THE STORY
I love to stare at maps. I find them fascinating. If you stare at them long enough, you start seeing some interesting things. For example, we think of Minneapolis/St. Paul as a very cold and northerly location. However, when you look at the same latitude as Minneapolis in Europe, you end up in the south of France, a place we do not usually think of as cold and northerly. Yet, the fact is that Minneapolis is about the same distance from the North Pole at Southern France.
Detroit, Chicago and Boston are also thought of as being relatively cold and northerly. Yet they are about as close to the equator as places like Rome, Italy and Barcelona, Spain in the heart of the Mediterranean Sea. Not exactly the same climate zone, even though the same latitude.
And what about our friend London, England? Well, if you take the same latitude as London and come over to North America, you end up on the north shore of Ontario, Canada in James Bay, about 1,100 miles north of Toronto. Sure, London can get cold, but nothing like James Bay.
So if someone tells you to pack your bags for a vacation, and the only thing they tell you is the latitude of your destination, you really don’t know very much. You have no idea what clothes are appropriate to bring.
THE ANALOGY
There’s a reason why you can have so many different climate zones at the same latitude. Climate is determined by more than one’s distance from the equator. Not only do you have to consider latitude, but you also have to consider altitude. And, more importantly, one has to take into account climate changers like ocean currents. Northern Europe is kept warm due to the Atlantic Meridonal Overturning Current, otherwise known as the Atlantic Conveyor.
The Atlantic Conveyor works to warm Northern Europe in two ways. First, it brings warm water from the Gulf of Mexico to Northern Europe. Second, it promotes “chimneys” in the ocean which push the coldest water straight down to the ocean bottom so that the warmer water stays closer to the surface. These factors are estimated to account for 10 to 15 degrees Fahrenheit of additional warmth for Northern Europe. The difference between 50 degrees Fahrenheit and 75 degrees is certainly enough to change your wardrobe.
In Southern Europe, Mediterranean Sea currents help keep coastal areas warm. Northerly winds off the Mediterranean even help to keep Germany warmer than it would otherwise be.
What makes this so deceptive is that all the warmth-providing activity is taking place below the surface. You cannot really see it with the naked eye. It is happening deep in the oceans and seas, and requires thousands of miles of territory in order to measure the full impact.
The latitude is something that is easy to measure. You can quickly look up any city in an atlas and get its latitude (or even faster on the internet). The impact of complex ocean currents gets a bit more complicated.
This same principle can hold true in the business world. We like to make strategic decisions based on facts. In this day and age, it is easy to get overloaded with a lot of facts. All of these facts can lull us into a sense of confidence about our decision-making. However, if you just look at the surface facts, you can come to some wrong conclusions, just like you can come to the wrong conclusions about climate from just looking at latitudes.
To get a complete picture of a market, one needs to find those undercurrents which are not immediately discernable on the surface, yet have a major impact on customer behavior. A business climate can be as complex as a weather climate. Your chances of bringing the right baggage for the job will require looking for those hidden factors which influence behavior.
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is that just because two groups of customers may share vary similar demographic characteristics, it does not necessarily mean that they will react the same way to your strategy.
Think of DNA, a measurable trait. A human and a chimpanzee have nearly identical DNA, yet I think that if you marketed to chimpanzees the same way as you do to humans, you would not get the same results. The same is true on other measurable traits.
We can see this in a demographic factor like ethnicity. Just because someone is a Hispanic in the United States does not mean that they behave the same way or can be appealed to in the same way. Some of these differences are due to factors thousands of miles away, just like the impact of the Gulf of Mexico on England’s climate. For example, if a Hispanic immigrated to the US from Puerto Rico, they will have different characteristics from a Hispanic originally from Mexico, because the Hispanics bring a bit of their culture of origin with them to the US.
Another major impact is time. A third generation Hispanic in the US is typically not very different from mainstream Americans, whereas a first generation Hispanic acts very differently. One has to dig a little deeper below the surface to segregate Hispanics by generation in the US.
If one looks globally at a factor like household income, one can see vastly different standards of living, even though the amount of money earned is about the same. “Middle Class” behavior often has only a tangential relationship to income, just like temperature is only tangentially related to latitude.
I remember over a decade ago when Marsh Supermarkets, out of Indianapolis, Indiana decided to build a large supermarket in India. The “facts” seemed to show a rising percentage of households in India with incomes large enough to afford the benefits of supermarket shopping. Based on facts like this, they built a store in India. It was an utter disaster.
What Marsh discovered was that the due to a different labor market than in the US, the people in India who could afford to shop at supermarkets could also afford cheap labor to do their grocery shopping for them. These shoppers preferred to patronize the small independent shops, because these shopkeepers were their friends and were more in tune with the culture of these hired hands. Hence, the culture of the hired hands was more important than the affluence of the family who hired them when it came to choosing where to purchase groceries. I guess that even though Indianapolis starts with the word “India,” that does not make you an expert on the nuances of Indian culture.
Recently, the Wall Street Journal wrote an article on the fact that Disney has finally decided to no longer go it alone when entering cultures different from the US. They are forming partnerships with local companies who know the undercurrents of the local culture. In India, Disney formed a partnership with Yash Raj Films, a local family-oriented film company in the Bollywood tradition.
To quote the Wall Street Journal,
“Disney's traditional approach was largely to force-feed its U.S. products from its Burbank, Calif., headquarters. The company ultimately concluded the cookie-cutter approach wouldn't work, and now it is going country by country, with a particular focus on five hot markets: India, China, Russia, Latin America and South Korea. ‘We're building Disney from scratch,’ in countries such as India, said Mr. Iger, citing the company's founder and namesake: Just ‘as Walt did in the U.S. over 50 years ago.’"
SUMMARY
Surface statistics, like latitude or demographics, only tell part of the story and can lead to wrong strategic conclusions. Often, underlying currents of culture and history can have a greater impact than the surface statistics. It pays to dig a little deeper under the surface (or find people who are already intimate with these undercurrents).
FINAL THOUGHTS
Just knowing the distance from the equator can be very misleading about climate if you do not differentiate between miles north versus miles south. The Northern Hemisphere has opposite seasons from the Southern Hemisphere. Now that would really throw off your ability to pack the right clothing.
Wednesday, June 20, 2007
Monday, June 18, 2007
The Same, Yet Better
THE STORY
Sometimes I feel sorry for the American automakers. In their advertising, they always seem to find a need to tell the audience something to the effect that, “We are just like Honda and Toyota, only better.”
Of course, a statement like than brings up a number of questions:
1) The more you keep telling me that Toyota and Honda are the ideal benchmark for comparison, the more you are convincing me that they are the gold standard. Aren’t you then implying that the foreign car is the one I should really be desiring instead of the American car?
2) If you are just like them, how can you be better than them?
3) If Honda and Toyota are the ones you are trying to imitate, how can a copy become better than the original? At best, shouldn’t you only be able to achieve parity? And if you are trying to catch up with them, won’t you always be a step behind?
4) If you are better than them, then why do you have to sell your cars at a discount to a Honda or Toyota?
Apparently, I’m not the only one who has trouble with this logic, since Toyota just keeps getting stronger.
It’s sort of like a child on the playground saying, “I’m just as tall as the tall kids, only taller.” First, if you were really that tall, wouldn’t you be one of the “tall kids”? Second, if you are just like them, then how can you be taller?
THE ANALOGY
The point of most strategies is to find a way to gain market share. For your product or service to gain market share, someone else’s product has to lose market share. As a result, strategies tend to target the place where the most market share lies—with the market leader.
