang may outweigh and benefits of the pairing up.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that a handful of stronger relationships in the supply chain may end up putting your firm in a weaker overall position with the rest of the marketplace. In the end, you may be worse off than before. In other words, by dating a couple of your friends, you may alienate the rest of your friends.

This may appear to run contrary to conventional wisdom. When it comes to strategy, it is commonplace to hear references to staying close to your core business (stick to what you know). And what could be closer to your core business (and knowledge base) than the neighboring pieces of the supply chain? Therefore, there is a temptation to want to form stronger associations (or acquisitions or startups) above you (suppliers) or below you (customers) in the supply chain.

For example, many retailers are moving upstream to get stronger control over their suppliers, creating exclusive brands or even buying out the supplier. Approximately half the sales at Kohl’s and JC Penney come from such relationships. Nervous suppliers (who are not part of the deal) are responding by opening up their own retail stores (becoming their own customer).

At first, one can dream up reasons why this could be a wise move. First, it is assumed that more ownership of the supply chain leads to more control and that more control leads to the ability to extract more profits. Second, it is assumed that there are some synergies and economies of scale in there somewhere which will lower your expenses.

Unfortunately, my experience and observations have shown me that reality usually works in the opposite direction. More often, the move to control more of the supply chain can serve to lower sales and increase costs. Allow me to explain why.

Buying a Supplier
First, let’s look at what happens if you acquire one of your main suppliers. Typically, prior to the acquisition this supplier had other customers besides you. Many of those other customers may be your direct competitors. When the supplier was independently held, all of these competitors would be okay with all buying from this same supplier. It was a happy group of friends.

However, once you purchase this supplier, the relationships change. These direct competitors suddenly have less desire to purchase from that supplier, because that money would now be going into the same company as one of their direct competitors (namely you). The fear would be that the profits from the supplier could be funneled into your core business and used to make life more difficult for them. So they start purchasing more from another supplier.

Your purchase of that supplier has made the supplier less desirable for no other reason than the fact you own it. You have tainted its independence with your connection to it. Sales for the supplier will most likely drop with these other customers and it is usually unlikely that you will throw enough extra business at them to make up the difference.

And even if you could throw more business to the supplier you purchased to make up for the supplier’s lost sales volume, consider this. There was a reason before why that supplier was not getting all of your business. They probably didn’t deserve it. Just because you now own them may not have made them any more deserving of that business.

And, of course, your negotiating stance has changed with that supplier now that you own them. Before, if you could negotiate tough terms with them, you got a disproportionately higher share of the value chain profits as they got disproportionately less. In other words, you could put the squeeze on the supplier and win at their expense.

However, if both sides of the negotiating table are owned by the same company, then you are only putting a squeeze on yourself. In fact, because you become more of a captive audience to your supplier, you will probably have less aggressive negotiations and end up paying more than you did before.

As a result, when you buy a supplier, there are forces at work to destroy value. There is pressure for the supplier’s sales to go down (do to defections from your competitors) and for your core business’ costs to go up (due to a weaker negotiating stance with the owned supplier).

Buying a Customer
A similar problem occurs if you make an acquisition downstream in the supply chain. The customers you did not acquire will resent the fact that you purchased one of their competitors, and weaken the sales of your core business as they abandon you.

If you own your customer, you may negatively change the focus of that company. Instead of letting them focus on their customer, you may try to get them to act in the best interest of your core business. For example, you may force them into purchasing too much inventory from you, or inventory they would not otherwise want. If you make them try to please your needs, rather than their own needs or their customer’s needs, you will make them less profitable.

And if you avoid this influence and let them run as before, then you have not created any synergies. The benefits of the purchase (for which you probably paid a premium) start to vaporize.

So again, when you buy a customer, there are forces at work to destroy value. You pay a premium price for the opportunity to destroy the company’s worth, for no other reason than the fact that you own it.

SUMMARY
When you purchase firms directly above you (supplier) or below you (customer) in the supply chain, you have upset the old order of business for the entire supply chain. Unfortunately, these changes tend to work against you rather than for you. Synergies and economies of scale fail to occur to any large measure. Instead, the results tend to be alienation of customers and higher costs—a bad combination.

FINAL THOUGHTS
There’s an old saying that one shouldn’t date people at the company where they work. Not only may it make things awkward at work during the period of dating, but it can get really ugly at work afterwards when the couple breaks up. Once you determine that the types of acquisitions mentioned in this blog are often mistakes, you may want to sever the relationship and sell the business (i.e., break up). However, by then a lot of the relationship damage in the supply chain is already done, so it will still be ugly.