Showing posts with label Steve Jobs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steve Jobs. Show all posts

Thursday, April 5, 2018

Strategic Planning Analogy #577: What do you March To?



THE STORY
John Philip Sousa (1854-1932) was considered to be the best composer and conductor of American marches who ever lived. His nickname was the “American March King.”

When I was in college, I heard a story about a time when Sousa had visited my college. He supposedly told the heads of the college that he thought our college fight song was one of the best marches he had ever heard. That made me feel proud.

However, now that I am older, I have heard many additional stories about Sousa. As it turns out, John Philip Sousa visited a lot of colleges over his lifetime. And each college tells a similar story about how Sousa told them that their college fight song was one of the best he had ever heard.

Suddenly, Sousa’s stated opinion of my alma mater’s fight song seems a lot more meaningless.

THE ANALOGY
Strategists talk a lot about how companies should try to please their customer. But you hear far less about how customers often try to please the company…and this is a bad thing.  Sousa is a perfect example of this phenomenon.

Think of the college as being like a company and their fight song is their product. Sousa is the customer. In an attempt to try to please all of the “companies” Sousa tells them all that he loves their “product” (the fight song). So, in his attempt to please all of the “companies,” Sousa’s opinion of their “product” becomes worthless.

Customers in today’s world are often giving as worthless an opinion to companies as Sousa did to colleges—all in an attempt to please (not offend) the company. This desire to be nice and no-offensive results in consumer opinions which are as worthless as Sousa’s.

Many companies today use customer opinion surveys as a Key Performance indicator (KPI) to judge their strategic success. Unfortunately, there is often a Sousa-like bias in the customer to please the company and give opinions which turn out to be meaningless. KPIs with meaningless data can be very dangerous.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that even though it is important to please the customer, don’t judge your success by asking customers if they were pleased. There is too much bias in the desire of many customers to please companies, making answers to those types of questions worthless.

One example which comes to mind are the quick auto oil change companies. After you get your car’s oil changed, they send out a survey to ask you if you were pleased with the service. This sounds reasonable until one digs deeper.

As it turns out, many of the mechanics will tell their customers about the survey they are about to receive. Then the mechanic tells them that if they rate him with anything lower than a perfect score, the mechanic will get no credit towards his performance bonus. Many customers don’t want to keep their mechanic from getting a bonus and besides, who wants to return to a mechanic who is upset at them for giving him a low score? You want your mechanic to like you. So all of the sudden, almost all the mechanics are getting superior grades (the Sousa phenomenon—worthless information).

To remedy the situation, on a recent oil change survey I saw a new question asking if the mechanic told you in advance how your ranking would affect him. I guess that was put in there to “weed out” some of the bias. Unfortunately, just putting that question in the survey creates more of that same bias. Who wants to get their mechanic in trouble for talking about the scores?

Preference is Better than Opinion
One way to get around opinion bias is to stop asking people’s opinion about your product. For example, you could instead ask about preferences. Using our analogy, that would be like instead of asking Sousa about his opinion of your fight song, you would ask him to rank order the top 25 fight songs from favorite to least favorite. Sousa may still like them all, but at least now you will know which ones he likes more.

Knowing customer preference (compared to numerous options) is more important than opinion about a single product, because we don’t always buy what we like, but are more likely to buy what we prefer.

I might like nearly all cars, but I don’t buy nearly all cars. I am more likely to buy the car I prefer. Therefore preference among choices is a better indicator of future success than mere opinion on a single item.

Behavior is Better than Preference
But even here biases can creep in to distort the results. In a desire to please the company, I might rank it higher in preference than I should. Therefore, an even better question is to ask about past behavior. For example, I could have asked Sousa how many times he listened to each of the college fight songs in the past two years. Past behavior is less prone to bias. Looking at what Sousa actually listens to is probably a better indicator of what he actually likes than asking his opinion.

I would have far more confidence in a KPI measuring behavior than one that measures opinion or preference.

SUMMARY
KPIs are a key part of strategy. Choosing a KPI that gives inaccurate or distorted information can be very dangerous. KPIs based on asking customers if they like you is one such dangerous KPI. It is better to ask for preferences against competition. Better yet, just ask about past behavior.

