Thursday, July 5, 2007

Horizon Blindness

THE STORY
Back around the time I was in High School, my parents decided to go on a vacation to the Canadian Rocky Mountains. Living in the Detroit area at the time, my parents determined that it was a lot cheaper to cross the Detroit River and fly out of Windsor, Canada, rather than fly out of Detroit. Therefore a buddy and I drove my parents over to Windsor to catch their plane.

As long as we were in Canada, my buddy and I decided to drive around the countryside for a few hours before heading back to the US. Although the Detroit side of the river was quite urban, the Canadian side became farmland very quickly. What impressed me was how far I could see into the distance before coming across a flat horizon line, where the sky met the earth.

This was not a common sight to me. Having spent most of my life in a dense urban environment, you could never look more than a few blocks before your sight was blocked by a building. You would never see a horizon point where the sky touched the land, because it was hidden behind all of those buildings.

It reminded me of a study I had done in high school about the Pygmies of Africa. The Pygmies spend their whole life in the dense jungles, where they can never see more than a few feet in front of them. One day, a group of anthropologists were going to take some Pygmies out of the jungle and back to their university.

This was the first time the Pygmies had ever been out of the jungle. It was also the first time they had ever seen a horizon line out in the distance. The Pygmies were confused because everything out in the distance was tiny. They couldn’t figure out how everything out there could be so much smaller. They were even more surprised when some of these items came closer to them and got larger as they came nearer. How did they miraculously grow in size as they got nearer?

THE ANALOGY
Because the Pygmies had always lived in an environment where they could never see more than a few feet in front of them, they had never developed the concept of depth perception. They had no idea of the principle that things would appear smaller, the farther off they were in the distance. They just assumed that everything would look to be the same size, no matter how far off an object was away. After all, everything always looked to be the same size in the dense jungle. The Pygmies were so used to only looking a few feet in front of them that they did not know how to act when confronted with a more distant horizon.

A similar problem can occur in the business world, except that it involves time horizons, rather than distance horizons. If one spends their whole business life dealing with the crisis of the moment, they never get a chance to see beyond what is immediately in front of them (their crisis of the day). They can become so used to only looking out a day or two at a time that they do not know what to do when confronted with a more distant time horizon.

Items out in more distant time can look funny and small—so small that it is easy to have a tendency to ignore them. Unfortunately, because these people have not looked out into the distance of time before, they are mistaken in thinking that the issues in front of them are small. Instead, they are large, major issues which only appear to be small because of the distance of time. As that time approaches and become nearer, the issues start looming larger and larger. Because these people had never developed depth perception in time, it was all very surprising when these items came closer. They were unprepared to deal with them.

Had they spent more time studying more distant time horizons, they could have developed the depth perception necessary to understand how large an issue is in the future. That would give them ample time to prepare for it today.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of time horizons. Strategic planning requires looking off to more distant time horizons. The purpose is to better understand what is in front of you, so that you can prepare for it in the most advantageous way. If you are unaccustomed to looking off into the distance of time, you will not accurately understand what is in front of you, so your decisions will not be as effective.

One time, I had the pleasure of meeting with John Hagel III, an expert in strategic planning. He was speaking on the topic of time horizons. John Hagel said that in strategy, one must consider three separate time horizons. The first time horizon is the immediate future—what will happen in the next year or so. The type of strategic planning necessary for this time horizon can usually be accomplish via an annual budget, provided your budgeting process is more than just making up numbers to satisfy an unrealistic annual profit target.

A strategic annual budget starts by determining the most likely conditions which a business will encounter in the next year. Then, based on the analysis, the leaders make the tough choices about where in invest or divest its resources (time, talent, treasure) in the next year in order to optimize within that environment.

The second time horizon is typically about 3 to 5 years out. The strategic process for the second time horizon is somewhat similar to the first. One studies the future to determine the likely environment, and then makes plans of how to allocate resources to optimize performance in that environment.

The third horizon is more than five years away. The strategic planning here involves dreaming up a desirable (and possible) future, and then determining what must be done to make that potential future state become the future which actually evolves and comes into being.

