Showing posts with label Strategic Fit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Strategic Fit. Show all posts

Thursday, March 17, 2016

Strategy Planning Analogy #559: Don’t Blame the Racetrack

THE STORY

This past week I was at a large park. This park had a long jogging trail. I watched some of the joggers using the trail.

Some joggers were moving effortlessly along the trail. It was as if they were just gliding on air. They looked like they could go on merrily forever.

Other joggers were bent over and huffing & puffing. Their forward progress was almost non-existent. They looked like they were about to pass out.

Based on my observations, was this a good trail for jogging on or not?

THE ANALOGY

Actually, that’s the wrong question. This was the same jogging trail for all joggers—the ones gliding effortlessly and the ones about ready to pass out. The variation was not in the trail, but in the users of the trail. It wasn’t the trail that determined success or failure; it was the condition of the joggers using the trail.

Therefore, the better question would be: Are you (as a jogger) in the right condition to succeed on this trail?

This is similar to a question I have often heard in strategic planning: Is this a good strategy? Like the question about the trail, it is the wrong question to ask.

Name almost any reasonable strategy, and I will find winners (companies gliding along effortlessly) and losers (those about to pass out) among those implementing the same strategy. Since all of these companies were following the same strategy, it cannot be the strategy which determined success or failure.

No. It was the condition of the company which determined if they were succeeding or failing with that strategy.

Therefore, instead of asking if the strategy is good, we should be asking if our company is in the right condition to succeed with this strategy.

THE PRINCIPLE

The principle here is that strategy success is based in large part on whether there is strategic fit. The greater the fit between who you are as a company and the qualities needed for the strategy to work, the more likely you will succeed with that strategy.

If you want to succeed on that jogging trail, your physical conditioning must fit with the physical requirements of the trail. If there is no fit, you will fail. This is true for both jogging trails and business strategies.

It’s like going to a job interview. All the candidates who make it as far as the interview are smart and talented. But the one who eventually gets the job is usually the one with the personal qualities which best fit with the hiring organization.

Similarly, your company can be full of smart and talented people. But if the company’s culture and capabilities do not fit with the chosen strategy, you will fail with that strategy.

You may observe another company and say, “Look! They’re succeeding with this strategy. That means it’s a good strategy, so if I follow that strategy I should succeed as well.”

But that is faulty reasoning. That would be like the out-of-shape huffer & puffer looking at the physically fit glider on the jogging trail and saying, “Look! That person is succeeding on this jogging trail. That means it is a good trail and that I should succeed as well.”

That logic ignores the fact that the huffer & puffer is not fit for the trail and will never succeed on it, no matter how many others glide by.

When considering fit, here are some thoughts to keep in mind:

1) Most Runners in a Race Lose
In horse racing, only the top three finishers in the race matter—the ones who either win, place or show. The rest are losers. Similarly, in the race to succeed with a strategy, only a small handful really succeed with a given strategy. The rest are all losers.

Take technology. How many wildly successful (and profitable) computer companies are there? Other than Apple and Samsung, are there any other successful smartphone companies? How many companies are winning in the smart watch category?

The point is that one can pull out all sorts of statistics about the how wonderful a particular category is—how fast it is growing, how large it will become, how much money will be spent. It can make the strategy of entering that category look very desirable.

However, in the long run, only a very few companies actually earn meaningful profits in that category. The rest are losers.

Were all the losers bad companies with incompetent people? No. They just did not have as good a fit (culturally, image, competency and capability-wise) in the category as the winners.

Being a good operator is not enough if you want to win. There have been lots of good companies making good technology who lost. In fact, nearly all of them lost. If you want to win, you need a better fit than anyone else.

That requires one of two things. Either only select strategies where your current fit gives you competitive advantage, or change yourself to get in shape for the strategies you want, so that your fit is more in alignment than others.

In the latter case, your strategy becomes a two-step strategy. First, get in shape to have the best fit. Second, pursue the strategy where that new fit is most valuable.  

2) Strategy Choice is Both External and Internal
Strategic Fit means having alignment between what a strategy needs and what a company can offer. Therefore, when choosing a strategy, you have to look both externally (at what a strategy needs) and internally (at what I have to offer).

If we only look at the appeal of the strategy, we are missing half the analysis.

We also need to look at ourselves. And we have to be honest with ourselves and admit to our shortcomings. We have to look into the mirror and see ourselves as we really are.

If we are having trouble with objectivity, we can turn to asking customers and other industry players or consultants to help us see ourselves as we really are.

When former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg was considering running as an independent candidate for President of the United States in 2016, he did some consumer research (I happened to get one of his surveys). The research convinced Bloomberg he did not have a good enough fit to win, so he decided not to run.

Your research may also show that you do not have the right fit to win at a particular strategy. If so, be like Bloomberg and don’t implement that strategy.  

3) Money Rarely Overcomes a Bad Fit
Some people think that if you have enough money, you can buy your way to success. The problem is that money is relatively easy to obtain. And the ones with the best strategic fit tend to be the companies that find it easiest to get the money.

Therefore, money rarely becomes a differentiating factor. If a lot of companies can get it, then having money does not get you an edge. Besides, the money will be most effective in the hands of the people with the best fit, so even if you have a little more money, it will probably not be enough to overcome a weaker fit.