That is why American automobile brands tend to target Toyota and Honda—because that is where the market share is. The problem is not that others have the market share you want. The problem is in how you go after that share.
It is safe to assume that the market leaders got there for a reason. Therefore, many believe that if they can take that reason away from the leaders and attach that same reason to their brand, then they will become the leader. Hence the strategy of “I’m just like the leader, only better.”
The problem, as we have seen, is that it is difficult to win with that type of logic. Saying that “I’m just like the leader, only better” is not very convincing. That type of logic points the consumer to your competitor as the standard for what is good. Instead, it is better to discount the standard set by the leader by setting a different standard for what is good, and claim that for yourself.
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of comparison. To win market share, one must convince the customer that, when compared to the competition, you are superior in some meaningful way. As we have seen, it is difficult to create a sense of superiority for yourself if you use as your benchmark the factor which made the current leader successful. All you are doing is playing into their strength.
Over the years, I have learned two important facts:
1) BEFORE YOU CAN CONVINCE SOMEONE THAT YOU ARE SUPERIOR TO THE COMPETITION, YOU MUST FIRST CONVINCE THEM YOU ARE DIFFERENT FROM THE COMPETITION.
2) THE BEST WAY TO CONVINCE SOMEONE YOU ARE DIFFERENT IS TO EMPHASIZE A DIFFERENT SET OF ATTRIBUTES.
These are explained below.
1) Before you can convince someone that you are superior to the competition, you must first convince them you are different from the competition.
Claiming to be the same, but better is a hard sell, because it is impossible to be viewed as better if you are perceived as merely the same. This is especially true if another brand has already achieved ownership to that attribute in the minds of the customer.
To be better, one needs to be different. There is a specific order here. First you have to prove you are not the same—that you are different. Then, and only then, can you prove that the thing which makes you different is the thing that makes you better. This can be very convincing.
This is how Dawn won the dishwashing liquid war. Before Dawn, the standard upon which one rated a dishwashing liquid was on how clean it made the dishes. Dawn came to market by ignoring this. First, it claimed to have unique superiority in fighting grease. Since nobody else was making that claim, and since Dawn was pretty good at fighting grease, it won that argument. Then, Dawn tried to prove that grease fighting is the most important attribute for choosing a dishwashing liquid. It won enough people with that argument to win the entire dishwashing war.
2) The best way to convince someone you are different is to emphasize a different set of attributes.
It is hard to prove a difference to the competition if you are picking on the competition’s strength. First, there is less room to create a differential, since they are already good at it. Second, the consumers will always give the leader the benefit of the doubt on the attributes which gave them the leadership position.
Therefore, if you want to prove you are different, it is better to pick a new, unclaimed territory. Dawn did that with grease fighting.
Going back to the automobile industry, Chrysler was an also-ran in the truck business. Looking at the leaders (Ford and Chevy), Chrysler saw that they were trying to win with a rational appeal. They were emphasizing rational facts, like how much weight you could put in the truck bed, how much it could tow, how long they last, etc. Rather than try to compete in this rational space, Chrysler went for something entirely different—an emotional appeal.
Chrysler designed its trucks to look sexy in a testosterone sort of way. They were made to look like the big rigs—the semis. They even put an engine in them built by the company that makes semi engines. They made you feel like you were driving something special—that you were a big man on the road like a semi driver. The commercials emphasized the bragging rights to having a manly machine rather than to any rational features. This strategic approach boosted their market share more than anything else they had ever done in the truck space.
In the retail space, I remember when Wal-Mart was just starting to expand out of their southern US base. As they were moving east to the Carolinas, they were going to meet up with the local chain, called Rose’s. Rose’s decided that Wal-Mart was a leader based on certain things, so before Wal-Mart got to the Carolinas, Roses had converted its stores to look as much like a Wal-Mart as possible. They painted their stores with the same color scheme, put up signs that looked like Wal-Mart, displayed merchandise like Wal-Mart, and so on.
Unfortunately, when Wal-Mart came to town, people saw that one thing Rose’s could not copy was how low Wal-Mart’s prices were. Since it imitated everything else, Rose’s was seen as having no distinctive advantage—it was just a higher priced version of Wal-Mart. Rose’s soon disappeared as a company.
By contrast, Shopko tried a distinctively different tactic. While Wal-Mart was winning the battle of low everyday prices, Shopko decided to win the battle of having the best advertising deals—a high/low approach to pricing. It provided a distinct alternative in the marketplace. Shopko is still in existence today, more than 20 years after Wal-Mart entered their territory.
SUMMARY
Before you can convince someone you are superior, you must first convince them you are different. Difference is easier to obtain if you emphasize attributes other than the ones already claimed by the leader.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Just because you want to gain market share does not mean it all has to come from the leader. Sometimes just creating clarity around something different will allow you to gain a disproportionate share of the people who don’t like the leader and are just looking for a rationale to pick someone else. And that could be enough market share to become very successful.
Sometimes I feel sorry for the American automakers. In their advertising, they always seem to find a need to tell the audience something to the effect that, “We are just like Honda and Toyota, only better.”
Of course, a statement like than brings up a number of questions:
1) The more you keep telling me that Toyota and Honda are the ideal benchmark for comparison, the more you are convincing me that they are the gold standard. Aren’t you then implying that the foreign car is the one I should really be desiring instead of the American car?
2) If you are just like them, how can you be better than them?
3) If Honda and Toyota are the ones you are trying to imitate, how can a copy become better than the original? At best, shouldn’t you only be able to achieve parity? And if you are trying to catch up with them, won’t you always be a step behind?
4) If you are better than them, then why do you have to sell your cars at a discount to a Honda or Toyota?
Apparently, I’m not the only one who has trouble with this logic, since Toyota just keeps getting stronger.
It’s sort of like a child on the playground saying, “I’m just as tall as the tall kids, only taller.” First, if you were really that tall, wouldn’t you be one of the “tall kids”? Second, if you are just like them, then how can you be taller?
THE ANALOGY
The point of most strategies is to find a way to gain market share. For your product or service to gain market share, someone else’s product has to lose market share. As a result, strategies tend to target the place where the most market share lies—with the market leader.
That is why American automobile brands tend to target Toyota and Honda—because that is where the market share is. The problem is not that others have the market share you want. The problem is in how you go after that share.
It is safe to assume that the market leaders got there for a reason. Therefore, many believe that if they can take that reason away from the leaders and attach that same reason to their brand, then they will become the leader. Hence the strategy of “I’m just like the leader, only better.”
The problem, as we have seen, is that it is difficult to win with that type of logic. Saying that “I’m just like the leader, only better” is not very convincing. That type of logic points the consumer to your competitor as the standard for what is good. Instead, it is better to discount the standard set by the leader by setting a different standard for what is good, and claim that for yourself.
THE PRINCIPLE
The principle here is the principle of comparison. To win market share, one must convince the customer that, when compared to the competition, you are superior in some meaningful way. As we have seen, it is difficult to create a sense of superiority for yourself if you use as your benchmark the factor which made the current leader successful. All you are doing is playing into their strength.
Over the years, I have learned two important facts:
1) BEFORE YOU CAN CONVINCE SOMEONE THAT YOU ARE SUPERIOR TO THE COMPETITION, YOU MUST FIRST CONVINCE THEM YOU ARE DIFFERENT FROM THE COMPETITION.
2) THE BEST WAY TO CONVINCE SOMEONE YOU ARE DIFFERENT IS TO EMPHASIZE A DIFFERENT SET OF ATTRIBUTES.
These are explained below.
1) Before you can convince someone that you are superior to the competition, you must first convince them you are different from the competition.