John Hagel III made the point that all three planning horizons need to be studied. For example, if one only looks at the first and most immediate time horizon, one may make decisions which look good in the immediate term, but end up destroying a company’s potential in the future. The principle is that by only focusing on the immediate, you squander away your future potential by taking the profits out of the business too quickly rather than reinvesting for the long haul. For more on this topic, see the blogs “Don’t Eat Your Seed Corn” and “Cutting Your Way to Prosperity (Part 3).”

If you only look at the third horizon (more than 5 years out), you may develop a wonderful path to long-term prosperity, only to go bankrupt today because you did not find a way to feed the business today to fund that path. A focus only on the middle horizon may make you fall victim to missing out on both the profits of today and the long-term prosperity.

The most interesting comment made by Hagel was that when most people think about strategic planning, they tend to focus on the middle time horizon (three to five years out). In his opinion, this is the least important of the three. Here is his logic.

Near-term planning can be very powerful, because it is easy for the organization to understand, rally around, and deliver the desired results. Provided the annual targets are realistic, they can be a powerful tool in giving the direction necessary for the people out in the field to do what is necessary in the short term. People are pretty good at finding ways to hit an annual budget (especially if it is tied to bonuses).

Long-term planning can be very powerful as well, because it gives you enough time to actually create the future of your dreams. It takes time to develop the desired competencies and influence how an industry will develop. If done properly, you can actually increase your ability to control the future when given the time to actually create it to your advantage and ensure that the business rules the industry operates under are defined in a manner which benefits your position.

The problem is the mid-term planning. It is too far off to seem relevant to the day to day field employee and to close in to be easily molded and manipulated to your advantage by your company. It is, ironically, the time horizon over which you have the least control even though it is the one we tend to focus on the most.

Therefore, we need to still spend time looking at what is immediately in front of us, like the Pygmies do in the dense jungle. We also need to be looking at far away horizons, where there is still enough time to dream up an ideal state and make plans to bring that state into reality. In other words, we have to sometimes get out of the daily jungle and train ourselves in depth perception.

The middle horizon can then become a combination of forward extrapolation of today’s budget and a backwards extrapolation of that needs to be done in the interim to get to the desired future state. If you only try to do the middle time horizon (without the other two), you cannot properly fit the middle horizon into its proper context between the near and the far.

SUMMARY
Strategic planning needs to look near-term, mid-term and long-term. Otherwise, one may try to maximize the potential in one time frame at the expense of the others. Annual budgets need to be thought of as a means of accomplishing near term strategic goals. And long-term planning must look out far enough to encompass enough time to gain control of how the future will evolve.

FINAL THOUGHTS
My wife recently got tri-focal glasses, so that she can see well at three distances. It took awhile for her to get used to the three lenses, but eventually it became automatic and natural. When starting three-horizon planning, it can be very difficult at first trying to see all three parts. But hang in there…eventually it will become more automatic and natural.

Friday, June 29, 2007

Bumpy Roads are Better

THE STORY
Yesterday, I spent most of the day in a car driving to Chicago for my daughter’s wedding. Fortunately, the roads had been recently repaved, so the ride was nice and smooth. However, I started thinking about what would happen if the road had been really bumpy.

Let’s assume for a moment that we were driving a truck full of items and we had to take these items a long distance on a very bumpy road. Before leaving on the journey, we had loaded the truck in a certain way, with boxes of cereal on the bottom and boxes of basketballs on the top. Once we get on the bumpy road, we can feel the truck bouncing up and down and shaking the entire trip.

At the end of that long and bumpy journey, we open up the back of the truck—and to our horror—we see a jumbled up mess. Some of the boxes of basketballs have shifted to the bottom and some of the boxes of cereal had bounced to the top.

Then, we say to ourselves, “If only we had been able to drive on a smooth road. Then nothing would have changed—everything in the back of the truck would be exactly where we put it at the beginning of the journey.”

THE ANALOGY
Often times, companies can hold an opinion similar to that truck driver. We long for a smooth ride for our journey into the future. We view stability in a marketplace as a good thing. Stability tends to be more predictable. It is easier to do strategic planning in a stable environment. We feel like we have greater control of what is going on.

In reality, however, a smooth and stable ride can be a business person’s worst enemy. Usually, the key objective of strategic planning is to find a way to improve one’s position in the marketplace. This typically requires finding ways to gain market share.