Just ask the large, cumbersome, bureaucratic companies that had a lot of money but lost out to a small, nimble company that started out in a garage with little cash. Despite having more money, they lost out to the company in a garage because their culture and mindset was a poorer fit. Having more money was not enough to overcome this.

Example
I consulted with a company that was pursuing a broad-based leadership strategy in a particular industry. One of the requirements of that strategy was to aggressively consolidate the industry by rapidly buying up smaller operators. The problem was that this company’s culture was financially conservative and their core competency was not rapid, large consolidation.

As a result, other companies following a similar leadership strategy in this industry were doing a better job at consolidation, because they had a better fit. This meant that the company I was consulting with was falling behind and becoming less relevant as a leader.

Therefore, I recommended that the company shift from a leadership strategy to a niche strategy. The recommended niche was chosen by looking at where this company had a competitive advantage in terms of fit.

Now the company is confident they are on a path that is more likely to achieve success, because the strategy has a better fit with who they are.

SUMMARY

No strategy is universally good or bad for everyone. There will be winners and losers among people using the same strategy. The difference between the winners and losers is how strong the fit is between the strengths of the company and the requirements of the strategy. Therefore strategic planning cannot merely look externally for a good place to be, but it must look internally to ensure that you are the right company to be in that place.

FINAL THOUGHTS


Getting in shape never sounds like fun, but trust me, you will be much happier running the race if you are in shape. Make sure you are in the right shape shape for running the strategic race you have chosen. If you are out of shape for the race, don’t blame the racetrack when you lose.

Monday, November 5, 2012

Strategic Planning Analogy #475: Don’t blame the Violin


 
THE STORY
If you put a violin in my hand and told me to play it, I don’t think you would like the results.  It would sound awful.  After all, I’ve never had a violin lesson in my life.

I could blame the problem on the violin.  I could say that it was a bad violin and that is why the music sounded so poorly.

However, I knew someone who was the first chair violinist for an orchestra.  If you put that same violin in his hands, the music would sound quite different.  In his hands, the music would be wonderful.  So was the problem the violin or the one holding it?

 
THE ANALOGY
A frequent topic of business strategy is growth.  Often times, the growth strategy involves either acquiring another company or entering another business.  A lot of time and effort goes into determining whether what is a good company to acquire or a good business to enter.  Yet, in spite of all that analysis, a large percentage of growth strategies fail.

We can start blaming the failure on the growth target.  For example, we can say that the acquisition target was bad or the targeted new industry was bad.  However, for every industry where someone fails, someone else succeeds.  So is it really a bad industry?

The problem is similar to the violin.  In the right hands, the violin makes great music, whereas in the wrong hands, the violin produces an irritating screech.   The value of the sound coming from the violin is not primarily due to the quality of the violin.  Instead, the value is created by the quality of the hands playing the violin.

In the same way, the value of owning a particular business or being in a particular industry often has more to do with the quality of the company who is trying to obtain it than the quality of what is trying to be obtained.  So before you start blaming your growth target, take a moment to look at your own hands.  Are those the hands of a virtuoso in this venture or are your hands better skilled for something else? 

 
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here has to do with strategic fit.  If the desired company or business is a bad strategic fit for you, it really doesn’t matter how great the desired target is.  In your hands, it will fail.  Therefore, a good strategic process should spend more time focusing on its own hands than on what it wants to put in it.

Wanting to Be in an Industry in The Worst Way
We can see this principle in action by looking at an example.  I have a friend who is looking at getting into the mobile payments industry.  This industry is concerned with figuring out how to transfer payments from the buyer to the seller when items are purchased on a smartphone.  Is this a good industry to get into?

Some facts would indicate that the mobile payments industry could be very lucrative.  Smartphone penetration is high and rapidly getting higher.  Long-term estimates of commerce over mobile phones is astronomical.  Even if you can only charge a miniscule fee for handling the payment transfer, the net revenue potential is huge.  So perhaps this is a great place to be.

But so far, we’ve only looked at the quality of the industry.  Predicting success by only looking at the industry is like trying to predict the value of the sound from a violin by only looking at the violin.  If we want to truly understand how the violin will sound, we also need to look at the hands of the one who wants to play the violin.

So I look at the hands of my friend.  He’s a great businessman with many skills.  However, for this venture, he has only a small pool of capital and a small staff of support.  He has never directly been in the payment transfer business.

I compare this to the hands of other people who would also like to own the mobile payments business:

1)      ISIS, a consortium of some of the largest mobile carries in the world (AT&T, Deutsche Telekon, Verizon, Vodafone) who want to cut out the middle man and do the transfers themselves.

2)      Merchant Customer Exchange, a consortium of some of the largest retailers in the world (Walmart, Target, Best Buy, CVS, etc.) who want to cut out the middle man and do the transfers themselves.

3)      Well capitalized companies willing to devote a lot of time and talent to owing the mobile payment space, like Google Wallet, Square, and PayPal (part of EBAY).