Claiming to be the same, but better is a hard sell, because it is impossible to be viewed as better if you are perceived as merely the same. This is especially true if another brand has already achieved ownership to that attribute in the minds of the customer.
To be better, one needs to be different. There is a specific order here. First you have to prove you are not the same—that you are different. Then, and only then, can you prove that the thing which makes you different is the thing that makes you better. This can be very convincing.
This is how Dawn won the dishwashing liquid war. Before Dawn, the standard upon which one rated a dishwashing liquid was on how clean it made the dishes. Dawn came to market by ignoring this. First, it claimed to have unique superiority in fighting grease. Since nobody else was making that claim, and since Dawn was pretty good at fighting grease, it won that argument. Then, Dawn tried to prove that grease fighting is the most important attribute for choosing a dishwashing liquid. It won enough people with that argument to win the entire dishwashing war.
2) The best way to convince someone you are different is to emphasize a different set of attributes.
It is hard to prove a difference to the competition if you are picking on the competition’s strength. First, there is less room to create a differential, since they are already good at it. Second, the consumers will always give the leader the benefit of the doubt on the attributes which gave them the leadership position.
Therefore, if you want to prove you are different, it is better to pick a new, unclaimed territory. Dawn did that with grease fighting.
Going back to the automobile industry, Chrysler was an also-ran in the truck business. Looking at the leaders (Ford and Chevy), Chrysler saw that they were trying to win with a rational appeal. They were emphasizing rational facts, like how much weight you could put in the truck bed, how much it could tow, how long they last, etc. Rather than try to compete in this rational space, Chrysler went for something entirely different—an emotional appeal.
Chrysler designed its trucks to look sexy in a testosterone sort of way. They were made to look like the big rigs—the semis. They even put an engine in them built by the company that makes semi engines. They made you feel like you were driving something special—that you were a big man on the road like a semi driver. The commercials emphasized the bragging rights to having a manly machine rather than to any rational features. This strategic approach boosted their market share more than anything else they had ever done in the truck space.
In the retail space, I remember when Wal-Mart was just starting to expand out of their southern US base. As they were moving east to the Carolinas, they were going to meet up with the local chain, called Rose’s. Rose’s decided that Wal-Mart was a leader based on certain things, so before Wal-Mart got to the Carolinas, Roses had converted its stores to look as much like a Wal-Mart as possible. They painted their stores with the same color scheme, put up signs that looked like Wal-Mart, displayed merchandise like Wal-Mart, and so on.
Unfortunately, when Wal-Mart came to town, people saw that one thing Rose’s could not copy was how low Wal-Mart’s prices were. Since it imitated everything else, Rose’s was seen as having no distinctive advantage—it was just a higher priced version of Wal-Mart. Rose’s soon disappeared as a company.
By contrast, Shopko tried a distinctively different tactic. While Wal-Mart was winning the battle of low everyday prices, Shopko decided to win the battle of having the best advertising deals—a high/low approach to pricing. It provided a distinct alternative in the marketplace. Shopko is still in existence today, more than 20 years after Wal-Mart entered their territory.
SUMMARY
Before you can convince someone you are superior, you must first convince them you are different. Difference is easier to obtain if you emphasize attributes other than the ones already claimed by the leader.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Just because you want to gain market share does not mean it all has to come from the leader. Sometimes just creating clarity around something different will allow you to gain a disproportionate share of the people who don’t like the leader and are just looking for a rationale to pick someone else. And that could be enough market share to become very successful.
Saturday, June 16, 2007
Mighty Canoes
THE STORY
From the late 1700s into the early 1800s, one of the most strategic locations in North America was the Straights of Mackinac. Located between the Upper and Lower Peninsulas of Michigan, this narrow waterway connects two of the great lakes—Lake Michigan and Lake Huron. It is also not very far from the mouth of Lake Superior. Whoever controlled the Straights of Mackinac controlled the lucrative fur trade, which brought great wealth to whomever was in charge.
To ensure control of the straights, a fort was built on Mackinac Island, located just to the east of the straights. For a time, the British controlled the fort, but after the American Revolutionary war of 1776, it was given to the Americans. The key feature of the fort was the wall of cannons on the south side. These cannons were strong and powerful—able to shoot cannon balls long distances towards attacking war ships, which would by necessity need to approach from the south.
This defensive wall of cannons gave the Americans so much confidence that there did not appear to be a great need to fortify the fort with many soldiers. Only about 60 were deemed necessary. After all, the ships would be blasted away by the cannons before reaching shore, so hand to hand combat seemed remote.
When the War of 1812 was declared, the British saw this as their opportunity to retake Fort Mackinac and regain control of the fur trade. Enlisting the help of their Native Indian allies and some of the fur trappers, the British used mostly canoes to quietly paddle their way to the north side of the island in the middle of the night. They dragged a small cannon onto shore and up the hill towards the fort.
At daybreak, the British fired a single warning shot from the cannon, awakening the American soldiers. The Americans found themselves in quite a predicament. First, their defensive cannons were on the wrong side of the fort. Second, even if they could quickly move them to the other side, they would be worthless, because the cannons were designed to shoot far out into the water, not down the side of the hill. Third, the Americans were well outnumbered by the British, the Indians and the trappers.
As a result, the American commander Porter Hanks surrendered the island to the British without firing a single shot.
THE ANALOGY
Be it armies or businesses, we all tend to fortify our defenses at the point where we believe we are most vulnerable to attack. In the case of the Straights of Mackinac, if an army of warships were to come, they would most likely come up through Lake Huron from the more populated areas to the south. Hence, the fort was built to defend that type of an attack. Thinking like an army, they assumed their primary enemy would be an army just like them—someone who would use warships.
Indians and trappers, however, do not have war ships. They use canoes. As the Indians and trappers were gathering in the region to join up with the British preparing for the attack, they did not appear to be a threat. Indians and trappers canoed through the area all the time. They were not soldiers.
Although a warship cannot attack Mackinac Island from the north, canoes can. Because the Americans were only prepared for a conventional attack by like-minded soldiers, they were unprepared for a northerly attack from what appeared to be harmless canoes. Instead, they turned out to be mighty canoes.
This same problem often happens in business. Our best laid strategic defenses turn out to be worthless because they prepare us for the wrong type of war.
THE PRINCIPLE
The problem here is that we tend to look in the wrong direction when it comes time to create a strategic defense. The problem is twofold:
1) Looking Backward Rather Than Forward
2) Looking Inward Rather than Outward
Each of these will be looked at separately and then shown how they worked together to hinder a recent battle in the business world.
1) Looking Backward Rather than Forward
There is a tendency to believe that the next strategic battle will be fought in a similar manner to the battles of the past. The expectation is that relatively similar weapons will be used and that relatively similar tactics will be used. Therefore, when preparing a defense, there is a tendency to prepare to do a better job against what we have seen in the past. In other words, our preparation makes us ready to win a war that is already over.
History is shown that each new major war is fought with a different type of weapon and a completely different set of tactics. These render defenses prepared for fighting wars the old way obsolete and relatively useless.
For example, after World War I, France spent a considerable amount of time and money preparing a strong defense against any future attack by Germany. It was designed under the assumption that Germany would attack the second time the same way they did the first time—with slow, protracted, stationary battles. France was confident that if Germany tried the WWI tactics again, they would fail against the French defense. However, in WWII, Germany used a new mobile “blitzkrieg” approach for which the French were not prepared. The French defense proved to be worthless.
The Americans at Fort Mackinac expected a warship attack, because that was the traditional approach of the past. They were not prepared for a new type of war using canoes.