It is extremely difficult to change one’s position and gain share in a very stable environment. To quote our truck driver, on a smooth road everything is in the same place at the end of the journey as it was when we started. Nothing moves. In business, this implies that in a stable environment, it is very difficult to attain a better position, because everyone in the marketplace tends to stay in the same position—nobody moves.

Instead, it is the bumpy and unstable ride which provides the greater opportunities to shift one’s position. In our story, the bumpy ride allowed boxes of basketballs, which had been on the top of the heap, to fall to the bottom while some boxes of cereal were able to make their way to the top. The same is true in business. Instability and change in the marketplace make it easier to shift one’s position from the bottom of the heap to the top.

As business people, it may be in our best interest to steer our business to the bumpy roads

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that changing environments can work to our favor, it we manage it well. Unstable environments have many advantages.

First, in unstable environments, customers are more willing to reconsider their purchasing behavior. We all tend to be creatures of habit. If nothing has changed in the marketplace, then there is little reason to even consider changing one’s habits. People will continue behaving as in the past (without even thinking about it). We just sort of go into autopilot and don’t alter our behavioral course.

However, if there is a lot of change going on, consumers can get jarred out of their habits. In turbulent air, we turn off the autopilot and put our hands back on the steering wheel. We pay more attention to what is going on and may alter our behavioral choices.

A simple example can be seen in the housing market. With the slowdown in people changing their residence, there is less reason to be concerned about home-related purchases. With this type of this stability in living arrangements, consumers just sort of drift through life without paying much attention to their home environment. Instead, other, more pressing issues of the day fill our mind. As a result, sales at retailers selling things related to the home, like Home Depot and Lowes, suffer.

However, when people have a major change in their lifestyle by moving into a new home, they take the time to reassess what they own and what they need. New needs arise, and sales at places like Home Depot go up. The change in residence increased one’s awareness of home needs and increased purchasing in that area.

Grocery shopping can be very habitual. People tend to shop the same store at the same time each week. These habits will rarely change from week to week, especially if there is stability in the marketplace. It is only when our environment changes that we get jarred out of that habitual pattern.

Perhaps a Wal-Mart supercenter opens up in the neighborhood, offering a new alternative to the conventional supermarket. Perhaps we get a huge promotion which changes our financial position. Maybe we are entertaining the boss for dinner at our house tonight. Any of these changes could get us out of our weekly rut and cause us to change where we shop or what we buy for groceries.

Therefore, change and instability can be our friend, particularly if we do not like our current position. Change causes people to stop their sleepwalking through life and pay attention—to rethink their habits. This is when people will be most receptive to paying attention to your marketing message. This is when they are most likely to switch their loyalty from someone else to you.

A second benefit from change is that it provides an opportunity to redefine the marketplace in your favor. In the grocery world, choices were often ruled by price. If you had the lowest prices, you tended to win. However, we are now entering a changing environment. There are scares of tainted food coming out of China (if it can kill our prized pets, what might it eventually do to us?). People are starting to worry more about the impact companies have on the environment. As baby boomers age, they are worrying more about health concerns. All of these changes can provide an opportunity to redefine how people think about food. Rather than stressing price, one can change the value priority to include more concern over health and safety.

Firms like Whole Foods are finding many converts who are changing their values regarding food and are willing to pay a little bit more to people who are selling food more in tune with these new values.

The benefit here is that if you are not the best at providing what consumers are looking for today, change may provide the opportunity to convince people to reconsider their values so that they prize more of what you are the best at providing.

Therefore, we should embrace change in the marketplace. It can be our friend in terms of increasing demand, increasing receptivity to our marketing, increasing shifting of share to our brand, and getting people to change their value priorities to more closely match our strengths.

If the market is stable, it can be in our best interest to take the initiative to create the instability on our own. Maybe we need to do something shocking, to wake people out of their autopilot and rethink their habits.

There’s a reason why the word “new” is so powerful. It makes what we currently do seem “old.” If we say we are “new”, it is more likely to break a habit than if we say we are “just like before.” And if we aren’t new, then maybe we can help convince people that their situation has changed, which should cause them to reassess their behavior—hopefully in your direction.