FINAL THOUGHTS
This problem is even worse if you are asking customers about new concepts or products for which they have to prior experience. As Steve Jobs of Apple used to say: “You can't just ask customers what they want and then try to give that to them. By the time you get it built, they'll want something new.”  And when commenting on what kind of consumer research Apple did for the iPad, Jobs said, “None. It is not the consumers’ job to know what they want.” In other words, KPIs on future concepts should steer clear of consumer opinion even more than others. When it came to the future, Jobs marched to the tune of the future, not to the obsolete marches still in the heads of the customers.

Monday, September 23, 2013

Strategic Planning Analogy #511: Motivated by Money


THE STORY
Years ago my team was proposing a new business plan to our CEO. In brief, the idea was to stop a competitor’s aggressive move into our markets by making a reciprocal move into their most profitable market. Since we were in a stronger cash flow position than them, we could afford to attack their key source of cash, and they would have to retreat in order to protect their core.

We could inflict great pain on them in their key market with only limited pain on ourselves. And this would cut off the cash they were using to attack us. Hence, we would create a long-term gain for ourselves with only a small immediate hit to ourselves.

The CEO listened to the detailed strategy with a puzzled look on his face. Eventually, he looked up and said, “Don’t give me a strategy. Just tell me how to make money.”

Since the strategy did not immediately make more money for the firm, the CEO rejected it. As a result, the competitor continued attacking our company. Eventually, their cash flow became even stronger, so they became even more aggressive. Over time, this aggressive behavior wiped out a key division of our company, leaving us with a huge loss of earnings.

The CEO’s actions helped us make a little bit more money in the near-term, but wiped out an entire division in the long term. It appears that we would have made a lot more money if we had focused less on making money and more on having a strategy.


THE ANALOGY
In the world of capitalism, making money is a good thing. If you aren’t eventually making money, your investors and other key stakeholders will get upset. However, if your only motivation is to obtain money, then you may make decisions which lead to bankruptcy. The irony is that a single motivation towards money is not usually the best path for achieving the most money.

As we saw in the story, the best path for making the most money involved a time consuming process which caused near-term pain. By rejecting this approach and instead taking steps which created the most money immediately, the company put itself on a long-term path which destroyed a key division of the company.

Key decisions are made based on what motivates us. If “making money right now” alone is the key motivation, then we may end up making the wrong decisions. Other motivators are more likely to make more money.


THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that motivations matter. And the singular motive to just “make money” is not the best motivation.

The Principal Applied to Entrepreneurism
Many studies have been done to look at what makes a successful entrepreneur. These studies consistently show that if the primary motivation for the person becoming an entrepreneur was “to make a lot of money,” then they usually failed as an entrepreneur.

Becoming a successful entrepreneur takes a lot of hard work and a lot of sacrifice. It often requires living near the poverty line for quite a while before the business takes off. If all you want is a lot of money right away, then you typically will not put up with the level of sacrifice needed to succeed as an entrepreneur. So you will fail.

In fact, there was a recent stream of articles on Quora.com about people who voluntarily chose to become homeless in order to invest everything they had into their entrepreneurial start-up. In essence, they were looking for ways to become as personally cashless as possible for the sake of building the business. That type of sacrifice requires a different type of motivation than merely wanting to make money.

The studies on entrepreneurism usually show that the most successful entrepreneurs are motivated primarily by a desire to create a superior solution over what is currently in the marketplace. They are more driven to build a better answer for others than build a bigger pile of cash for themselves. Yet, ironically, by not focusing so much on the bigger pile of cash, the entrepreneur is more likely to eventually have that big pile of cash.

The larger, grander, and nobler motive of giving the world a better alternative is needed to motivate the extreme levels of sacrifice needed to create success. It also has a secondary benefit. Customers don’t just want to give you money because you want them to give it to you. The customer wants great value. If you are motivated to provide superior value for the customers, then you are motivated by the same thing that will motivate customers to give you their money.

In other words, an outward motivation to better the lives of others is the best way to get others to voluntarily want to give you the money needed to get rich. This point really reached home to me when watching the recent movie about the life of Steve Jobs. Making money was nowhere near the top motivator for Jobs. He was driven by a motivation to make great products (and got very angry with those who did not share that motivation). Yet, in the end he was very wealthy.