4)      And, of course, we cannot forget the sizable threat from the traditional payment transfer experts (Visa, Mastercard, AMEX).  They have a lot to lose if commerce moves from their stronghold to the mobile space.  They know the business and will fight strongly to keep it.

When I compare the hands of my friend to these hands, it is obvious that he is not the virtuoso in this space.  His hands are not good enough to win against these foes.  It is almost irrelevant how much potential the industry has.  He will never see it, because he will lose.

Now some would say that if an industry is large enough and profitable enough, there is room for smaller players (with lesser hands) to do well.    The problem with that thinking is that it doesn’t take into account the dynamics of an industry.  New, exciting industries eventually mature.  This usually causes the following:

1)      The industry consolidates to only a few survivors (almost none of the little guys survive to maturity).

2)      The profits are not spread equally.  The leaders get a disproportionate share of the profits with the lesser players being lucky if they break even.

3)      The intense competition to get to the top usually results in the profit level of the entire industry to drop.  That is why most mature industries have a return on investment near the cost of capital.

So, for my friend, entering this business would be a big mistake. It doesn’t fit his hands.

Wanting to Buy a Company in the Worst Way
A similar problem occurs in acquisitions.  One could analyze all sorts of acquisition targets.  You might find a company with a great business model, great people, and a great balance sheet.  Is that a great company to acquire?

Well, just as you cannot tell if a violin will sound great by only looking at the violin, you cannot tell if a company should be bought by only looking at the target company.  You also need to look at the company doing the acquiring.

The biggest problem is that thorough due diligence will typically find out what the underlying value of the target company as is would be.  And both sides of the negotiation will know that value.  Great companies will command a premium and weak companies will command a discount.  It is very difficult to steal away a company at a bargain price below market value.

In fact, acquirers typically have to pay a premium to obtain a company, often in the range of 20 to 40% above market value.    

So here’s the dilemma.  For this acquisition to be a great deal, you have to have such good hands that you can make the business perform at levels so superior to the status quo that you can cover the premium plus enough extra to cover your required rate of return.   If your hands aren’t skilled enough to do that, then you will lose, no matter how great a company the acquisition target is.

The irony is that supposedly “bad” companies may be better acquisition targets, because it may be easier to add value to them.  That is why there are firms out there like Cerberus, who specialize in investments in very weak firms.  They do well because they have developed skills in turning around weak companies.  In these specialized hands, they can add value to weak firms.  They are the virtuosos of turnarounds and can make good music even with a weak company.

What to Focus On
Therefore, strategists need to focus on the hands of their own company.  What instruments can they play well?  Which instruments will they play poorly?  What instruments could they learn to play well?

After this type of analysis, a couple of strategic results could occur:

1)      Build on a strength.  Great musicians practice all the time to enhance their skills.  Similarly, once a company determines its strategic path, it needs to continually enhance the skills needed to pull it off.  GE has been great for many decades in running diverse portfolios, because it knew that diverse portfolios succeed best when in the hands of great generalist managers.  So GE worked diligently to build a virtuoso group of generalist managers.

 
2)      Shore Up a Weakness.  If there is a strategic path you want to take, but don’t have the right hands for it, develop that skill before embarking down that path.  There is a reason why firms like Google devote so much effort into getting the best technical talent available.  They realize that to win in the spaces where they want to go requires virtuoso technical talent.  Without it, the strategy will fail, so they make sure that they have it.

 
SUMMARY
When embarking on a path to growth, don’t just focus on the growth target.  Instead, a majority of your focus should be on yourself.  It is only in understanding yourself that you will know where you can add value.  If you can add value, you can make even mediocre targets desirable.  And if you cannot add value, then you will not succeed in even the best looking area of growth.  So make sure you have a strategy for strengthening/creating skills at value creation as part of your overall strategy.

 
FINAL THOUGHTS
There are several instruments which I can play much better than a violin.  Those are the instruments which I should place in my hands.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Strategic Planning Analogy #424: Matching Up


THE STORY
Recently, I was talking to someone who was divorced. After the divorce, she had been using a number of internet dating sites to find a new partner. Her ex-husband was also using a number of internet dating sites at this time to find a new partner.

What was interesting was that these internet dating sites kept making suggestions that these two formerly married people should start dating each other. Given the nature of the negative emotions surrounding their divorce, I can assure you that the idea of getting them back to dating each other is a very, very bad idea.

THE ANALOGY
One of the secrets to a good marriage is a good match between the people getting married. And although computer dating services may help reduce the risk of a bad match, they are not foolproof. As seen in the story, some of their suggestions can be disastrous. That is why extra effort needs to applied to ensure the match is truly good.

The same idea applies to strategies. Like marriages, strategies require good matches between the people involved. After all, strategies are only good if they are effectively implemented. Implementation requires the actions of a number of stakeholders. If these stakeholders are not well matched up with the essence of the strategy, they will stray from the strategic intent. Implementation will suffer.

Yes, there are computer programs and internet sites to help us find the right strategic stakeholders, be that strategic partners, acquisition targets, employees, customers, lenders, equity holders, etc. However, these tools are not foolproof. Extra effort is needed to ensure that all the parties match up well with the thrust of the strategic intent. If we are not diligent and vigilant in making sure we have good strategic matches, we will end up with the equivalent of a strategic divorce…and that is rarely the desirable way to implement a strategy.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here has to do with strategic fit. Strategic fit based on how well stakeholders match up with the strategy. Typically, the better the fit, the better the strategic execution.