SUMMARY
Although stability may appear to be a nice thing, it tends to freeze a marketplace and inhibit change. Strategy is about changing one’s situation for the better. That is easier when a market is in turmoil. Therefore, if there is change in the marketplace, use it to your advantage. Anticipate which direction the change will take the marketplace and then position yourself to be best suited for the change. If change is not occurring, try to create change on your own.

Bumpy rides can often lead to better end points, where your boxes shift to the top of the heap.

FINAL THOUGHTS
If you are a market leader, you may not like change, because you may have nowhere to go but down if things change. However, given enough time, change will occur, whether you like it or not. So you may as well prepare for it.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Every Intersection is Not a Crossroad

THE STORY
One time, a colleague and I were talking about how some companies do their strategic planning. Once a year, they bring together a large gathering of their executives for an offsite planning meeting. At the meeting, a big announcement is made that the company is “at a crossroad” in their strategy and that major changes are needed to get back on track or to choose a new direction.

It got me thinking. In the average city there may be 12 blocks to a mile. If you are able to maintain an average speed of 30 miles per hour, you will drive past an intersection about every 10 seconds.

You would think a driver was rather crazy if he stopped his car every ten seconds, got out of the car, and started telling everyone excitedly that he was at a major crossroad. Then, if he held a long business meeting to decide which direction to go every time he came to an intersection, you would really think he was mad. At that pace, it would take him all day to get across town.

So I turned to my friend and said, “When you’re driving across town, you will go past hundreds of intersections. You can’t call every one of them a major crossroads.”

THE ANALOGY
Automobiles are like companies, driving towards their future. Intersections along the road are opportunities—opportunities for a company to change its strategic direction. Just because every intersection provides an opportunity to turn does not mean that you need to turn at every intersection. In most cases, a driver ignores the majority of the intersections and does not even consider them while driving, because he knows that they will not lead to his destination.

In the same way, every opportunity presented to a company does not require a rethinking of strategy. Most opportunities can be ignored. Instead of leading to someplace special, they will just take you on a detour that goes nowhere, while at the same time keeping you from reaching your intended strategic destination. These “opportunities” turn out to only be opportunities to get side-tracked, waste resources, and fail in achieving a lasting strategic success.

Often times, the most important aspect of a strategy is not what it tells you to do, but in defining the greater list of things you are not supposed to do. Knowing what you can ignore can free you to better focus on the few essentials needed for strategic success. The likelihood of success becomes much easier, because you can focus on only those things that help you reach your strategic destination. Using the driving analogy, let us say that your strategic destination is Paris. As you are driving along, you can ignore all of the roads that do not lead to Paris and only focus on the smaller subset of roads that moves in a direction towards Paris. As a result, you will get to Paris sooner and enjoy it longer.

Of course, just because you can ignore many of the intersections does not mean that you can ignore every intersection. If you stay on any single road long enough, eventually it will lead to a dead end. The same is true with strategy. It never runs exactly in a straight line. You may need to drive around a roadblock set up by your competition. You may need to make a small side trip to acquire new competencies for the journey ahead.

Therefore, ether extreme will get you in trouble. If you turn at every possible intersection, you will end up driving in circles and end up getting nowhere. At the same time, if you never turn, you will end up running out of road before you reach your destination.

THE PRINCIPLE
Effective strategic planning has three elements:
1. A vision of an attainable position where you can win/prosper in the future.
2. A path showing the steps necessary to get from where you are today to the vision.
3. A feedback loop to ensure that you are going in the right direction once you start the journey down the path.

The Vision
Creating a vision that properly motivates your team to act properly has a lot to do with getting the right perspective on timing. If you have chosen a vision that is too far into the future, the people in your business may not know which path to take to get there, because they cannot find the link between where they are today and where the future vision is. For example, if you told the driver in our analogy that the ultimate destination is to go to the moon, he may have no idea how to get his automobile closer to the moon. Worse yet, he may think your goal is too outrageous and is impossible to achieve, so he stops listening to you and drives wherever he wants. Now, not only are you no closer to the moon, you no longer have a team.

Goals that your people cannot relate to because they are too far away or too different from what they understand fail to motivate. Instead, they may have the opposite effect of paralyzing the troops or leading them into chaos or defection.