Rather than looking backwards in time to find our inspiration for strategic defenses, we need to look forward and anticipate how the next battle might look, and how it will be different from past battles. That is why a key component of strategic planning involves spending time trying to envision potential future scenarios, to answer questions, like:
A. What the future environment will be like?
B. How consumer needs and desires will evolve?
C. What non-tradition opportunities and threats could crop up which better fit the future environment?
D. What will it take to win in that future world?
One thing we probably count on is the fact that what worked in the past will not work in the future. Therefore, we need to prepare ourselves for new types of battles with new types of tools. Just as the Americans at Mackinac should not have rested in the confidence that the big cannons would always protect them, businesses should not rest in the fact that the tools which worked for them in the past will always for them in the future.
2) Looking Inward Rather than Outward
The American soldiers made the mistake of thinking that their enemy would be a lot like them—professional soldiers trained to fight traditional battles. Instead, they got Indians and fur trappers. Businesses do the same thing in thinking that our enemies will be similar to us.
If you are the cola leader, like Coke, you may see the enemy as another cola, like Pepsi cola and prepare to win the cola wars. Instead, the new enemy is sports drinks, fortified beverages, energy drinks and the like. Pepsi caught on to seeing the potential new enemy as being a non-cola sooner than Coke and has reaped the benefits.
In many cases, the most potent enemy does not look like us at all. Rather than looking inward at our own narrowly defined industry to find enemies, we need to look outside our industry. Strategic thinking can help us find the new enemies lurking outside our traditional industry, ready to gobble up our market share.
Newspapers Vs. the Internet
For most of the second half of the 20th century, newspapers in the United States had a virtual monopoly in their home market. They were strong; they were powerful. They were confident that nobody was going to be able to start up a new newspaper that would cause any serious damage to their near-monopoly. Owing the local newspaper was like owning the big cannon, ready to take on anyone who wanted to build a rival newspaper.
Then, at the end of the 20th century, the internet started to get used by people other than scientists and researchers. To the powerful newspapers, the internet looked like little canoes going by—no big threat. After all, we’re in the newspaper business. The internet is not a newspaper…not even close. Who would ever place an ad on something like that?
Eventually, the internet became a very viable information source. It used new tactics that were foreign to the newspapers:
1) Fresh news available 24 hours a day.
2) Ability to interact with the news and other readers of the news real-time, using Web 2.0 technology
3) Customize the news so that you only get the news you wanted
4) Combine news from multiple sources
5) Make the news available for free
These young internet upstarts did not act like newspaper people. What’s the matter with them.
Well, now the newspapers are fighting for their lives against the digital world. Because they looked backwards to the past (this is how the news had been done and will always be done) and they looked inward at the newspaper industry (instead of looking outside for threats), they caught on to what was happening too late. The mighty canoes of the internet are winning the war.
SUMMARY
A good strategic defense needs to be based on looking forward (at what the new tactics for success will be) and outward (at players who are not a part of your traditional industry). Strategic planning is a process which helps one look forward and outward.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Of course, traditional internet players cannot sit back and think they’ve won the war any more than the newspapers before them. New threats, new tactics, new players will show up to threaten them as well. For example, will mobile phones change the rules so that the money is made at the carrier level instead of at the content level? Will users take over the content and leave out the internet content players? And so on…
From the late 1700s into the early 1800s, one of the most strategic locations in North America was the Straights of Mackinac. Located between the Upper and Lower Peninsulas of Michigan, this narrow waterway connects two of the great lakes—Lake Michigan and Lake Huron. It is also not very far from the mouth of Lake Superior. Whoever controlled the Straights of Mackinac controlled the lucrative fur trade, which brought great wealth to whomever was in charge.
To ensure control of the straights, a fort was built on Mackinac Island, located just to the east of the straights. For a time, the British controlled the fort, but after the American Revolutionary war of 1776, it was given to the Americans. The key feature of the fort was the wall of cannons on the south side. These cannons were strong and powerful—able to shoot cannon balls long distances towards attacking war ships, which would by necessity need to approach from the south.
This defensive wall of cannons gave the Americans so much confidence that there did not appear to be a great need to fortify the fort with many soldiers. Only about 60 were deemed necessary. After all, the ships would be blasted away by the cannons before reaching shore, so hand to hand combat seemed remote.
When the War of 1812 was declared, the British saw this as their opportunity to retake Fort Mackinac and regain control of the fur trade. Enlisting the help of their Native Indian allies and some of the fur trappers, the British used mostly canoes to quietly paddle their way to the north side of the island in the middle of the night. They dragged a small cannon onto shore and up the hill towards the fort.
At daybreak, the British fired a single warning shot from the cannon, awakening the American soldiers. The Americans found themselves in quite a predicament. First, their defensive cannons were on the wrong side of the fort. Second, even if they could quickly move them to the other side, they would be worthless, because the cannons were designed to shoot far out into the water, not down the side of the hill. Third, the Americans were well outnumbered by the British, the Indians and the trappers.
As a result, the American commander Porter Hanks surrendered the island to the British without firing a single shot.
THE ANALOGY
Be it armies or businesses, we all tend to fortify our defenses at the point where we believe we are most vulnerable to attack. In the case of the Straights of Mackinac, if an army of warships were to come, they would most likely come up through Lake Huron from the more populated areas to the south. Hence, the fort was built to defend that type of an attack. Thinking like an army, they assumed their primary enemy would be an army just like them—someone who would use warships.
Indians and trappers, however, do not have war ships. They use canoes. As the Indians and trappers were gathering in the region to join up with the British preparing for the attack, they did not appear to be a threat. Indians and trappers canoed through the area all the time. They were not soldiers.
Although a warship cannot attack Mackinac Island from the north, canoes can. Because the Americans were only prepared for a conventional attack by like-minded soldiers, they were unprepared for a northerly attack from what appeared to be harmless canoes. Instead, they turned out to be mighty canoes.
This same problem often happens in business. Our best laid strategic defenses turn out to be worthless because they prepare us for the wrong type of war.
THE PRINCIPLE
The problem here is that we tend to look in the wrong direction when it comes time to create a strategic defense. The problem is twofold:
1) Looking Backward Rather Than Forward
2) Looking Inward Rather than Outward
Each of these will be looked at separately and then shown how they worked together to hinder a recent battle in the business world.
1) Looking Backward Rather than Forward
There is a tendency to believe that the next strategic battle will be fought in a similar manner to the battles of the past. The expectation is that relatively similar weapons will be used and that relatively similar tactics will be used. Therefore, when preparing a defense, there is a tendency to prepare to do a better job against what we have seen in the past. In other words, our preparation makes us ready to win a war that is already over.
History is shown that each new major war is fought with a different type of weapon and a completely different set of tactics. These render defenses prepared for fighting wars the old way obsolete and relatively useless.
For example, after World War I, France spent a considerable amount of time and money preparing a strong defense against any future attack by Germany. It was designed under the assumption that Germany would attack the second time the same way they did the first time—with slow, protracted, stationary battles. France was confident that if Germany tried the WWI tactics again, they would fail against the French defense. However, in WWII, Germany used a new mobile “blitzkrieg” approach for which the French were not prepared. The French defense proved to be worthless.
The Americans at Fort Mackinac expected a warship attack, because that was the traditional approach of the past. They were not prepared for a new type of war using canoes.
Rather than looking backwards in time to find our inspiration for strategic defenses, we need to look forward and anticipate how the next battle might look, and how it will be different from past battles. That is why a key component of strategic planning involves spending time trying to envision potential future scenarios, to answer questions, like:
A. What the future environment will be like?
B. How consumer needs and desires will evolve?
C. What non-tradition opportunities and threats could crop up which better fit the future environment?
D. What will it take to win in that future world?
One thing we probably count on is the fact that what worked in the past will not work in the future. Therefore, we need to prepare ourselves for new types of battles with new types of tools. Just as the Americans at Mackinac should not have rested in the confidence that the big cannons would always protect them, businesses should not rest in the fact that the tools which worked for them in the past will always for them in the future.