If all you want is a lot of money and aren’t motivated by a larger purpose, then you’re probably better off seeking a life of crime than one of entrepreneurism. In crime you get the money involuntarily from people. Rather than giving them a reason to want you to have their money, you just steal it.

This is not to say that successful entrepreneurs have no motivation for wealth. No, a desire to be rewarded for one’s sacrifices is logical. If there is no potential for a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, then the entrepreneur will eventually stop the effort of chasing the rainbows. The point is that a money motivation alone is usually not enough. A larger, external motivation to provide the world something better is also needed.

The Principle Applied to Big Business
This same general principle also applies to large corporations. In the story at the beginning of the blog, we saw a large corporation destroy one of its business divisions because it focused too much on looking for easy ways to make money quickly rather than looking at the sacrifices needed to ensure long-term viability.

The grander, market-based motivations help large corporations in many ways. First, they provide a reason for all of the employees to give a strong effort on behalf of the company. Let’s face it. In large businesses, most of the employees are not going to become extremely wealthy. So why should they put in the extra effort?

When you have a business mission based on a larger, nobler goal, you provide a motivator that everyone can rally around. There’s the old story of the government official in the 1960s who was getting a tour of the NASA operations. He was asking people at NASA what they did. When he asked the question to a NASA janitor, the janitor replied “I’m helping to put a man on the moon.” Because the janitor captured the larger vision, he became a more diligent janitor.

Is your mission wrapped in a nobler goal, like putting a man on the moon? This is a great motivator for the masses in your organization.

Second, if a large business does not see its mission in larger terms, then it will not know what to do to succeed. Many large businesses have strategic plans which say little more than “We want to make a lot of money.” Sure, they may disguise it in more “flowery” language and make it sound more tangible by attaching a numeric target to it. But fancy words and numeric targets won’t disguise the reality that these types of “strategic plans” are nothing more than vague wishes for greed.

Just because you can say “We want to make a lot of money” does not mean that you have a clue as to how to make that money. Money is made when you have a solution desired by the marketplace that you can profitably provide because of the unique business model you have designed to deliver that solution. Unless your business has a specific strategy about…

1.     What it is delivering to the marketplace;
2.     Why it is a superior solution; and
3.     How it can be delivered profitably

…then you will not make those big piles of money. Without a reason to succeed, there is no reason to expect to succeed. Therefore, large companies need a planning process to ensure that the reason to succeed is discovered.

Finally, in large companies, you have lots of people doing all sorts of different things. If there is not a common understanding of what your success formula is, then employees will go off in all sorts of different directions. These uncoordinated efforts will be more like random anarchy than a coordinated march to success.

If you want a large company to be successful, you need to everyone moving in the same direction towards that success formula. That requires not only developing the grander plan, but making sure it is widely known and is rewarded when followed. Otherwise, the plan will not reach reality.


SUMMARY
People act based upon their motivations. Ironically, the best primary motivation to create business wealth is not an inner motivation for wealth. Instead, it is an outer motivation to provide a superior solution in the marketplace. This outward focus forces one to create the types of value needed to cause others to pay you for your offering (the source of wealth). It also provides that higher cause which motivates people to work harder. That is why companies need strategic plans which outline what the outward success formula is and put it in words which motivate employees to put it in place because it achieves a higher, nobler goal.


FINAL THOUGHTS
In the movie Wall Street, Michael Douglas (playing the role of Gordon Gekko) famously says, “Greed is Good.” I say “Greed is Not Enough.” You also need a viable plan and an external motivation which transcends greed.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Emergent Vs. Positioning (Part 2)


 

INTRODUCTION
In the last blog, we looked at a comparison between the Emergent view of strategy and the Positioning view.  I explained why I prefer the positioning view.  In today’s blog (part 2), I will explain why I think the emergent point of view also makes some good points and how to incorporate them into a positioning framework to get the best of both worlds.