Now it may be true that for your business, it is necessary to build a future that eventually takes you as far away from where you are today as the moon is distant from the earth. But, to make the vision real for the team that you want to take there, you may need to break it down into smaller chunks. For example, instead of just saying you are going to the moon, tell the team that the first goal is to get to Florida, where the Cape Canaveral space launching pad is located. Now this is something they can find on a roadmap and draw a path and a plan to get there.

Of course, there is a different problem if you break down the vision into too small of a block of time. If the timing around your vision is too short, you will not be able to build a suitable path. For example, let’s say that instead of telling people we are going to the moon, all you tell them is that the vision is to back the car out of the garage. This is something the team understands and can easily accomplish, so they rush out to the car and back it out of the garage. Then they get out of the car and come back to say, “We’ve accomplished our vision! We’ve reached our goal!” This is followed by a celebration.

Well, now you need to give them a new vision, so you tell them to get back into the automobile and back down the driveway to get to the street. So the team goes back to the car and gets to the end of the street and start to celebrate again. This is starting to sound like our earlier example, where the man sets his goal only a block away at a time, requiring a need to stop every ten seconds to set a new vision. At this pace, you will never get to the moon.

Worse yet, because the team has no idea of the larger vision, they will only prepare for the shorter vision. If all you think you are doing is backing a car out of the garage, you may just hop into the car quickly and do it, without bothering to even put on a coat or shoes. You certainly wouldn’t be thinking about packing a suitcase with spare clothing, bringing along snacks to eat, or checking to make sure the engine is in fine working order. However, if you knew that you were eventually driving 1000 miles to get to the space launching pad in Florida, you might prepare differently. Without proper preparation, you may never reach your goal.

Therefore, the ideal vision should describe a destination that is far enough away from today that people will adequately prepare for the journey (further away than just getting to the end of the driveway), but not so far away that they have no idea how to prepare for the journey (not as far as going to the moon).

The Migration Path
Once the vision is described, the task moves to designing the migration path to get there. Designing the migration path would be like getting a map and determining the best roads to take to get to Cape Canaveral in Florida. Just as the perfect vision requires getting the right balance in terms of timing (not too short, not too long), the perfect migration path needs to get the right balance in terms of detail (not too much, not too little).

The team should not spend years on trying to design the absolute perfect path to get from here to Cape Canaveral. That level of detail is impractical. After all, there may be detours along the way. Changes in weather may affect which route is the best. Unexpected road construction may occur. There may be unexpected problems with the automobile. All of these occurrences will create a need to alter your route, no matter how much time you spend perfecting it.

In the business world, you cannot entirely control your destiny. Therefore, acting as if you can and spending too much time designing perfection into your plan is a waste of time.
On the other hand, if you do not prepare at all, your vision will never be reached. You will be reacting to your environment, rather than helping to direct how the future evolves. If you do not try to help direct how the future evolves, your competition will, and I can assure you that they will try to form a future that advantages them over you.

Hence, you need a balance in your migration path—enough detail to show what big activities need to be accomplished to help control your destiny and reach your vision, but not so much detail that there is no room to flex with the inevitable change.

Feedback Loop
As you start implementing your plan, you need to monitor your progress through a feedback mechanism, in order to:

• Ensure that you are not unintentionally deviating from the vision and migration path; and

• Determine whether changes in the environment necessitate modifications to the vision and/or migration path.

The beauty of driving past a new intersection every ten seconds is not that you have to stop at every intersection. The beauty is that if you find out that you are off course a little bit, you are only ten seconds away from an opportunity to readjust your direction to get back on track. Each intersection should not be seen as a major crossroad requiring a new strategic initiative, but as an opportunity to adjust to stay on plan.

SUMMARY
Strategic planning is about determining a destination for your business (a vision) and a means to get there (a migration path). If you find yourself frequently making major changes to your vision or migration path, then you have probably:

• Set your destination too close to where you are today (and thereby never make any meaningful forward progress); or

• Set your destination so far away or made your migration path so vague that the team members do not understand what to do to get there (and thereby get nowhere); or

• Not monitored your progress through a feedback loop often enough to see when current actions need to be adjusted to get back on track (before it is too late).