2) Looking Inward Rather than Outward
The American soldiers made the mistake of thinking that their enemy would be a lot like them—professional soldiers trained to fight traditional battles. Instead, they got Indians and fur trappers. Businesses do the same thing in thinking that our enemies will be similar to us.
If you are the cola leader, like Coke, you may see the enemy as another cola, like Pepsi cola and prepare to win the cola wars. Instead, the new enemy is sports drinks, fortified beverages, energy drinks and the like. Pepsi caught on to seeing the potential new enemy as being a non-cola sooner than Coke and has reaped the benefits.
In many cases, the most potent enemy does not look like us at all. Rather than looking inward at our own narrowly defined industry to find enemies, we need to look outside our industry. Strategic thinking can help us find the new enemies lurking outside our traditional industry, ready to gobble up our market share.
Newspapers Vs. the Internet
For most of the second half of the 20th century, newspapers in the United States had a virtual monopoly in their home market. They were strong; they were powerful. They were confident that nobody was going to be able to start up a new newspaper that would cause any serious damage to their near-monopoly. Owing the local newspaper was like owning the big cannon, ready to take on anyone who wanted to build a rival newspaper.
Then, at the end of the 20th century, the internet started to get used by people other than scientists and researchers. To the powerful newspapers, the internet looked like little canoes going by—no big threat. After all, we’re in the newspaper business. The internet is not a newspaper…not even close. Who would ever place an ad on something like that?
Eventually, the internet became a very viable information source. It used new tactics that were foreign to the newspapers:
1) Fresh news available 24 hours a day.
2) Ability to interact with the news and other readers of the news real-time, using Web 2.0 technology
3) Customize the news so that you only get the news you wanted
4) Combine news from multiple sources
5) Make the news available for free
These young internet upstarts did not act like newspaper people. What’s the matter with them.
Well, now the newspapers are fighting for their lives against the digital world. Because they looked backwards to the past (this is how the news had been done and will always be done) and they looked inward at the newspaper industry (instead of looking outside for threats), they caught on to what was happening too late. The mighty canoes of the internet are winning the war.
SUMMARY
A good strategic defense needs to be based on looking forward (at what the new tactics for success will be) and outward (at players who are not a part of your traditional industry). Strategic planning is a process which helps one look forward and outward.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Of course, traditional internet players cannot sit back and think they’ve won the war any more than the newspapers before them. New threats, new tactics, new players will show up to threaten them as well. For example, will mobile phones change the rules so that the money is made at the carrier level instead of at the content level? Will users take over the content and leave out the internet content players? And so on…
Thursday, June 14, 2007
Cutting Your Way to Prosperity? (part 3)
THE STORY
Once there was a farmer who thought he had come up with the secret formula for living the good life. When he was young, this farmer had noticed how so many other farmers were struggling to make ends meet. Not wanting to live that way, this young farmer’s goal was to live well by farming differently.
Therefore, the young farmer spent time investigating what other farmer’s were doing, to find out why they were having trouble making ends meet. After a thorough analysis, he came to his conclusion: Farmer’s do not live well, because they foolishly waste their money. He saw many ways in which farmers were wasting their money:
1) They would let portions of their land lay fallow each year rather than plant something they could make money off of.
2) They put all kinds of money into fertilization and irrigation. Why spend all that money on something Mother Nature supplies for free? (rainwater and fertile soil)
3) They would waste money buying expensive seeds when they could just get seeds for free off of part of the prior year’s crop.
So the young farmer put his plan into action. He planted his entire land every year. He would use “free” seeds from what was produced in last year’s crop. He cut way back on irrigation and fertilization, relying on the “free” resources of Mother Nature.
At first, this plan seemed to work quite well. The money he saved on irrigation, fertilization, and seeds was used to live the good life—a nice home, nice car, luxury lifestyle. He was proud that he had “beaten the system” and could live well on the farm. Over time, however, the plan seemed less successful—every year the fields supplied less and less produce. Eventually, it got so bad that eventually the farmer had to declare bankruptcy.
THE ANALOGY
The farmer in the story failed because he had a tragic flaw in his logic. He assumed that the farmland would continue to produce at peak performance forever without replenishing the soil. Yes, Mother Nature may have gotten him started out with good soil, but if you do not replenish the soil through fertilizer, irrigation, and letting it lay fallow, it will eventually become depleted—unable to produce crops. Weak crops do not produce the kinds of seeds which create healthy crops the following year—and are nowhere near as effective as specially grown hybrid seeds.
The farmer’s success was an illusion. What he thought was high profits from current operations was actually stealing the profits from future crops by failing to reinvest in the soil. These were not extra profits—they were the costs of doing business which he was refusing to pay. By not paying the price of reinvestment into the soil, he was destroying his own future.
Does it sound silly that a farmer would not be smart enough to take care of his soil? Well, I’ve seen otherwise smart business people destroy their future by not reinvesting in their businesses. Yes, it is wise to not be extravagant in your business spending. Keeping costs low can be a good thing, especially during the tough times. But a continual effort to starve a business of investment, even during the good times, can cause a business to have the same fate as this farmer.
THE PRINCIPLE
This is the third and final blog in a series on the pitfalls of cost-cutting. In the first blog, “part 1”, we looked at how some cuts are really not cuts at all, but are rather just shifting of costs from one location in the company to another. In “part 2” we looked at the problems that can occur when cost-cutting is done without being connected to strategy. In this third blog, we will look at what happens when extreme cost-cutting becomes the norm, even in good times.
Extreme cost-cutting means not reinvesting into the future cash flow streams of the company and instead taking the money out as today’s extra profits. It may make you look like a genius today, but in the long run it depletes the business of what it needs to produce future profits. Businesses are like soil, they need to be replenished.
The temptation to take the money out rather than reinvest seems greater today, with top executives spending ever less time in their position. If the leaders only expect to be hold the position for a couple of years, why worry so much about the long term? In the world of marketing, the average CMO lasts less than two years in a job. Often times, as in the recent case at Macy’s, the rapid change in CMOs is a result of a conflict between near-term sales promotion and long-term brand building. The CMOs trying to invest in the long-term strength of the brand are losing favor to leaders trying to take the profits out now.
There are three main reasons why reinvestment is crucial to long-term success:
1) Things Wear Out
2) Customers are Fickle
3) Technology Improves
These are discussed below.
1) Things Wear Out
Cutting back on repairs and maintenance may work for a short period of time, but eventually, lack of repairs and maintenance will cause thinks to break down. There is an old Fram auto parts advertising campaign where a mechanic would say “Pay me now or pay me later.” The implication was that you could spend a few dollars now on a Fram oil filter or put it off until your engine breaks down and then pay hundreds and hundreds of dollars on engine repair.
This principle may seem obvious for equipment and machinery. However, other things can also wear out if money is not put into them. For example, in retailing, shopping centers and entire neighborhoods can wear out and become tired. It may become necessary to spend the money to move a store a few miles to a more vibrant neighborhood, even though the store itself may still be in relatively good condition.
Strategies themselves can wear out overtime and become less relevant in a changing environment. With the current movement to green environmentalism, an old formerly successful strategy viewed now as environmentally wasteful could severely damage a company. It is better to invest time and money in strategic thinking on a continual basis to stay in front of these changes, rather than waiting until it is too late to efficiently react.