The logic behind this idea seems pretty obvious. For example, if your employees are strongly opposed to what the strategy is trying to accomplish, then they will rebel and resist. Implementation will suffer (I have witnessed this firsthand). However, if the employees are in strong agreement with the strategy, then they will more heartily implement it properly.

Anyone who has had an activist investor who wanted to move the company in a different direction than the management has also seen how such a mis-match can stall strategic implementation. The worst case scenario is that the two sides (management and equity investor) will get into a nasty fight and neither strategic option will be strongly embraced. The company suffers greatly.

Or ask Netflix about how well their strategy to split the company went after they announced it and found out that it was a major mis-match for their consumers. Customers rebelled, subscriptions dropped dramatically, and the stock price dropped equally dramatically. Netflix had to abandon the original strategy to split the company.

So it would seem to be a no-brainer that companies need to cultivate a strong strategic fit with all their stakeholders—be it employees, investors, customers, or whomever is important to the success of strategy implementation. Yet, like with Netflix, there are so many examples where companies have not been diligent and vigilant in maintaining strategic fit with these stakeholders (and have suffered the consequences).

So what causes companies to stray from this basic principal? To put it bluntly, it usually boils down to either greed or laziness.

Greed and Overreach
Greed can ruin strategic fit in two ways. First, greed can lead to strategic overreach. A great strategy is typically based upon owning a strong position. For example, a position may be based on superiority in delivery an attribute, like quality, speed or service. By definition, these positions tend to be limiting. To strongly own one of these attributes, one typically has to make trade-offs against other attributes. For example, for Apple to truly own coolness, elegance and ease of use, it has had to trade away from low cost/low price.

Limiting can initially sound bad, but it can actually be very good. It is easier to find strategic fit with customers if you stick to your point of uniqueness. Your customers became your customers because they also wanted that point of uniqueness. There was a fit.

But greed can set in. Management may want to expand beyond their point of uniqueness. They want to become much more. As a result, they overreach and destroy strategic fit with their customers.

For example, every time Wal-Mart has tried to expand beyond their low cost/low price position and try to become known for fashion, it has failed. It is a mis-match with how Wal-Mart is perceived by those who want low cost/low price and those who want fashion.

When exclusive high fashion brands let greed cause them to overreach and try to be more relevant to the masses, it leads to long-term disaster. The old customer who loved the exclusivity will walk away quickly. The new masses will eventually walk away as well, because a lot of the appeal to them was in emulating the exclusive customer (who is no longer associated with the brand). Not only is there now a mis-fit with the customer, but also their supply chain. Once the fashion brand appeals to the masses, the exclusive retail outlets will drop the brand because it no longer fits with their strategy.

Or how about Toyota? Toyota had a strong position in producing dependable cars. However, Toyota got greedy and wanted to make all kinds of cars at all kinds of prices. The trade-offs which used to lead to superior dependability started to fade away. Quality and dependability dropped to levels which hurt the credibility of the old position. People were no longer willing to pay a high premium to get the “dependability” of a Toyota, because it no longer seemed worth it.

Greed and Cheapening
Another outcome of greed may be in underinvesting in the core position in order to cut costs and make more money. To own a position, you have to invest in it. Choke off investment in the strategy (in the name of greed), and your actions no longer fit the strategy. For example, another part of Toyota’s problem was that they underinvested in the quality levels needed to create dependability (in order to increase the profits needed to invest in overreach). This lead to less dependability in the cars and a mis-fit with the customers.

In this economy, companies are finding they can get away with paying their employees less. In the long run, however, this is creating a mis-fit between employees and the company. The good employees leave as soon as they can. They ones who can’t leave get angry and become less committed to putting in any extra effort behind the strategy.

If you cheapen your approach enough (in labor, parts or whatever), execution will eventually suffer to the point where you lose the right to own that position. Then your strategy is lost. Greed for short-term bottom-line gains eventually leads to far lower long-term profits.

Laziness
Sometimes it isn’t overt acts like overreach or cheapening which ruin strategic fit. Sometimes it is just a lack of effort to keep fit from eroding away. We can get lazy in our vigilance to maintain fit. For example, we may let mis-fitting employees creep into the business because we do not police that characteristic close enough in the hiring process. We hire them because they have superstar status and forget to do the due diligence into whether they are the right fit for the culture and strategy. When the fit is wrong, they can poison the culture of a company and ruin the strategy.

Many of the Silicon Valley firms like Google, Apple and Facebook realize how important engineering excellence is to their core strategy. As a result, they are not lazy in their approach to getting the best engineers. They do whatever it takes in terms of pay, perks and image to gather this important resource for their company the best they can.

Another place laziness in fit-seeking can occur is when looking for investment capital. We may take equity investment money from someone just because they want to invest in us and not take the effort to ensure that there is a strategic fit between their objectives and ours (and regret it later when they challenge our strategy due to a mis-match). Or we can acquire a company because the financial models look good, but not do additional due diligence into strategic fit. That lack of strategic fit can make the acquisition a disaster. In fact, poor fit is one of the leading causes of acquisition failure.