It’s okay to adjust the focus of the company every year based on where it is along the migration path, but if your business reinvents its overall strategic plan and migration path every year, then you really do not have a plan at all. You just have a series of unrelated tactics.

FINAL THOUGHTS
We might laugh at a person driving across town one block at a time, stopping every ten seconds at each intersection to replot his course. However, this is not that different from a company that only plans out one quarter at a time, stopping every three months to plot a new course.

In general, if your long-term destination is correct, most of the quarters along the way will be successful. However, if you only look out one quarter at a time, the cumulative direction of all of your quarters strung together rarely moves in a positive direction, and your business will “run out of gas” before reaching a more desirable future.

Monday, June 25, 2007

Gems on the Cutting Room Floor

THE STORY
Back during World War II, there was a shortage of rubber. Scientists in the United States were trying to quickly come up with a viable synthetic substitute. James Wright was one such scientist, working at one of GE’s laboratories under a government contract.

While working on the project, he accidentally dropped some boric acid into silicone oil. The combination produced a goo which had many rubber-like properties. When GE tried to get interest in this compound around the world, there were no takers, not even the US War Production Board. It was seen as no better than the synthetic rubbers already in use.

Well, at least the scientists had fun with it. They would roll it in a ball and bounce it, or stretch it flat and use it to lift a copy of a newspaper article. In 1949, Peter Hodgson, an unemployed ad man, was at a party where the scientists were playing with their invention. Hodgson saw potential in this failed experiment, so he borrowed $147 and bought the production rights from GE. He started producing the product under the name of “Silly Putty.” When he died in 1976, the success of Silly Putty caused Hodgson’s estate to be worth $140 million.

THE ANALOGY
In the process of creating a strategy, one can go through a lot of ideas. Most of the ideas will be awful. A handful will be very good. Many ideas may be interesting, but really “off strategy.” In other words, they may have some business potential, but they do not fit the strategic direction of the company.

In the story above, the strategy was to help the war effort by designing a high quality synthetic rubber. Silly Putty, tried, but failed in that strategic effort. Since it was useless towards fulfilling the synthetic rubber strategy and well outside the core competencies of GE to be in the toy business, the silly putty idea was essentially thrown away.

Peter Hodgson was able to get the rights to the product from GE for practically nothing. He was basically allowed to sweep up a gem off the waste that GE had tossed onto the floor. Just because an idea does not fit one’s strategy does not mean that one should just toss it away. It may be a wonderful fit in someone else’s strategy.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that good ideas have value, even if they have no real value to you with regards to your current strategy. If the idea is really, really fantastic, it may be worth your while to change your strategy. It can be a wiser move to abandon what you originally wanted to do and switch to building a strategy around that gem you threw away onto the floor. There is no harm in abandoning a path if a far better path comes along.

A second approach would be to diversify into continuing your current strategy as well as the new strategy. Although this can sometimes make sense, there is a risk that by trying to do two entirely different things, one can lose focus and end up doing neither well.

A third approach would be to “sell” the idea to someone else. This can often be a wise move, because the idea may be more valuable to someone else’s strategy than your own. There are a number of ways to sell an idea.

One can license the idea and get royalties. Once can invest in setting up someone else in the business and get a share of the profits. One can sell the idea for shares in the other company. Or one can just sell all rights for a fee. In general, I would think that the best way to sell the idea is one where you get a higher share of any upside potential.

After all, it was most likely going to end up on your cutting room floor with no value. Therefore, little is lost if you do not get much for the idea up-front. However, if you negotiate to get a piece of the action, either through royalties or shares in the company, then you can really rake in some easy profits.

This approach may also make more sense to a potential buyer, who may not have a lot of up-front money to pay you and who, at the time, has little to lose by giving you a piece of future action which may never occur.

One of the worst things to do is just hand it over for virtually nothing. GE got practically nothing out of the Silly Putty deal, even though their invention was worth hundreds of millions of dollars to Hodgson.

Xerox’s famous Palo Alto research facility came up with a whole slew of great inventions which others made millions off of while Xerox got practically nothing. If Xerox had gotten out of its core business and gotten into the full-time business of selling their great ideas at a fair price, they probably would have been better off.