 
POINT #1: SUSTAINABLE COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE

The Issue
The emergent position brings up two good issues.  The first has to do with sustainable competitive advantage.  The positioning school tries to find positions which provide sustainable competitive advantages.  The emergents respond that sustainable competitive advantages are becoming increasingly more difficult to create, so finding those types of positions can be a more futile undertaking.

First is the “sustainability” part of the phrase.  In a seemingly ever faster changing environment, very little appears sustainable.  So if change is constant, why seek sustainability? 

Then there is the “competitive advantage” portion of the phrase.  With rapid change comes frequent upgrades and frequent obsolescence.  It makes any advantage very temporary.  It is like a ping pong game, where the ball keeps bouncing from one side to the next—first side A has the advantage and then side B has the advantage, then side A regains the advantage, and so on.  So instead of trying to achieve lasting advantage, emergents just try to stay in the game by responding with their ping pong paddle in a way to keep the game alive.

The Solution
Is this phenomenon a concern?  Yes.  Is the problem as dire as the emergents believe?  I don’t think so.  First of all, this is not the first time rapid change has occurred in business.  We’ve gone through the industrial revolution, the widespread adoption of electricity, the movement to a knowledge-based economy, and so on.  Yes, there is some turmoil during the transition, but companies with a good strategy find a way to make it through the transition.

The solution is to change the focus of where one looks for advantage.  Even when many things are changing, many others stay the same.  In particular, when products and technologies are changing rapidly, basic human needs and desires still stay the same.   There is always a segment wanting low prices.  There is always a segment wanting status.  There is always a segment wanting convenience.  There is always a need to feel loved or appreciated.

Now the means by which these constants are achieved may change.  The core solutions do not.  So the solution is to find positions which are not tied to particular products, but to enduring solutions.  For example, Wal-Mart positioned itself around the enduring solution of offering low prices.  Now the way it has done this has changed.  It started as a discount store.  When it looked like wholesale clubs could provide lower prices, they opened up Sam’s Club.  When it looked like supercenters could provide lower prices, they aggressively replaced discount stores with supercenters.  When it appeared that building a more sustainable and eco-friendly supply chain could lower costs and prices, Walmart aggressively went in that direction. 

The point is that Walmart’s low price position gave them an anchor.  As the world was changing around them, they did not panic.  They just kept migrating to wherever that position could be best met.  And through that singular focus, they were able to reinforce that position with the customers and become continually stronger.

Bausch & Lomb was in the lens business, but they focused their position on the end solution—better sight.  As a result, they migrated in to contacts, eye surgery equipment and eye enhancing vitamins.  Yes, the product changed radically, but because of their focus, they knew what had to be done to stay relevant.  They found a place where they could differentiate and win.

Apple keeps changing their offering, but each offering is true to their position of selling cool, easy to use interfaces between people and their data.

Without these positioning anchors, the myriad of strategic choices would overwhelm a company.  You cannot do it all.  You have to focus.  You have to make trade-offs.  And these enduring positions help light a path within the confusion of change.  In fact, they can help you better anticipate where to go, due to that focus.  Without it, you are always trying to catch-up to whatever looks hot today.  And by the time you match it, the world has moved on to the next hot item.  You never get ahead that way.

Another positioning approach to take is to create a position around speed and flexibility.  The emergent view is to always be racing to keep pace with change.  If speed and flexibility are so important in a rapidly changing environment, wouldn’t building excellence around speed and flexibility be a great position?   Build your positioning trade-offs around speed and flexibility, so that you become faster and more flexible than those who do not make those trade-offs.  This position actually makes rapid change an advantage for your position.

 
POINT #2: LOSS OF CONTROL

The Issue
The second key point emergents make is that businesses are losing control of the interaction with their customers.  The power is shifting to the consumer.  Social media and web 2.0 have given the consumer more of a voice.  They are having a greater say in how products are designed and marketed. 

If consumers are gaining a greater control over the conversation, then emergents would say that consumers are gaining greater control over a company’s position.  If that is the case, then a company can no longer rely on managing its business by managing its position.  Instead, a company needs to chase where the consumer conversation is going and whatever emerges from that is the strategy.

The Solution
Well, this is true to a point.   And that point ends when you shift from incremental strategy to transformational strategy.  Consumers can be great critics of the status quo.  They can tell you what is wrong with a product and how to incrementally make it better.   However, they tend to be quite bad at voicing opinions about transformational issues which go beyond what the consumer has experienced. 