Recommendations
As we have seen, strategic fit cannot be assumed to be a given. Fit can fade away due to greed or laziness. Therefore, we need to become proactive in aggressively cultivating strategic fit with all our key stakeholders—investors, employees, customers, partners, supply chain, etc. We need to make fit a high enough priority to overcome the impulses of greed and laziness.

Whenever a decision is being made which impacts a stakeholder, we need to ask this question: Will this move strengthen or weaken strategic fit?

Cultivating fit needs to become integral to the strategy itself. We need to seek out investors who agree with our approach. We need to seek out employees who believe in the strategy. We need to find distributors where supporting our strategy is in their best interests. We need to aggressively seek out those customers who are looking for what we are offering. We need to only aggressively go after acquisitions with a strong fit. It cannot be taken for granted. It must be sought out.

SUMMARY
Strategic implementation is strongest when all the stakeholders to the strategy are well-matched to the strategy. Without a strong fit across the board, the strategy suffers. There are many forces (like greed and laziness) which can naturally work against strategic fit. Therefore, we need to be proactive at seeking out and protecting strategic fit.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Sure, not everyone is a good fit for our company. But that doesn’t mean we should give up looking for them. They are out there. We just need to take the effort to seek them out.

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Strategic Planning Analogy #410: Self Awareness



THE STORY
Imagine, if you will, a man who is trying to find the ideal woman to marry. We’ll call him Bob.

Bob does a great deal of research into determining the characteristics of a great wife. Then he does research into where to find women with these characteristics. Finally, Bob applies “proven” tools for approaching these women.

Unfortunately, Bob has absolutely no luck in convincing any of these women to become his wife. In frustration, Bob complains to one of his friends, “I don’t understand why I am not having success finding the ideal wife. I’ve done all the research and used all the accepted techniques. I found the great women, but none want to be my wife. What am I doing wrong?”

Bob’s friend answers, “Take a look at yourself. You are obesely overweight. You are unemployed. Your personality is rude and obnoxious. You are sloppy and ugly. Until you fix up your own act, no woman will be interested in you.”

“Hmmmm,” says Bob. “I’ve spent so much time looking for the right woman that I never spent any time looking at myself.”

THE ANALOGY
Looking for great business opportunities can be a lot like looking for that perfect spouse. You can do all the research (like Bob did) to determine what the characteristics of a great opportunity are (like high growth, large demand, good margins, low competition, etc.). Then you can do the research to find out where those types of opportunities exist (like emerging economies, or social networking businesses, or green technology). And then you can apply proven techniques to try to get into those great business opportunities (acquisitions, alliances, etc).

And you can still fail miserably, just like Bob.

And the failure may have nothing to do with all that research you did. The problem may be that instead of focusing entirely on looking for opportunities, one needs to occasionally focus on one’s self. Look in the mirror at your own business. Do you have the proper qualities to make the deal work? What are you bringing to the opportunity which adds value? Does your company look to others like Bob—totally undesirable?

It takes two to make a great marriage. Don’t forget your part in the deal.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here has to do with strategic fit. A supposedly great deal may actually be a terrible deal if there is no strategic fit. Even if the opportunity has all the characteristics typically associated with success, it can still be a miserable failure in the wrong hands (no strategic fit). Therefore, when making strategic assessments of potential opportunities, do not look at them in isolation, but in the context of their fit with your organization.

This point was driven home to me in a recent study issued by the Corporate Executive Board. Their report said:

“Despite strategists and senior managers having spent decades on emerging markets strategy, they still spend too much time trying to understand the market and not enough on understanding whether their firm is ready for that market. Our research on over 1,000 market entry examples shows that this mistake is made over 70% of the time.”

In other words, right now emerging markets are the pretty girls that the guys want to marry. But just because the woman looks attractive to you doesn’t mean that you look attractive to the woman. This may seem obvious. However, since businesses are making this mistake of going in ill-prepared over 70% of the time, the idea must not be as obvious as I think.

I’m not saying that these companies are failing because they are bad companies. They just aren’t ready for the opportunity because of a poor fit.

Jigsaw puzzle pieces aren’t inherently good or bad by themselves. What makes them good or bad is whether or not they properly connect with your puzzle piece. If the pieces fit together, everything is good. If not, then the piece is not useful to you—even if it is very useful to someone else.

So what can we learn from this?

1) First, Look In The Mirror
Before going on a strategic quest for the ideal new opportunity, take time to first look into a mirror. Research yourself before researching others. Until you know what you look like, you won’t know what opportunities will fit. Ask yourself questions like these:

a) How can I add value to an opportunity?

b) What is causing me to be successful in some of my current businesses? Is it a particular skill I bring to the marketplace or is it a particular type of characteristic of the marketplace itself?

c) What is causing me to have problems in some of my businesses? Is it the lack of a skill or is it the wrong type of marketplace?

d) Where can I succeed better than others? (Differentiated Skills, Competitive Advantage)

e) Where does my expertise lie? Am I better at a particular stage of a lifecycle (start-up vs. growth vs. maturity)? Am I better with particular value positions (low price vs. high service)?

f) What is the best cultural fit for me?