Getting into the Venture Capital business full-time may not be right for you, but getting profit out of a great idea which does not fit your core strategy should always be considered. Perhaps you can set up some of your employees who discovered the idea into a separate company (for a share of the profits). Perhaps you can spend a little time figuring out who the idea might be most useful to and then spend a little time pitching it to them.

Sometimes you can have your cake and eat it too. Let’s suppose for a minute that Silly Putty had also been a great synthetic rubber. Just because that would fit the strategy and make lots of money for GE, it does not stop them from also selling the idea as a toy to someone else. Why not use it internally for your purposes and still sell it to others for different purposes. You may have many great areas in your business that could be redeployed elsewhere.

HEB supermarkets in Texas was so good at deploying technology in their stores that they set up a separate profit center to consult with other retailers in how to use technology. They figured that so many people were asking to tour their operations, they may as well charge for the privilege.

SUMMARY
Ideas can have great value, even if they are not useful in helping your strategy. Their worth may be more valuable in the hands of others. It may be worthwhile to spend a little time to see if you can get these ideas into a place where they can be more valuable (and share in that value, especially for a piece of the upside). Even ideas that are useful to you may also be useful to others, so that you can get your return on that idea twice. It sure beats just throwing the idea away.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Of course, this type of discussion implies that your company spends lots of time coming up with ideas. Unfortunately, I know a lot of places that see strategy very narrowly in terms of “more, cheaper.” In other words strategy doesn’t get much further than setting targets to get more (sales, earnings, production, etc.) while spending less (cutting budgets). If that’s your version of strategy, then this blog has little application to you.

Saturday, June 23, 2007

Early Bird

THE STORY
Back in the late 1990s a phenomenon was sweeping through US protestant churches. Some churches were changing the style of worship music. Instead of singing traditional hymns backed by a large organ, they went to singing contemporary praise songs backed by a “praise band,” with electric guitars and drums. Choirs were replaced with song leaders and soloists.

This change in music seemed to strike a chord (pun intended) with a good number of people. The early churches which adopted this change in music started growing in membership very quickly. Many became “mega-churches”, with congregations of several thousand.

People in religious circles started to take notice. “Experts” in church growth started writing about it and, when consulting with churches that wanted to grow, advised them that they needed to ditch the hymns and go with praise songs.

At first, the advice seemed to work. Those churches that were early adopters of this new worship format saw similar types of rapid growth. However, after awhile, the later adopting churches which changed their format more recently were not seeing a similar type of growth. Instead, they were seeing the opposite—more people were leaving than coming.

It’s the same strategy as before. It’s still working for the early adopter churches. Why isn’t it working for the later adopters?

THE ANALOGY
The early adopting churches of contemporary worship were providing something new and different to worshippers. Since only a small minority of churches were doing it at first, the people who wanted to worship this way had to flock to the few places that were offering it. This caused the membership in these early adopter churches to swell in size.

The later adopters were facing a different problem. First of all, many of the people at these churches were there because they did not desire a contemporary worship service. If they had really wanted contemporary worship that badly, they would have switched to worshipping at one of the early adopter churches.

Second, by switching over to contemporary worship late in the game, these churches were not really offering anything new that wasn’t already available. Those that preferred contemporary worship would already be worshipping at one of the early adopter churches of contemporary worship. There would be no reason for them to switch to the late adopter church.

Finally, the early adopter churches had attracted some of the best musicians of contemporary worship in the neighborhood. They had been at it for awhile and were pretty good at it. The later adopters were still adjusting to the change and were in most cases not as polished as what the early adopters had become by this time. So the later adopters would appear at first to not be as good at contemporary worship as those more established in the format.

Therefore, many of the ones who were in the later adopting churches who did not want the contemporary worship left those churches and few who preferred contemporary worship came to take their place.

Businesses can fall into the same pattern. Early adopters get a competitive advantage by getting into a new strategic trend while it is still relatively unique. Businesses who enter into the same strategy at a later date do not achieve anywhere near the same benefit as the early adaptors, even though it is the same strategy which worked for the early adaptors.

As they say, the early bird gets the worm.

THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of early adoption. In general, early adopters of a strategy get more benefits out of the strategy than later adopters. There are three reasons for this:

1. Negotiating Benefits
2. Differentiating Benefits
3. Perpetuating Benefits

This picture helps illustrate these benefits. These are explained below.

1) Negotiating Benefits
In the business world, when you have something new and different to offer, it is often difficult to get that first big customer. Nobody wants to be the first one to put their reputation on the line in case the new idea doesn’t pan out. However, once you land that first big customer and you can prove success, others will quickly fall in line around your product.

Since getting that first big account is so important, one is often willing to bend over backwards to get that business. You may offer that first customer a lot more than what the following customers get. This could include things like:

a) A lower price
b) More on hands help from the seller
c) More promotional dollars
d) Exclusivity for a period of time
e) Perhaps even a piece of equity in the company

The early adopter is in a much more powerful position when negotiating the deal. They can ask for and typically get more than if they wait, because the early adopter has to power to make or break a new concept or product.

I remember back when Sears introduced the Discover card. At first, no other retailer wanted to honor the card. It looked like it was going to be a dismal failure. Eventually, however, the Dayton Hudson company (now Target Corp.) decided to honor the Discover Card at its department stores and discount stores. Once Dayton Hudson signed up, others soon fell in line and started to honor the card. I would imagine that Dayton Hudson got a pretty good deal when they signed up to honor the card. It was most likely a better deal than what the followers got.

Best Buy discovered Netflix long before it was a popular brand. Best Buy approached Netflix with an offer to help make it a success. Of course, Best Buy was in a more powerful position than Netflix. Assistance by Best Buy could be the difference between Netflix succeeding or failing. So Best Buy negotiated a sweet offer and helped to make Netflix the powerful brand it is today. I highly doubt that those who came along later to help sell Netflix got as good a deal as Best Buy.

The point is that if you think a new idea or concept is going to take off, it is better to get in early, because that is when you have the most negotiating power to get a better slice of the new business.

2) Differentiating Benefits
As we saw with the churches, the ones who were early adopters created differentiation in the marketplace. They were offering something new and different. This gave people a reason to switch to the early adopters. By the time the late adopters got around to the change, it was not longer differentiating. It was just like others in the marketplace, providing little reason to switch to them.

You can see that with Best Buy and its Geek Squad. Best Buy was the first major retailer to provide great service on high technology. This gave them a competitive edge for a time…a reason to go to Best Buy over the competition. It was so successful that others eventually felt the need to copy the idea, such as Circuit City with Firedog and Staples with “Easy Tech” service. However, by coming in later, they were not offering anything new or differentiating. They were just playing catch up (and I’ll bet Best Buy picked off the best service people by being first, so that they will have a hard time catching up in quality of the service).

When you are the first to offer something that is truly new and desirable, one can often (for a time) charge a premium price and still grow market share. By the time the late adopters get into the game, it is more competitive. The premium price goes away through price wars. In the end, most everyone ends up with a similar offering, but the early adopter got more profits out of it during the time when it was a differentiating strategy rather than a “me too” strategy. So if you are all going to end up offering the service eventually, it pays to get in when there are still differentiation benefits (for market share and profit margin).

3) Perpetuating Benefits
If you are an early adopter, you get to reap the benefits of early negotiation and early differentiation. These help give you an advantage versus competition, who did not get the additional profitability and market share like the early adopter. These additional benefits can be plowed back into the business to make it even stronger than before (making it ever harder for competitors to catch up).

In addition, when others come along with the next big new thing, they will probably first go to the one who has the reputation for being an early adopter. You get to be first in line to get all those advantages again, which can further strengthen your position in the marketplace.

As a result, early adopters get into a perpetuating virtuous cycle, where they keep increasing their advantage relative to competition.

SUMMARY
Eventually all great new things eventually become the norm—the radical becomes tomorrow’s traditional. If you wait until they are the new tradition before jumping in, you miss out on all of the advantages gained by the early adopter. If the transition is going to happen anyway, one may as well get in early.

FINAL THOUGHTS
Getting in early does not mean jumping into every half-baked scheme which comes along. Most new ideas are bad ideas. Be choosy. Just don’t wait until it is already a proven success before jumping in. Take calculated risks.