This is because a) most consumers are too busy living their current lives to spend time dreaming up all the particulars around the business model for the next big thing; and b) if they have no experience to relate to, then they have trouble getting their arms around it and give an accurate assessment.

That is why Henry Ford supposedly said, “If I’d asked my customers what they wanted they would have asked for a faster horse.”

That is why Steve Jobs supposedly said, “You can't just ask customers what they want and then try to give that to them. By the time you get it built, they'll want something new.”  And when commenting on what kind of consumer research Apple did for the iPad, Jobs said, “None. It is not the consumers’ job to know what they want.”

So if you want to remain in an approach to strategy which is only incremental, then perhaps the idea of following the customer makes sense.  But if you want to transform the world like Henry Ford or Steve Jobs, it would seem that following the customer is a poor choice.  Instead, you still need to lead the customer and be pro-active in what you do.  And if the world is moving as fast and creating as much obsolescence as the emergents proclaim, then I think the transformation approach is even more important.  And that means that significant control is still in the hands of the successful companies.

 
SUMMARY
The emergents make some good points, but not enough to get me to abandon the positioning perspective.  Instead, I just altered the positioning perspective slightly to accommodate the concerns.  You can see them in the chart nearby.  For the concern of the world changing too quickly, I suggest either shifting positions to timeless solutions or to speed & flexibility solutions.  For the concern of losing control, I suggest focusing more on transformations, where control is still strong.

 
FINAL THOUGHTS
Although there is good and bad in both points of view, that does not give an excuse to abandon all approaches to strategy.  It is still worth doing.

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Plate Spinning



THE STORY
When I was a little boy, I used to enjoy watching the Ed Sullivan show on TV. Frequently on the show, he would have as one of his acts a “plate spinner.”

The plate spinner would have a number of long, thin wooden rods sticking straight up, all in a row. Starting at one end of the row, he would put a plate on top of the wooden rod and start spinning it until it was going fast enough to not fall off of the rod. Then he would move on to the next rod and get another plate spinning. He would continue this down the entire row of wooden rods.

Soon, the plates he began spinning earlier would slow down, start to wobble and almost fall off the wooden rod. The plate spinner would have to stop what he was doing and go back and very quickly get that plate spinning again. Eventually there would be so many spinning plates that the plate spinner would be frantically running from rod to rod trying to keep them all going.

Eventually, he would not be able to keep up with them all, and plates would start to fall and break. As a young boy, seeing someone breaking plates on TV seemed like fun.

THE ANALOGY
In the business world, leaders are confronted with a great number of tasks and responsibilities. Often times, it can feel like being one of those plate spinners. You are frantically moving from crisis to crisis just trying to keep things from breaking. There appears to be no time for quiet reflection or strategic concerns. All the effort is used just to keep the plates spinning.

It doesn’t need to be that way. In this blog we will look at how to stop being a plate spinner and how to become a more effective long-term leader. Plates were originally made to hold scrumptious meals. Let’s stop spinning plates and use them to feast on the fruits of successful planning.

THE PRINCIPLE
Back around the late 1980s, I read a book summary about how to be an effective manager. The author studied a number of executives who were noted for being effective leaders. He then wrote about the traits he saw in the effective leaders. I’ve forgotten the name of the book or the author and tried in vain to locate the book on the internet. If any of you know the name of the book, let me know.

What the author found was that there was no single way to be an effective leader, but rather several, although the methods did have something in common. As I’ve pondered what I read in the book summary so many years ago, I have modified the common principle of success to being “leveraged focus.” Using the analogy above (something the author did not do), when compared to plate spinning, the successful leader would not try to spin all of the plates by his/her self. Instead the leader would focus on only one of the plates. However, the leader would focus in such a way that the plate he was spinning would have an indirect impact on all of the other plates. His spinning of the one plate would leverage all of the other plates to keep them spinning without a need for the leader to focus on all of them.

The author mentioned several different types of “plates” to focus on and how they could leverage all of the others. I do not remember them all, but here are most of them:

1) Focus on People
2) Focus on Investment
3) Focus on Vision
4) Focus on Process

Each of these will now be described in greater detail.