Based on the answers to these questions, you can now know what are the right criteria to look for in new business opportunities.

2) Don’t Get Seduced By the Hot Fad
At any point in time, there are hot fads in business investments. “Common Knowledge” tells everyone that these are the places to be, so businesses flock to them. As the Corporate Executive Board points out, a current hot fad is getting into emerging markets (like China or Brazil).

Yes, a lot of money will be made in these hot markets. It is also true that many companies will lose a lot of money going after these hot markets. In fact, most companies will fail. Only a few companies (like Amazon) succeeded in the first dotcom bubble. Most died a horrible death.

So just because a market is “hot” does not mean that success is a given. Hot markets can also burn the company that is not prepared or not a good fit.

Therefore, do not get seduced into thinking that you have to pursue particular opportunities just because they are the hot place to be. Don’t think that just because all of your peers are pursuing a particular strategic path that you have to do the same thing.

Instead, look for the opportunities which fit well with what you do. Perhaps your best opportunities lie far away from the current fad.

3) Make Yourself Presentable Before Diving In
Sometimes, an opportunity might have great potential for you, but you are not ready yet for that opportunity. If Bob was going to lure a great wife, he was first going to have to lose some weight, get a job and improve his personality. Your company may need to do something similar.

When McDonalds was beginning to grow internationally, they ran into a problem. They wanted their hamburgers and french fries to have the same quality and taste as in the USA. However, these other nations did not have access to the proper types of cattle and potatoes to make that happen. Therefore, before they could build their restaurants, McDonalds had to spend a great deal of time working with the local agricultural infrastructure. They had to convince the local farmers and ranchers to use McDonalds-style cows and potatoes and raise them in the proper manner.

Until McDonalds got the infrastructure in place, they were ill-prepared to build their restaurants globally. If they had just rushed in with the restaurants (before fixing the infrastructure), they may have failed.

If you find a great opportunity, determine what you need to be successful with it. Then look at what you have to offer. If you are missing something (as McDonalds was with infrastructure), then work on filling that gap before diving into the opportunity. Don’t be like the 70% in the study who fail to spend the time to become appropriately prepared.

SUMMARY
A key aspect of strategic planning is to find future growth opportunities. As important as this is, don’t become so focused on looking outward for opportunities that you fail to look inward at yourself. The best opportunities are the ones that fit with who you are (or who you can be). Preparing yourself to win can be more important than finding a so-called “winning” opportunity.

FINAL THOUGHTS
The more you strengthen your core competencies and skill sets, the more places there will be where you can find additional opportunities to succeed.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Strategic Planning Analogy #363: Star Players



THE STORY
Once upon a time, there was a basketball team which was doing very poorly. The owner of the team started yelling at the coach about how disgusted he was with the team losing all the time.

The coach responded, “The problem is the poor talent on this basketball team. We don’t have any athletic stars on this team. If you can go out and get us some star athletic talent, I can make this basketball team a winner.”

So the owner went out to hire some star athletes. A week or two later, the owner announced that he had just hired some great athletic superstars for the basketball team. These superstar athletes were among the best in their field. It took a whole lot of money to sign them to the team—more than anyone else on the team was making—but the owner was hoping that their superior skills would bring him a winner.

Yet the basketball team continued to lose. In fact, the team was worse than it was before adding the star athletic talent. Why? These star athletes were among the best jockeys the horse racing world had ever seen. Unfortunately, a jockey’s key attributes include being short and light weight—not exactly what you want on a basketball team.

THE ANALOGY
Although the story is made up, it contains a lot of truth. When times are bad, there is a tendency to want to get some superstars on your team. It happens in sports all the time. The idea is that if we can just get one or two star players on the team, we can move from being a loser to being a winner. It’s seen as the quickest way to make a big improvement.

That’s why the top players in a sport make so much money. They are seen as the difference between being a loser and being a winner. And that is worth a lot.

This phenomenon is not just limited to sports. Businesses do this all the time as well. When a business is continuously producing poor results, there is pressure on the board of directors to do something quickly. To common perception is that the quickest path to moving a company from being a loser to being a winner is the same as for a sports team—just hire some star talent.

As a result, businesses pay a fortune to hire one or two superstar leaders from outside the company. They put a business superstar (who’s been on the covers of all the business magazines) into the CEO chair. Unfortunately, the track record for bringing in outside superstars in business is not very successful. James Heskett, a professor at the Harvard Business School, was recently musing on the internet about the research showing how the superstar philosophy often does not usually work in the business world. The results are underwhelming.

Why is that so often the case? I think it is like what happened in the story. You can bring in superstars, but if they are not fit for the task at hand, all that super-ability is wasted. Those may have been the best jockeys in the world—absolute superstars in their field. But their talent is useless for playing basketball. There was not a good fit between the jockey star’s ability and the basketball team’s need.

It also works the other way. A basketball superstar would be a lousy jockey. The outstanding abilities of a leading basketball player are ill-suited to riding a racehorse.