2) Customers Are Fickle
Even if everything in your business is in fine working order, it does not mean that there is no need to reinvest. Customers are fickle. Loyalty is weak. Just being in fine working order may not be enough if competition is investing in the latest and the newest gizmos and gadgets. Shiny new things from the competition can catch the eye of your consumers and make you look dull and drab by comparison, even if there is nothing inherently wrong or broken in your process.
The goal is not to be serviceable. The goal is to be superior (in some way versus competition). Superiority is a relative term. Today’s exciting superiority can fall behind competition if they invest at a faster rate than you do.
3) Technology Improves
Even if your investment is in fine working order, that does not ensure top performance. For example, you may have the absolute best computer operating system available in the 1980s (which is when you purchased it) and you may have kept it in fine working order all these years. However, there have been so many technological advances since the 1980s that you would be woefully uncompetitive in the marketplace versus significantly more efficient competitors who are using the power of more up-to-date computer technology.
It could even be more subtle than this. In retailing, one could have perfectly serviceable cash registers which do a good job of scanning the price tag and letting the customer pay you. However, modern cash registers (which are now called Point of Sale computer terminals), can do so much more—capture customer data, process credit cards faster, allow more sophisticated pricing programs, suggest add-on selling opportunities, handle customer loyalty programs, and so on. By not investing in the new terminals, one is missing out on opportunities and falling behind those that do make those investments.
SUMMARY
Continual aggressive cost cutting may be seen by some as being efficient, but it does not necessarily mean that you are effective. By not reinvesting in your business on a regular basis, you can deplete it of its ability to produce revenue in the future.
FINAL THOUGHTS
The biggest problem with chronic underinvestment is that by the time one can see the problem, it is often too late to fix it. The soil of the business is too depleted. Too much time and money would be needed to bring it back to life. And you don’t have the money, because you took it out in extra profits. And without new income coming in, you do not have the time to wait until the soil is brought back to life.
Once there was a farmer who thought he had come up with the secret formula for living the good life. When he was young, this farmer had noticed how so many other farmers were struggling to make ends meet. Not wanting to live that way, this young farmer’s goal was to live well by farming differently.
Therefore, the young farmer spent time investigating what other farmer’s were doing, to find out why they were having trouble making ends meet. After a thorough analysis, he came to his conclusion: Farmer’s do not live well, because they foolishly waste their money. He saw many ways in which farmers were wasting their money:
1) They would let portions of their land lay fallow each year rather than plant something they could make money off of.
2) They put all kinds of money into fertilization and irrigation. Why spend all that money on something Mother Nature supplies for free? (rainwater and fertile soil)
3) They would waste money buying expensive seeds when they could just get seeds for free off of part of the prior year’s crop.
So the young farmer put his plan into action. He planted his entire land every year. He would use “free” seeds from what was produced in last year’s crop. He cut way back on irrigation and fertilization, relying on the “free” resources of Mother Nature.
At first, this plan seemed to work quite well. The money he saved on irrigation, fertilization, and seeds was used to live the good life—a nice home, nice car, luxury lifestyle. He was proud that he had “beaten the system” and could live well on the farm. Over time, however, the plan seemed less successful—every year the fields supplied less and less produce. Eventually, it got so bad that eventually the farmer had to declare bankruptcy.
THE ANALOGY
The farmer in the story failed because he had a tragic flaw in his logic. He assumed that the farmland would continue to produce at peak performance forever without replenishing the soil. Yes, Mother Nature may have gotten him started out with good soil, but if you do not replenish the soil through fertilizer, irrigation, and letting it lay fallow, it will eventually become depleted—unable to produce crops. Weak crops do not produce the kinds of seeds which create healthy crops the following year—and are nowhere near as effective as specially grown hybrid seeds.
The farmer’s success was an illusion. What he thought was high profits from current operations was actually stealing the profits from future crops by failing to reinvest in the soil. These were not extra profits—they were the costs of doing business which he was refusing to pay. By not paying the price of reinvestment into the soil, he was destroying his own future.
Does it sound silly that a farmer would not be smart enough to take care of his soil? Well, I’ve seen otherwise smart business people destroy their future by not reinvesting in their businesses. Yes, it is wise to not be extravagant in your business spending. Keeping costs low can be a good thing, especially during the tough times. But a continual effort to starve a business of investment, even during the good times, can cause a business to have the same fate as this farmer.
THE PRINCIPLE
This is the third and final blog in a series on the pitfalls of cost-cutting. In the first blog, “part 1”, we looked at how some cuts are really not cuts at all, but are rather just shifting of costs from one location in the company to another. In “part 2” we looked at the problems that can occur when cost-cutting is done without being connected to strategy. In this third blog, we will look at what happens when extreme cost-cutting becomes the norm, even in good times.
Extreme cost-cutting means not reinvesting into the future cash flow streams of the company and instead taking the money out as today’s extra profits. It may make you look like a genius today, but in the long run it depletes the business of what it needs to produce future profits. Businesses are like soil, they need to be replenished.
The temptation to take the money out rather than reinvest seems greater today, with top executives spending ever less time in their position. If the leaders only expect to be hold the position for a couple of years, why worry so much about the long term? In the world of marketing, the average CMO lasts less than two years in a job. Often times, as in the recent case at Macy’s, the rapid change in CMOs is a result of a conflict between near-term sales promotion and long-term brand building. The CMOs trying to invest in the long-term strength of the brand are losing favor to leaders trying to take the profits out now.
There are three main reasons why reinvestment is crucial to long-term success:
1) Things Wear Out
2) Customers are Fickle
3) Technology Improves
These are discussed below.
1) Things Wear Out
Cutting back on repairs and maintenance may work for a short period of time, but eventually, lack of repairs and maintenance will cause thinks to break down. There is an old Fram auto parts advertising campaign where a mechanic would say “Pay me now or pay me later.” The implication was that you could spend a few dollars now on a Fram oil filter or put it off until your engine breaks down and then pay hundreds and hundreds of dollars on engine repair.
This principle may seem obvious for equipment and machinery. However, other things can also wear out if money is not put into them. For example, in retailing, shopping centers and entire neighborhoods can wear out and become tired. It may become necessary to spend the money to move a store a few miles to a more vibrant neighborhood, even though the store itself may still be in relatively good condition.
Strategies themselves can wear out overtime and become less relevant in a changing environment. With the current movement to green environmentalism, an old formerly successful strategy viewed now as environmentally wasteful could severely damage a company. It is better to invest time and money in strategic thinking on a continual basis to stay in front of these changes, rather than waiting until it is too late to efficiently react.
2) Customers Are Fickle
Even if everything in your business is in fine working order, it does not mean that there is no need to reinvest. Customers are fickle. Loyalty is weak. Just being in fine working order may not be enough if competition is investing in the latest and the newest gizmos and gadgets. Shiny new things from the competition can catch the eye of your consumers and make you look dull and drab by comparison, even if there is nothing inherently wrong or broken in your process.
The goal is not to be serviceable. The goal is to be superior (in some way versus competition). Superiority is a relative term. Today’s exciting superiority can fall behind competition if they invest at a faster rate than you do.
3) Technology Improves
Even if your investment is in fine working order, that does not ensure top performance. For example, you may have the absolute best computer operating system available in the 1980s (which is when you purchased it) and you may have kept it in fine working order all these years. However, there have been so many technological advances since the 1980s that you would be woefully uncompetitive in the marketplace versus significantly more efficient competitors who are using the power of more up-to-date computer technology.