1) Focus on People
This type of effective leader would focus on making sure that the right people were in the right part of the organization, pretty much to the exclusion of most other factors. This leader would get very involving in the hiring process for all executives, making sure to be part of the interviewing. This leader would spend a great deal of time making sure the skills of people matched their responsibilities and that there was a cultural fit.

The leverage works as follows: If you get great people properly aligned in the organization to take advantage of their strengths, and give them the right tools, they can do great things. In other words, if the “people focus” plate is spinning well, it will create an environment where great people on their own will find the right plates and spin them for you. Just get the right people in the right place and then get out of their way. By focusing on one plate, you get them all.

Dick Schulze, the founder of Best Buy is probably a good example of this type of leadership. He was always fond of saying “you win with people.”

2) Focus on Investment
This second type of effective leader would focus on making sure that the company was putting the resources behind the right projects. He or she would spend a lot of time focusing on capital investments—where and how the money is being spent. Returns on investment would be a key point of interest.

The leverage works as follows: If you can effectively control where the resources are placed in an organization, then you can effectively control what the organization does. In other words, you focus on determining which plates are the best ones to spin. Then you put enough resources behind those plates to ensure that they will keep on spinning without a need to constantly monitor them. The resources will get the work done, so you don’t need to be everywhere at once trying to spin the plates yourself.

3) Focus on Vision
This third type of effective leader spends a significant amount of his or her time on making sure the vision and mission is right. Then this type of leader spends most of the remaining time communicating the vision, to make sure that everybody understands it and is behind it.

The leverage works as follows: If you can get everyone focused in moving in the same direction, then you will end up moving the company in that direction. The details about which particular plates should be spun would occur naturally as people gravitate to the plates most in line with the vision and start spinning them. By focusing only on the direction, you can get all the proper action from others as a natural consequence.

Steve Jobs is probably a good example of this type of leader. He sets the tone for what Apple stands for, and because the people intimately know what he is looking for, they deliver.

4) Focus on Process
A lot of the failure in business comes from poor execution. Therefore, this fourth type of effective leader focuses a great deal of time on process—examining how things get done in the organization. This type of leader looks for ways to streamline a process, eliminate bottlenecks, and make handoffs more seamless. Process flow charts consume the interest of this leader.

The leverage works as follows: By focusing on the Process Plate, one is creating an environment where it is harder for things to fail. Therefore, one does not have to keep running from wobbly crisis plate to wobbly crisis plate, because the efficiencies of the process tend to make the plates keep spinning longer all on their own.

The point of all this is that leaders cannot do it all themselves. However, they still need to make sure that all the proper plates are spinning. So rather than be half-hearted at everything, pick a plate to really focus on. And then make sure that you leverage that effort so that the impact of that plate indirectly gets all the other proper plates to spin on their own. This then allows the leaders the freedom to be true leaders, rather than just frantic plate spinners.

SUMMARY
Even though a lot of things have to go right in order for a business to be successful, that does not mean that leaders need to spend time on every little thing that has to go right. In fact, if a leader gets spread that thin, they will end up being effective at nothing. Instead, leaders need to focus more narrowly to ensure that one particular aspect gets done supremely well, be it the people factor, the process factor, the resource factor or the vision factor. Then, the trick is to make sure the effectiveness in that one area ripples out to all the other areas, so that the consequence of the narrow focus causes everything else to naturally fall in line and get done without the need for constant leader attention.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Of course there are always exceptions. Great companies like GE tend to be able to do multiple things right. Regarding people focus, GE has one of the best executive development programs around. Regarding process, they have gotten their arms around processes like six sigma. Regarding resource allocation, they were leaders in no longer investing in businesses that were not #1 or #2 in their field. The mix of the GE portfolio has changed greatly over time, as investments changed with the environment. Regarding vision, people quickly start to understand “the GE way.”

However, even here there has been focus. They didn’t try to institute or perfect all of this at once. Instead, they would tend to focus on only one of these four areas at a time to get it right and then just rotate to the next focus. It has been more sequential plate spinning rather than simultaneous plate spinning.