Ignore the fit and you can end up paying too much to get something worthless at getting what you need done.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is simple. Don’t hire jockeys to play basketball (or vice versa). Even the best jockeys will do poorly at basketball, because it goes against their strengths. It is the wrong fit.

I believe the hiring of outside business superstars rarely works because almost by definition it will be a poor fit. Let me explain why.

The Needs of the Business Looking For a Star
Usually, the businesses with the greatest motivation to hire a superstar are like the basketball team in the story—chronic losers. After all, there is little motivation to go outside and spend a fortune on a business superstar if your business is already highly successful. No, it is the companies with lots of problems who have the greatest temptation to go after a superstar.

Although there can be lots of reasons why a company is consistently posting poor results, it usually boils down to two key issues:

1) A Poor Position in the Marketplace. This blog has talked about the importance of positioning probably more than any other topic over the years (for the best one, look here). It is virtually impossible to win in the marketplace unless you have a winning position. You need a reason why a significant number of customers would naturally prefer you over the competition to solve a particular problem. Without a strong position, the only way to get business is by “bribing” customers with below-cost price cuts and outlandish deals. And that is not a path to being a winner.

2) Poor Resources. If you lack in resources, it is hard to win. Those resources could be a lack of knowledge, competency, infrastructure, IT capabilities, money, modern automation, manufacturing capacity, supply chain connections, or a host of other such tools. Just as you cannot build a great house without great construction tools, you cannot build a great business without the needed business tools.

Therefore, it is probably the case that the biggest need of the business looking for a superstar is a new position and/or better resources.

The Abilities of the Typical Superstar
So if that is what the company needs, what does the typical superstar offer? Well, first, we need to understand that business superstars tend to come from highly successful companies. After all, the logic goes like this: how could this person be a business superstar if his or her business is doing poorly? Almost by definition, a superstar must come from a place with consistent success.

This means that the company where the superstar is from probably already has a good position and good resources. So what sets the superstar above the rest? Usually, they are the people who excel in getting the most out of that position and those resources. In other words, they tend to be super-operators. They can leverage those core elements better than others. They can make production more efficient, selling more powerful, and make the most out of the knowledge, data and capabilities inherent in the business.

The Lack of Fit
So here is the problem. The company needs a new position and a complete overhaul of its resources. The business superstar typically knows how to leverage positions and resources, but is clueless into how to create them in a place that doesn’t have them.

This is like hiring jockeys to play basketball. The fit is all wrong. The business superstar’s brilliance is worthless to the weak company, because there is nothing for him to leverage with his leveraging skills.

Jockeys know what to do if there is already a fast horse in existence. But if there is no fast horse, the jockey doesn’t know how to win. Similarly, a business executive skilled at improving a strong business doesn’t know what to do if there is not already strength to the current business.

I had a boss who put it something like this: “We keep hiring all these great people to turn around the business, but instead of their strengths transferring to the business, the weak business transfers to the people.”

Or to quote Warren Buffett, “When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact.”

In other words, when the skill-set of the star does not meet the needs of the business, the star will no longer look like a star. It’s not that they suddenly lost all their skills. They just have skills that are useless for the task at hand. Therefore, if you feel a burning need to turn around a weak company, make sure there is a good fit. Look for the rare star who is great at transformation (moving from weak to strong) rather than the more common star who is great at operation (getting more out of something already good).

SUMMARY
A company which is producing consistently poor results requires a different type of leader than the company that has been consistently strong. Therefore, it is very risky to take someone who has done well in a successful company and put them in a poor company. It is likely that the skill-set of the superstar at the strong company is a poor fit for the different needs at the weak company. Instead, if you are a weak company, look for people who are good at transformation, not good at operating in a place already transformed.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Operating a strategy well is a far different skill than creating a great strategy. Make sure you know which is the priority need before you fill the leadership position.

Friday, February 29, 2008

Analogy #160: Hire My Strategy


THE STORY
One time I was interviewing a candidate for a real estate analyst position. The purpose of this job was to analyze potential new store sites to help determine the likelihood of success if a store were built there.

One of the key responsibilities for this person would be to fly out to potential markets and then drive around to observe the area. These drive-around observations would be used to help determine the quality of the site, the type of neighborhood it is in, and how easy it is to drive to the site.

Near the end of the interview process, the candidate for the position asked a question: “Do you think the fact that I am declared legally blind and unable to drive a car would cause any problems?”

Needless to say, this candidate was not hired for the job.

THE ANALOGY
Trying to land a new job is a lot like trying to land a new strategy. However, in the case of a strategy, one has to do it twice—once to convince the company to “hire” the strategy and once to convince the consumer to “hire” it.

In the story above, the candidate failed to get the job. Since there are usually far more people applying for a job then there are openings, most people who apply will fail. With such a high level of competition, one needs a good plan of attack in order to get hired.

Similarly, consumers usually have many choices of who to patronize. If your strategy does not resonate with them, you will fail to be chosen. Hence, you need a good plan of attack as well.

THE PRINCIPLE
In this blog, we will look at four key principles used by candidates looking for a job and apply them to landing a strategy with your company and your customers.