It could even be more subtle than this. In retailing, one could have perfectly serviceable cash registers which do a good job of scanning the price tag and letting the customer pay you. However, modern cash registers (which are now called Point of Sale computer terminals), can do so much more—capture customer data, process credit cards faster, allow more sophisticated pricing programs, suggest add-on selling opportunities, handle customer loyalty programs, and so on. By not investing in the new terminals, one is missing out on opportunities and falling behind those that do make those investments.
SUMMARY
Continual aggressive cost cutting may be seen by some as being efficient, but it does not necessarily mean that you are effective. By not reinvesting in your business on a regular basis, you can deplete it of its ability to produce revenue in the future.
FINAL THOUGHTS
The biggest problem with chronic underinvestment is that by the time one can see the problem, it is often too late to fix it. The soil of the business is too depleted. Too much time and money would be needed to bring it back to life. And you don’t have the money, because you took it out in extra profits. And without new income coming in, you do not have the time to wait until the soil is brought back to life.
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Cutting Your Way to Prosperity? (part 2)
THE STORY
One of my favorite comic strips of all time was Pogo, by the late Walt Kelly. In one of his comic strips, Albert the Alligator was running as fast as he could through the swamp. Pogo the ‘possum was desparately trying to keep up with the pace. While they were still running, Pogo asked Albert where he was going. Albert answered something to the effect that he didn’t really have a particular destination in mind. In response, Pogo replied, “If you don’t know where you are going, then why are you running so fast to get there?”
This story is not that dissimilar to what happened to Alice in Wonderland. Alice was confused, so she asked the Cheshire cat which way she should go. The Cheshire cat asked Alice where she was trying to get to. Alice said that she didn’t know. In response, the Cheshire cat said that if you don’t know where you are going, then it really doesn’t matter which path you take.
THE ANALOGY
Strategic planning is all about finding the right destination for your business and the right path (journey) to get you to your destination. Both are necessary ingredients to success. A goal without a means to get there is worthless. Similarly, tactics which lead nowhere are also worthless.
Sometimes, we can fall into the trap that captured both Albert the Alligator and Alice in Wonderland—disconnecting the journey from the destination. Albert was so intent on making progress on the path that he failed to take the time to choose a destination. A lot of activity and movement was enough to make him happy. And as Pogo pointed out, if the journey has no purpose, striving to do it faster or more efficiently does little, if any good.
Alice had a similar problem. She was so intent on leaving her current situation that she failed to take time to determine a better location. She was seeking guidance on which path to take to move away from a position she did not like. And as the wise cat responded, if you have not planned your destination, then it really doesn’t matter what you do or where you go.
Although it may seem silly to think that a business would be as foolish as Albert or Alice, it does happen. During the dot com boom, people were saying that choosing a destination is obsolete. All you need to do is race like Albert to get to the next “killer application” before someone else. Some of those dot com “geniuses” don’t look so smart anymore.
Another time when leaders are tempted to disconnect action from destination is during tough times. When tough times hit, there is pressure to make a lot of cuts in order to make it through until good times return. These cuts can be across the board, regardless of any strategic concern. Like Alice they are looking at avoiding the current bad situation rather than seeking out a better situation. The analogy I hear often goes something like this:
“I don’t have time to worry about fancy things like strategy and positioning. My patient is dying. I’ll worry about that luxury later. Right now I have to focus on stopping the bleeding.” And, of course, stopping the bleeding means stopping the flow of red ink by cutting costs as much as one can (and without thought as to how it will impact the strategy). However, if you do not know what is wrong with the patient and how to cure the underlying problem, stopping the bleeding will not ultimately solve the problem.
THE PRINCIPLE
This blog is the second in a series on avoiding pitfalls when in a cost-cutting mode. In the prior blog (see “Cutting Your Way to Prosperity (part 1)”), we looked at the pitfall of when cuts are really not cuts, but rather just a shifting of costs from one location to another. In today’s blog, we are looking at what happens when cost cutting is done without concern for its impact on reaching a strategic destination.
Three principles should be considered when making cuts to ensure that it doesn’t get disconnected from strategy:
1) Prioritization
2) Process
3) Preemption
These are covered in more detail below.
1) Prioritization
Across the board cuts can not only cut the fat in your business, but also the meat. I recall two discount store chains that cut their merchandise buying across the board. Unfortunately, not all merchandise sells at the same rate. Fast turning items like health & beauty care, household chemicals or candy sell through much faster than clothing. In one store, the only thing consumable item left in stock after inventory cuts was 2001 flushes, so that’s what an entire aisle was filled with. In another store, I saw more than three aisles filled with just one item—red licorice rope. I doubt if this left a good impression on the customer who was looking for the items which used to be on those shelves. Sometimes, you have to cut things differently, due to their different characteristics.
Rather than cut everything equally, one needs to make priorities. In general, areas that are most near and dear to one’s competitive advantage need to be cut the least. You’ve worked hard to build that reputation. Don’t give it all away at the first sign of panic.
Areas that are least crucial to your strategy should take the brunt of the cuts. Of course, this assumes that:
A. The people doing the cutting understand the strategic priorities of the company and what is most crucial to success; and
B. They understand how various cuts might impact the ability to continue down the path to one’s strategic goal.
Before making a cut, first ask yourself:
- Will there be a noticeable difference to my customers, enough to turn them away?
- Will this cut change the nature of who I am, to the point that I have inadvertently changed my strategy without knowing it? For example, if your historical strategy hinges on being known for superior service, and you cut the life out of your people providing the service, then you have really changed your strategy to no longer be about service.
2) Process
It takes a certain amount of input (people, money, equipment) to get a job done in a particular way. If you cut back on one or more of these inputs and do not change the expectations of the way a process gets done, you may be courting disaster by guaranteeing failure, since the same process cannot be done with the lower input. Decisions about cuts in inputs should not be divorced from decisions about the process creating the outputs.
Two types of process decisions can be made. First one can look at the various tradeoffs involved in cutting the inputs. For example, it you need to cut back on your service one can choose a tradeoff between speed and quality—either keep the quality and make it take longer to get the service, or keep the speed, but lower the quality. Depending on your strategy, one tradeoff may be better than the other. Hence, you alter your process based on which tradeoff you want to make. Making such a tradeoff is usually better than cutting back both quality and speed.
The second type of process decision may be to change the process to best fit the cut in inputs. For example, let’s say that the advertising budget gets cut. Since the original process cannot be achieved on the lower budget, maybe it’s time to do things differently, like maybe switch from TV advertising to radio, or move from mass-oriented advertising to just advertising to a narrow niche…or cluster fewer ad dollars into less frequent, but bigger bursts, instead of dribbling it evenly throughout the year.
Again, it is easier to know how to alter the process if you know your strategic direction, because it will help direct which alternative processes are most in tune with your strategic direction and destination.
Preemption:
Sometimes tough times are caused more by our own lack of strategic direction than by any outside forces. To quote from Pogo again, you may be in a situation where, “We have met the enemy, and he is us.” If your strategy is weak, you are more vulnerable to competitive onslaughts and economic downturns. Conversely, if your strategy is strong, you may be able to weather an economic downturn without much difficulty. You may not even have to cut much at all, because the strength of your strategy will carry you through.
The plummet in prices on digital TVs is hurting all the consumer electronics retailers with weak positions. Circuit City has been furiously trying to cut costs. Tweeter this week filed chapter 11. Best Buy, however, is still going strong due to its years of building a strong strategic position.
In other words, the best way to deal with price cuts is to avoid them completely by creating such a strong strategy that you are less vulnerable to downturns. This would be preempting cuts via strategic forethought.