Principle #1: Make Sure there is a Fit Between Capabilities and Qualifications
One of the best ways to increase your chances of getting a job is by having a close match between your capabilities (what you are good at) and the job’s qualifications (what they are looking for). The tighter the fit, the better the odds of getting the job.

In the story above, there was not a good fit. The job was highly dependent on strong observational skills and the ability to drive well in unfamiliar markets. Unfortunately, the capabilities of the candidate did not match up well to these qualifications. He was legally blind and unable to drive.

Now you may be saying to yourself, “Why would somebody so mismatched even apply for the job?” Yet it is not that uncommon for companies to do that with their strategies.

For example, let us suppose that the market leader in your industry is winning based on a low cost strategy. You might then conclude that a low price strategy is the ideal strategy for your industry and embark on building a low price strategy for your company.

However, your situation may be hampered by the fact that your company is not a low-cost operator. In fact, the market leader has such a cost advantage that you are not even close and could not catch up, let alone surpass them in low cost efficiency. At best, you will be inferior to the entrenched leader on price.

In such a case, your ability to land a low price strategy in the marketplace would have about as much a likelihood of success as a blind person applying for that real estate analyst position. The company should not even be trying to “apply” for that strategic position based on low price. Instead, it should have applied for a strategic position closer suited to its capabilities (Service? Quality? Convenience? Uniqueness?).

If you want to land your strategy, people (both internally and externally) must believe that the company has the capabilities to be the best at delivering what the strategy promises. Then, once you land the strategy, one has to deliver on the promise in order to keep the position. Therefore, only seek out strategic options where you have a chance of actually achieving superiority.

Principle #2: Keep the Resume Clear and Concise
Experts in the field will tell you that there are so many resumes out there, that there is not enough time for recruiters to analyze them all in detail. At best, you only have a few seconds to get your point across. If the recruiter cannot figure out who you are (based on your resume) in a few seconds, your resume is tossed out. Hence, the mandate is to make your resume clear and concise.

The same can be said about a business’ vision/mission/business statement. If it takes more than a few seconds for a person to figure out what you stand for based upon one of those statements, then you have lost the battle. You will be tossed out.

As mentioned in a prior blog (see “Play it Backwards”), fuzzy statements filled with vague platitudes are worthless in pointing out who you really are and what you are trying to accomplish. That makes them too hard for the internal troops to execute and too hard for the customers to embrace.

As marketing guru Al Ries likes to point out, successful companies can get the essence of their position down to a word (or two). For example:
Wal-Mart = Low Price
BMW = Ultimate Driving Machine
Apple = Cool Design
Disney = Family Fun

Can you boil your winning strategy down to a handful of words?

Principle #3: Look the Part
When you go in for an interview, rest assured that the interviewer will not only be paying attention to the words you say. He or she will also be paying attention to how you look. There’s a reason why experts recommend going to the interview in your best outfit, with shoes shined and hair cut.

To get the part, you need to look the part. If you look like a bum, you will be thought of as a bum (regardless of what you say), and few people want to hire a bum.

The same applies to your strategy. It is not just words on a piece of paper. It is the way you interact with all of your stakeholders. To be accepted as having a strategy of quality and service, everything you do must have the appearance of quality and service. Looks need to mirror strategy.

One of the keys to success for the Four Seasons hotels is the fact that everything you see reinforces the position of quality and service. Sometimes quality can be hard to scientifically calibrate as a consumer, because you cannot see all of the workings behind the scenes. Therefore, you look for visual cues to fill in the blanks. Therefore, make sure those visual cues shout out the message that reinforces the strategy.

When the warehouse club concept was first taking off, they sometimes put their stores in previously occupied buildings. I know of instances where the warehouse club operator spent extra money to covert a nice interior to something that appear cheaper in order to give the appearance of a better value.

Similarly, I know of a supermarket operator who did studies and found out that paying baggers to bag your groceries was as cost efficient as having the customer bag their own (since they were faster, so you could have fewer checkout lines). However, the company did not hire the baggers because it would create the appearance of being higher priced, even though it was not higher priced in reality.

Target is currently suffering in this recession, because its appearance in stores and advertising make it appear more expensive than it really is. In reality, Target’s prices are only about 1 or 2% higher than Wal-Mart on comparable items. Yet their appearance makes that gap seem larger.

Principle #4: Get Frequent Exposure
Job hunting experts will tell you that you need to keep your name in front of the hiring influencers. Don’t just send a resume. Also follow up with phone calls. After the interview, follow up with letters and phone calls.

Headhunters can easily forget who you are over time. Therefore, you need to put reminders in front of them on a periodic basis.

The same is true of strategy. If you only pull out the strategy once a year and then put it back on the shelf, it will not become ingrained into who you are and what you do. The essence of the strategy needs to be a part of the everyday conversation. The strategy will be forgotten if there are not frequent reminders.

SUMMARY
Landing a strategy is like landing a job. If you want your strategy to be successful, use the same principles as in job hunting: fit job/strategy to capabilities, have a concise resume/mission statement, look the part, and get lots of exposure.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Once you land a job, the work is not over. You need to keep building your skills and looking for ways to advance your career. Similarly, the job does not end once the strategy is crafted. You need to keep building on your strategic strengths and leveraging your position.