SUMMARY
During tough times or economic downturns, there can be a tendency to forget strategy and just rush to cut costs. Spending a little time first thinking about strategic implications can make cost cutting far more productive, and may even eliminate the need to make the cuts in the first place.
FINAL THOUGHTS
The best time to prepare for the tough times is when you are still in the good times. During the good times, you have the luxury of time to figure out your strategy and what is really critical to its success (the destination and the path). As a result, instead of acting irrationally or emotionally in panic when the bad times come, you can calmly go back to what you learned in the good times and do what makes sense both near term and long term.
One of my favorite comic strips of all time was Pogo, by the late Walt Kelly. In one of his comic strips, Albert the Alligator was running as fast as he could through the swamp. Pogo the ‘possum was desparately trying to keep up with the pace. While they were still running, Pogo asked Albert where he was going. Albert answered something to the effect that he didn’t really have a particular destination in mind. In response, Pogo replied, “If you don’t know where you are going, then why are you running so fast to get there?”
This story is not that dissimilar to what happened to Alice in Wonderland. Alice was confused, so she asked the Cheshire cat which way she should go. The Cheshire cat asked Alice where she was trying to get to. Alice said that she didn’t know. In response, the Cheshire cat said that if you don’t know where you are going, then it really doesn’t matter which path you take.
THE ANALOGY
Strategic planning is all about finding the right destination for your business and the right path (journey) to get you to your destination. Both are necessary ingredients to success. A goal without a means to get there is worthless. Similarly, tactics which lead nowhere are also worthless.
Sometimes, we can fall into the trap that captured both Albert the Alligator and Alice in Wonderland—disconnecting the journey from the destination. Albert was so intent on making progress on the path that he failed to take the time to choose a destination. A lot of activity and movement was enough to make him happy. And as Pogo pointed out, if the journey has no purpose, striving to do it faster or more efficiently does little, if any good.
Alice had a similar problem. She was so intent on leaving her current situation that she failed to take time to determine a better location. She was seeking guidance on which path to take to move away from a position she did not like. And as the wise cat responded, if you have not planned your destination, then it really doesn’t matter what you do or where you go.
Although it may seem silly to think that a business would be as foolish as Albert or Alice, it does happen. During the dot com boom, people were saying that choosing a destination is obsolete. All you need to do is race like Albert to get to the next “killer application” before someone else. Some of those dot com “geniuses” don’t look so smart anymore.
Another time when leaders are tempted to disconnect action from destination is during tough times. When tough times hit, there is pressure to make a lot of cuts in order to make it through until good times return. These cuts can be across the board, regardless of any strategic concern. Like Alice they are looking at avoiding the current bad situation rather than seeking out a better situation. The analogy I hear often goes something like this:
“I don’t have time to worry about fancy things like strategy and positioning. My patient is dying. I’ll worry about that luxury later. Right now I have to focus on stopping the bleeding.” And, of course, stopping the bleeding means stopping the flow of red ink by cutting costs as much as one can (and without thought as to how it will impact the strategy). However, if you do not know what is wrong with the patient and how to cure the underlying problem, stopping the bleeding will not ultimately solve the problem.
THE PRINCIPLE
This blog is the second in a series on avoiding pitfalls when in a cost-cutting mode. In the prior blog (see “Cutting Your Way to Prosperity (part 1)”), we looked at the pitfall of when cuts are really not cuts, but rather just a shifting of costs from one location to another. In today’s blog, we are looking at what happens when cost cutting is done without concern for its impact on reaching a strategic destination.
Three principles should be considered when making cuts to ensure that it doesn’t get disconnected from strategy:
1) Prioritization
2) Process
3) Preemption
These are covered in more detail below.
1) Prioritization
Across the board cuts can not only cut the fat in your business, but also the meat. I recall two discount store chains that cut their merchandise buying across the board. Unfortunately, not all merchandise sells at the same rate. Fast turning items like health & beauty care, household chemicals or candy sell through much faster than clothing. In one store, the only thing consumable item left in stock after inventory cuts was 2001 flushes, so that’s what an entire aisle was filled with. In another store, I saw more than three aisles filled with just one item—red licorice rope. I doubt if this left a good impression on the customer who was looking for the items which used to be on those shelves. Sometimes, you have to cut things differently, due to their different characteristics.
Rather than cut everything equally, one needs to make priorities. In general, areas that are most near and dear to one’s competitive advantage need to be cut the least. You’ve worked hard to build that reputation. Don’t give it all away at the first sign of panic.
Areas that are least crucial to your strategy should take the brunt of the cuts. Of course, this assumes that:
A. The people doing the cutting understand the strategic priorities of the company and what is most crucial to success; and
B. They understand how various cuts might impact the ability to continue down the path to one’s strategic goal.
Before making a cut, first ask yourself:
- Will there be a noticeable difference to my customers, enough to turn them away?
- Will this cut change the nature of who I am, to the point that I have inadvertently changed my strategy without knowing it? For example, if your historical strategy hinges on being known for superior service, and you cut the life out of your people providing the service, then you have really changed your strategy to no longer be about service.
2) Process
It takes a certain amount of input (people, money, equipment) to get a job done in a particular way. If you cut back on one or more of these inputs and do not change the expectations of the way a process gets done, you may be courting disaster by guaranteeing failure, since the same process cannot be done with the lower input. Decisions about cuts in inputs should not be divorced from decisions about the process creating the outputs.
Two types of process decisions can be made. First one can look at the various tradeoffs involved in cutting the inputs. For example, it you need to cut back on your service one can choose a tradeoff between speed and quality—either keep the quality and make it take longer to get the service, or keep the speed, but lower the quality. Depending on your strategy, one tradeoff may be better than the other. Hence, you alter your process based on which tradeoff you want to make. Making such a tradeoff is usually better than cutting back both quality and speed.
The second type of process decision may be to change the process to best fit the cut in inputs. For example, let’s say that the advertising budget gets cut. Since the original process cannot be achieved on the lower budget, maybe it’s time to do things differently, like maybe switch from TV advertising to radio, or move from mass-oriented advertising to just advertising to a narrow niche…or cluster fewer ad dollars into less frequent, but bigger bursts, instead of dribbling it evenly throughout the year.
Again, it is easier to know how to alter the process if you know your strategic direction, because it will help direct which alternative processes are most in tune with your strategic direction and destination.
Preemption:
Sometimes tough times are caused more by our own lack of strategic direction than by any outside forces. To quote from Pogo again, you may be in a situation where, “We have met the enemy, and he is us.” If your strategy is weak, you are more vulnerable to competitive onslaughts and economic downturns. Conversely, if your strategy is strong, you may be able to weather an economic downturn without much difficulty. You may not even have to cut much at all, because the strength of your strategy will carry you through.
The plummet in prices on digital TVs is hurting all the consumer electronics retailers with weak positions. Circuit City has been furiously trying to cut costs. Tweeter this week filed chapter 11. Best Buy, however, is still going strong due to its years of building a strong strategic position.
In other words, the best way to deal with price cuts is to avoid them completely by creating such a strong strategy that you are less vulnerable to downturns. This would be preempting cuts via strategic forethought.
SUMMARY
During tough times or economic downturns, there can be a tendency to forget strategy and just rush to cut costs. Spending a little time first thinking about strategic implications can make cost cutting far more productive, and may even eliminate the need to make the cuts in the first place.
FINAL THOUGHTS
The best time to prepare for the tough times is when you are still in the good times. During the good times, you have the luxury of time to figure out your strategy and what is really critical to its success (the destination and the path). As a result, instead of acting irrationally or emotionally in panic when the bad times come, you can calmly go back to what you learned in the good times and do what makes sense both near term and long term.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)